1. Home
  2. History
  3. Chandrayaan-3
History

Chandrayaan-3: How India Reached the Moon, From a Church in Thumba to the Shiv Shakti Point

At 6:04 pm on 23 August 2023, a lander named after Vikram Sarabhai set itself down on the Moon, farther south than any before it. The road there began in a fishing village church in 1963 and ran through a satellite built in a shed, water found on the Moon and a crash in 2019. Here is the whole story: what it found, what it cost, who was left unpaid, and why ‘south pole’ is still argued over.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 20 min read WhatsApp

Chandrayaan-3: How India Reached the Moon, From a Church in Thumba to the Shiv Shakti Point
Photo: ISRO/Simeon Schmauß · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • India’s space story began on 21 November 1963, when a borrowed American rocket went up from a church at Thumba, Kerala. Vikram Sarabhai led it, saying India had no ‘fantasy’ of racing to the Moon.
  • Aryabhata, built in sheds at Peenya, became India’s first satellite in 1975. Chandrayaan-1 reached the Moon in 2008, and NASA’s instrument on board found signs of water.
  • Chandrayaan-2’s lander crashed on 7 September 2019, about 2 km above the surface. Its failure report was never made public.
  • Chandrayaan-3 landed on 23 August 2023 at about 69.4 degrees south, four days after Russia’s Luna-25 crashed. Pragyan confirmed sulphur, and Vikram hopped 40 cm.
  • It cost about Rs 615 crore. Critics point to the stretched ‘south pole’ claim, the secret 2019 report, and unpaid workers at HEC in Ranchi. Gaganyaan and Chandrayaan-4 are still plans.

At a glance

1963–2023
Landing
23 August 2023, 6:04 pm IST. Launched 14 July 2023 on an LVM3 rocket from Sriharikota
Where
Statio Shiv Shakti, about 69.37°S, 32.32°E, about 600 km from the Moon’s south pole (NASA)
Craft
Vikram lander, 1,726 kg; Pragyan rover, 26 kg; propulsion module, 2,148 kg
Firsts
India became the fourth country to soft-land on the Moon, and the first to land this far south
Found
Sulphur confirmed on the spot; surface at about 70°C; a possible moonquake; signs of an ancient magma ocean
Cost
About Rs 615 crore (former ISRO chief K. Sivan). Luna-25: at least 12.6 billion roubles
Before it
Thumba rocket 1963; Aryabhata 1975; Chandrayaan-1 2008; Chandrayaan-2 lander crash, 7 September 2019
Next (plans)
Gaganyaan G1 uncrewed test, aimed at late 2026; Chandrayaan-4 sample return, about 2028
In this story · 20 parts
  1. 23 Aug 2023Nineteen minutes above the Moon
  2. Part 2Who’s who
  3. 21 Nov 1963A rocket in a church, 1963
  4. 30 Dec 1971The man who said no to the Moon
  5. 19 Apr 1975A satellite from a shed, 1975
  6. 22 Oct 2008A flag on the Moon, 2008
  7. 24 Sep 2009The water nobody expected
  8. 7 Sep 2019Two kilometres short, 2019
  9. 14 Jul 2023Built for everything to go wrong
  10. 19 Aug 2023A Russian crash, four days before
  11. 23 Aug 2023A country at its screens
  12. 29 Aug 2023Fourteen days of sunlight
  13. 3 Sep 2023The hop
  14. 26 Aug 2023Shiv Shakti and Tiranga
  15. 2023What did it cost?
  16. Sep 2023Was it really the south pole?
  17. 2025–2040What comes next
  18. Part 18Five claims, checked
  19. Part 19Three ways to see it
  20. Part 20Our take
Part 1

Nineteen minutes above the Moon

ISTRAC, Bengaluru On the History of India timeline →

Bengaluru, Wednesday, 23 August 2023, a quarter to six in the evening. In the mission control room at ISTRAC, ISRO’s tracking centre, rows of engineers sat in front of their screens. On the big screen at the front, a small marker hung above a grey curve. The marker was Vikram, a lander weighing about 1,700 kg. The curve was the Moon.

About 30 km above the surface, Vikram’s engines fired. It began to brake from about 1.7 km a second. Nobody on Earth could steer it now. A radio signal takes more than a second to cross the gap, far too slow for steering by hand. Vikram was flying itself, reading the ground with its own cameras and lasers.

Four years earlier, in this same room, the last Vikram had crashed.

This time the line on the screen stayed on its path. About 150 metres up, the lander stopped and hovered, looking for a flat, safe patch. Then it came down slowly. At 6:04 pm India time, after about 19 minutes of braking, it was on the ground. The room jumped to its feet. People hugged, shouted and cried. ISRO’s chairman, S. Somanath, took the microphone.

India is on the Moon.S. Somanath, ISRO chairman, in the control room, 23 August 2023

Minutes later, ISRO posted a message on X, written as if the spacecraft itself were talking.

India, I reached my destination and you too!ISRO’s post on X, in Chandrayaan-3’s voice, 23 August 2023

India had become the fourth country to make a soft, controlled landing on the Moon, after the Soviet Union, the United States and China. No lander had ever come down safely so far south, in the region of the Moon’s south pole. That last point would start an argument. But first, the road. It began 60 years earlier, with rocket parts carried to a church on bicycles.

Part 2

Who’s who

The people in this story

  • Vikram Sarabhai52Physicist who started India’s space programme. The Vikram lander is named after him
  • Peter Bernard PereiraBishop of Trivandrum, who gave his church at Thumba to the rocket scientists
  • A.P.J. Abdul KalamYoung engineer at Thumba. Later President of India
  • U.R. RaoLed the team that built Aryabhata, India’s first satellite. Later ISRO chairman
  • Mylswamy AnnaduraiProject director of Chandrayaan-1
  • K. SivanISRO chairman when Chandrayaan-2’s lander crashed in 2019
  • S. SomanathISRO chairman when Chandrayaan-3 landed in 2023
  • P. VeeramuthuvelProject director of Chandrayaan-3
  • Shanmuga SubramanianChennai volunteer who found the 2019 crash debris in NASA’s photos
  • Ouyang ZiyuanFather of China’s Moon programme. Disputed the ‘south pole’ claim
Part 3

A rocket in a church, 1963

Thumba, Kerala

Thumba, a fishing village just outside Thiruvananthapuram in Kerala, the early 1960s. Coconut palms, white sand and the Arabian Sea. In the middle of it stood St Mary Magdalene Church, where Latin Catholic fishing families came to pray.

The scientists wanted this spot. Thumba lies very close to the Earth’s magnetic equator, the line where the planet’s magnetic field runs flat. Rockets fired from here could study the strange electric currents in the high air above it. The man who wanted it most was Vikram Sarabhai, a physicist from Ahmedabad.

Sarabhai went to the local bishop, Peter Bernard Pereira. The bishop put the scientists’ request to his congregation. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, then a young engineer on the team, later remembered the answer. The congregation said ‘Amen’. The fishing families gave up land, houses and their church. They still say they did it freely, and that they are proud of it.

The prayer hall became a workshop and the bishop’s room an office. With no proper roads, rocket parts came on bicycles and bullock carts.

Thursday, 21 November 1963, at dusk. A two-stage Nike-Apache rocket, made in America, stood on its launcher by the sea. It weighed 715 kg and carried a 30 kg payload, a sodium vapour experiment from France to trace the winds high above. At about 6:25 pm it went up, and climbed to 207 km.

A thin rocket rising from a launcher on a smoke trail, in an old black-and-white photograph
The first rocket from Thumba, a Nike-Apache, just after lift-off in November 1963.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The rocket was borrowed and the payload was foreign. But the place, the team and the plan were Indian. On 2 February 1968, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi dedicated the Thumba station to the United Nations.

Part 4

The man who said no to the Moon

Kovalam, Kerala

Vikram Sarabhai was born in Ahmedabad on 12 August 1919, into a rich mill-owning family. After Cambridge, in 1947, he founded the Physical Research Laboratory in Ahmedabad. In 1962, with the nuclear scientist Homi Bhabha behind him, he set up INCOSPAR, the Indian National Committee for Space Research. In 1969 it became ISRO, the Indian Space Research Organisation.

Sarabhai was asked one hard question again and again. Why should a poor country spend money on rockets? His answer became famous.

We do not have the fantasy of competing with the economically advanced nations.Vikram Sarabhai, as quoted by ISRO

He went on to rule out the Moon, the planets and astronauts. Space, he said, must serve ‘the real problems of man and society’: weather warnings, maps, phones, and television for villages.

In September 1969 he signed a deal with NASA to beam teaching programmes by satellite to about 5,000 villages. It happened in 1975 and 1976. Sarabhai did not see it.

Vikram Sarabhai and NASA chief Thomas Paine sit at a table signing papers
Vikram Sarabhai (left) and NASA’s chief, Thomas Paine, sign the 1969 deal to bring satellite television to Indian villages.Photo: NASA · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

On 30 December 1971, two weeks after the war that made Bangladesh, Sarabhai died at Kovalam, near Thumba. He was 52. Fifty-two years later, the lander that touched the Moon carried his first name. The man who had no ‘fantasy’ of the Moon got there anyway.

Part 5

A satellite from a shed, 1975

Kapustin Yar On the History of India timeline →

Peenya, on the edge of Bangalore, the early 1970s. ISRO took over four big industrial sheds and turned them into labs, clean rooms and test halls. The leader was U.R. Rao, a space scientist. His team grew to about 200 people. Their job was to build India’s first satellite in about 30 months, for about Rs 3 crore.

In 1972 the Soviet Union had agreed to launch it. Rao later recalled sending Indira Gandhi three names. One was Jawahar, after her father. One was Maitri, friendship, for the Soviets. She picked the third: Aryabhata, after the astronomer who worked near Pataliputra 1,500 years ago.

On 19 April 1975, a Soviet rocket lifted it from Kapustin Yar in southern Russia. It weighed 360 kg. Then came trouble. After four days, a power failure stopped its experiments. After five, its signals went quiet. But it had shown that India could build a satellite and talk to it. For 21 years, from 1976, Aryabhata was printed on the back of the two-rupee note. It fell back to Earth in February 1992.

Two months after the launch, Indira Gandhi declared the Emergency. In 1980 India’s own rocket, the SLV-3, led by Kalam, put a satellite into orbit. In April 1984, Squadron Leader Rakesh Sharma flew to space on a Soviet craft. Indira Gandhi asked him how India looked from up there. ‘Saare Jahan Se Achha,’ he said: better than the whole world.

Part 6

A flag on the Moon, 2008

Sriharikota

Sriharikota, an island on the coast of Andhra Pradesh, early on the morning of 22 October 2008. A PSLV rocket rose over the sea with Chandrayaan-1 on top. Chandra means Moon; yaan means craft. India was going to the Moon at last.

It reached Moon orbit on 8 November. On 14 November, Children’s Day, the birthday of Jawaharlal Nehru, it let go of a small box of instruments, the Moon Impact Probe. The probe had the Indian flag painted on it. It fell for about 25 minutes, taking readings all the way. Then it smashed into the ground near Shackleton crater, by the south pole. The spot was named Jawahar Point.

Chandrayaan-1 was meant to work for two years. In August 2009, after 312 days, contact was lost. The mission cost about Rs 386 crore. It had already done something nobody expected.

Part 7

The water nobody expected

Sriharikota On the History of India timeline →

One of the instruments on board was the Moon Mineralogy Mapper, M3 for short, a NASA instrument. It split the sunlight bouncing off the Moon into its colours, and looked for the fingerprints of different chemicals.

On 24 September 2009, the journal Science published what M3 had seen. A thin film of water and hydroxyl, a close chemical cousin of water, lay across the surface, stronger towards the poles. Ever since the Apollo rocks were studied, most scientists had thought the Moon was bone dry.

A false-colour picture of the Moon with blue patches near the top and bottom edges
The Moon seen by NASA’s M3 instrument on Chandrayaan-1. Blue marks the water signal, strongest towards the poles.Photo: ISRO/NASA/JPL-Caltech/Brown Univ./USGS · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Then came a quarrel about credit. The instrument was American. ISRO said CHACE, an instrument on its falling probe, had sensed water first, in November 2008. Both rode on an Indian spacecraft. In 2018, scientists went back to M3’s data. They found ice on the surface near the poles, in craters where the Sun never shines.

That ice is why every space power now wants the south pole. Water can be drunk. It can also be split into oxygen to breathe and hydrogen for rocket fuel.

Part 8

Two kilometres short, 2019

ISTRAC, Bengaluru

In September 2014, Mangalyaan slipped into orbit around Mars on India’s first try. Confidence was high. Chandrayaan-2 would go further: an orbiter, a lander called Vikram, and a rover called Pragyan, meaning wisdom. It launched on 22 July 2019 and cost about Rs 978 crore. Its target was a high plain about 70.9 degrees south.

Bengaluru, a little before 2 am on 7 September 2019. Prime Minister Narendra Modi sat in the gallery at ISTRAC, with schoolchildren invited to watch. Vikram came down as planned. Then, about 2.1 km above the surface, the line on the screen bent away from its path. The data stopped. The room went quiet.

K. Sivan, ISRO’s chairman, walked over and spoke to the Prime Minister. Then he told the country that contact had been lost. Later that morning, after Modi spoke to the scientists, Sivan broke down. Modi hugged him and patted his back. The picture went round the world.

What went wrong? In November 2019 the government told the Lok Sabha that Vikram had slowed down more than designed in the second phase of braking. That left it outside the limits for its final braking. It ‘hard-landed’ within 500 metres of its target, the government said.

ISRO did not find the wreck. A volunteer in Chennai did. Shanmuga Subramanian, an engineer, combed through photos from NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter and spotted debris. On 3 December 2019 NASA confirmed the crash site and credited him.

A grey patch of the Moon’s surface with green and blue dots marking crash debris and an S marking one piece
Where the 2019 Vikram hit the Moon, from NASA’s orbiter. Green dots mark debris; the ‘S’ marks the piece Shanmuga Subramanian found.Photo: NASA/GSFC/Arizona State University · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

A Failure Analysis Committee wrote a report on the crash. ISRO had made such reports public in the past. This one it kept back. In 2020 it refused a request under the Right to Information Act, saying the report touched national security and strategic interests.

The orbiter, though, kept working. It is still circling the Moon. Four years later, it would help its little sibling call home.

Part 9

Built for everything to go wrong

Sriharikota

ISRO’s next chairman, S. Somanath, changed the question. Chandrayaan-2’s lander had been built to succeed when things went right. Chandrayaan-3’s, he said, had a ‘failure-based design’. The engineers listed everything that could fail, and planned for each one.

The lander got stronger legs, more fuel, more sensors and extra solar panels, so it could make power whichever way it landed. Its landing zone grew to about 4 km by 2.5 km, about 40 times bigger than before. There was no new orbiter. The old Chandrayaan-2 orbiter would relay messages. The whole mission cost about Rs 615 crore, according to K. Sivan.

Sriharikota, 14 July 2023, 2:35 pm. An LVM3, India’s heaviest rocket, rose into the sky. Apollo 11 had reached the Moon in four days. Chandrayaan-3 took the slow road. It looped around the Earth in bigger and bigger orbits, gaining speed each time. On 5 August it slipped into orbit around the Moon. On 17 August Vikram, with Pragyan folded inside, separated from the propulsion module that had carried it there.

Part 10

A Russian crash, four days before

Vostochny, Russia

11 August 2023, Russia’s far east. From its new Vostochny launch site, Russia sent up Luna-25, its first Moon mission since 1976. It was also heading for the Moon’s southern high latitudes, near a crater called Boguslawsky. It was due to land on 21 August, two days before Vikram. Newspapers called it a race.

On 19 August, during an engine burn to lower its orbit, Luna-25 went silent. Roscosmos, Russia’s space agency, said it had hit the Moon. Its chief, Yuri Borisov, blamed the engine burn. NASA’s orbiter later photographed a fresh crater about 400 km from where it was meant to land.

Luna-25 had cost at least 12.6 billion roubles, about $134 million, the Russian news site The Bell reported. Four days before their own landing, ISRO’s engineers had watched an older, richer space power fail.

Part 11

A country at its screens

Kolkata

On the evening of 23 August, India watched. In Kolkata, crowds gathered at the Birla Industrial and Technological Museum. ISRO’s YouTube stream had more than 8 million people watching at the same moment, a world record at the time. YouTube’s own chief congratulated ISRO.

A crowd of people seated and standing in front of a large screen at a museum in Kolkata
Kolkata, landing day, 23 August 2023: a crowd at the Birla Industrial and Technological Museum waits in front of a big screen.Photo: Biswarup Ganguly · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Prime Minister Modi was at the BRICS summit in Johannesburg, South Africa, and joined online. ‘India is now on the Moon,’ he said, as reports translated his Hindi. He said the success belonged to all of humanity.

Vikram was sitting at about 69.37 degrees south and 32.32 degrees east, on a plain between two craters called Manzinus C and Simpelius N.

Part 12

Fourteen days of sunlight

ISTRAC, Bengaluru

One day on the Moon lasts about 14 Earth days, and so does one night. Vikram and Pragyan ran on sunlight. They had one lunar day to work.

A few hours after landing, a ramp unfolded. Pragyan, a six-wheeled rover weighing 26 kg, rolled down onto the soil. Its back wheels were meant to stamp the ISRO logo and the Lion Capital of Ashoka into the dust. The prints did not come out as clearly as planned, WION reported.

Pragyan crept along at about a centimetre a second. On 27 August its camera spotted a crater about four metres wide just ahead. Controllers ordered it back, onto a new path.

On 29 August ISRO announced a first. Pragyan’s laser instrument, LIBS, had confirmed sulphur in the soil near the south pole, the first such measurement made on the spot. It also found aluminium, calcium, iron, chromium, titanium, manganese, silicon and oxygen. It was still looking for hydrogen, the sign of water.

Vikram had its own tools. A probe called ChaSTE pushed heat sensors into the ground. The surface was about 70°C. Just 8 cm down, it was below minus 10°C. An ISRO scientist said the surface heat was not expected. On 26 August, Vikram’s seismometer, ILSA, recorded what looked like a natural tremor, possibly a moonquake.

The gold-wrapped Vikram lander standing on grey lunar soil, seen from the rover
Vikram on the Moon, photographed by the Pragyan rover’s navigation camera on 30 August 2023 (ISRO image, processed by Simeon Schmauß).Photo: ISRO/Simeon Schmauß · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

By 2 September Pragyan had driven 101.4 metres. ISRO turned its solar panel to face the next sunrise and put it to sleep.

Part 13

The hop

ISTRAC, Bengaluru

Sunday, 3 September 2023. Vikram had one surprise left, and ISRO had not announced it. The lander folded up its ramp and two of its instruments. Then it fired its engines, rose about 40 cm, and came down 30 to 40 cm away.

It was a jump smaller than a child’s. But it proved the engines could fire again after nearly two weeks on the Moon. A craft bringing Moon rock home will need to do exactly that.

On 4 September Vikram went to sleep too. ISRO hoped both would wake at sunrise, around 22 September. They never answered. The night had fallen below minus 120°C, colder than their electronics could stand.

In November 2023, ISRO even brought the propulsion module back from the Moon to a high orbit around Earth.

The science kept coming. In 2024 the journal Nature published the soil readings from another Pragyan instrument, APXS. The ground was fairly uniform, made mostly of a pale rock called ferroan anorthosite. The scientists said this supports an old idea: the young Moon was once covered by an ocean of molten rock, a magma ocean.

Part 14

Shiv Shakti and Tiranga

ISTRAC, Bengaluru

Bengaluru, the morning of 26 August 2023. Modi came to ISTRAC to meet the team. He announced that the landing spot would be called Shiv Shakti point. Shiv, he said, stands for the welfare of humanity, and Shakti gives the strength to achieve it. Shakti also honoured the mission’s women scientists, he said. The spot where Chandrayaan-2 crashed would be Tiranga point, after the tricolour flag.

This Tiranga point will teach us that no failure is final.Narendra Modi, ISTRAC, Bengaluru, 26 August 2023, as reported in English

He also declared that 23 August would be National Space Day, every year.

Names on the Moon are approved by the International Astronomical Union, the IAU. The Hindu noted that its rules bar names with political, military or religious meaning. On 19 March 2024 the IAU approved ‘Statio Shiv Shakti’ all the same. Its list explains the name as the male (Shiva) and female (Shakti) sides of nature, from Indian mythology.

Readers’ poll

Who should name places on the Moon?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 15

What did it cost?

Ranchi

Rs 615 crore is a lot of money. For a trip to the Moon, it is very little.

  • Aryabhata, 1975: about Rs 3 crore
  • Chandrayaan-1, 2008: about Rs 386 crore
  • Chandrayaan-2, 2019: about Rs 978 crore
  • Chandrayaan-3, 2023: about Rs 615 crore, roughly $75 million
  • Russia’s Luna-25, 2023: at least 12.6 billion roubles, about $134 million (The Bell)
  • One launch of NASA’s Artemis Moon rocket and capsule: about $4.1 billion, NASA’s inspector general estimated in 2021

The whole Department of Space got Rs 12,543.91 crore for 2023–24, about 8% less than the year before. Space science, the part that pays for Moon and Sun missions, took a sharper cut. And the department spent less than it was given, about Rs 11,070 crore, the Takshashila Institution, a think tank, found.

Ranchi, 2023. At the state-owned Heavy Engineering Corporation, HEC, about 2,800 staff said they had not been paid for around 18 months. HEC had built launch-pad equipment for ISRO. One technician, Deepak Kumar Uprariya, told the BBC he was selling idlis at a roadside stall to get by, reports said. An MP, Mahua Maji, raised it in the Rajya Sabha.

The government’s PIB Fact Check unit called a BBC Hindi report on this ‘misleading’. It said HEC had supplied its ISRO equipment between 2003 and 2010, and nothing made specially for Chandrayaan-3. It did not answer the claim about the unpaid wages.

Readers’ poll

Should a country with many poor people spend money on going to the Moon?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 16

Was it really the south pole?

Beijing

Look at the numbers. The Moon’s south pole is at 90 degrees south. Vikram landed at about 69.4 degrees south. NASA, publishing its own photo of the landing site, put it about 600 km from the pole.

NASA usually counts the south polar region as 80 to 90 degrees south. Ouyang Ziyuan went further. In September 2023 he told China’s Science Times that the polar region runs only from 88.5 to 90 degrees. By his count, Vikram was 619 km outside it. The Moon is barely tilted on its axis, he argued, so its polar region is much smaller than the Earth’s.

ISRO’s own words were usually careful: ‘near the south pole’, or the ‘south polar region’. Many leaders, TV channels and social media posts were not. In February 2024 an American lander, Odysseus, came down at about 80 degrees south, much closer to the pole. It broke a leg and landed tilted.

So what is fair to say? Vikram made the first soft landing this far south; earlier probes that went farther south crashed or were meant to hit. ‘Near the south pole’ is fair, if you read ‘near’ broadly. ‘On the south pole’ is wrong.

Part 17

What comes next

Bengaluru On the History of India timeline →

Some of it is already history. Ten days after the landing, ISRO launched Aditya-L1 to watch the Sun. In June 2025, Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla became the first Indian on the International Space Station, on a private American mission.

The rest is plans, not facts yet. Space plans slip. Gaganyaan’s first flight was once meant for 2020.

  • Gaganyaan G1: an uncrewed test of India’s crew capsule, carrying a half-humanoid robot called Vyommitra. ISRO’s chairman, V. Narayanan, said in June 2026 it was aimed at the end of 2026. It had not flown by mid-November 2026. A flight with Indian astronauts is now spoken of for 2027.
  • Chandrayaan-4: approved by the Union Cabinet on 18 September 2024 for Rs 2,104.06 crore. It would need two LVM3 launches to land, scoop up Moon soil and bring it back to Earth. It is planned for about 2028.
  • Chandrayaan-5, or LUPEX: a bigger lander and rover for the south polar region, planned with Japan’s space agency, JAXA.
  • Bharatiya Antariksh Station: India’s own space station, with a first module planned for 2028 and the full station by 2035.
  • An Indian on the Moon by 2040: the goal Modi set for ISRO in October 2023.

Readers’ poll

What should India’s space programme do next?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 18

Five claims, checked

Claim 1

India landed on the Moon’s south pole

Why people believed it

Headlines, posts and some leaders said it on landing day.

What the record shows

Vikram landed at about 69.4 degrees south. NASA put it about 600 km from the pole. NASA counts the polar region as 80 to 90 degrees; Ouyang Ziyuan says 88.5 to 90. ISRO itself mostly said ‘near the south pole’.

Still openNear, not on. It was the first soft landing this far south.

Claim 2

Chandrayaan-1 discovered water on the Moon

Why people believed it

It is the proudest line of India’s first Moon mission.

What the record shows

NASA’s M3 instrument, on board Chandrayaan-1, found the water signal, published in Science in September 2009. ISRO says its own probe sensed water first, in November 2008.

On the recordTrue, as a joint find on an Indian spacecraft.

Claim 3

Chandrayaan-2 was a total failure

Why people believed it

Its lander crashed on live TV in 2019.

What the record shows

Vikram and Pragyan were lost. The orbiter kept working, is still circling the Moon, and relayed for Chandrayaan-3 in 2023.

BustedFalse. The landing failed; the mission did not.

Claim 4

The BBC mocked Chandrayaan-3 over India’s poverty

Why people believed it

A clip of a BBC presenter asking about toilets and poverty went viral in August 2023. Anand Mahindra replied: ‘The greatest poverty is the poverty of aspiration.’

What the record shows

The fact-checkers Alt News and BOOM found the clip was from July 2019, about Chandrayaan-2. The BBC confirmed it was old.

BustedFalse. It was an old clip, shared as new.

Claim 5

The engineers who built the launch pad were never paid

Why people believed it

HEC workers in Ranchi said so in 2023, and the BBC reported it.

What the record shows

Workers said about 2,800 staff went some 18 months unpaid. The government’s PIB Fact Check said HEC’s ISRO equipment dated from 2003 to 2010, and was not made for Chandrayaan-3.

Still openUnpaid wages were real, by workers’ and MPs’ accounts. The Chandrayaan-3 link is disputed.

Part 19

Three ways to see it

Both sides, and a third

What ISRO and the government said

  • Somanath said Chandrayaan-3 was built on lessons from failure, with a ‘failure-based design’.
  • Modi said the success belonged to all of humanity, and no failure is final.
  • A Lok Sabha reply said the Department of Space budget had doubled between 2013–14 and 2023–24.
  • The PIB Fact Check said reports linking HEC’s unpaid workers to Chandrayaan-3 were misleading.

What admirers say

  • Anand Mahindra said the mission gives a poor country the aspiration to rise.
  • The mission cost about Rs 615 crore, a small fraction of what bigger space powers spend.
  • It confirmed sulphur on the spot and gave Nature-published evidence for an ancient magma ocean.
  • More than 8 million people watched the landing live at the same moment.

What critics say

  • Ouyang Ziyuan said 69 degrees south is not the south pole at all.
  • The Wire and RTI applicants pointed out that ISRO never published its report on the 2019 crash, and refused an RTI request.
  • HEC workers and opposition MPs said staff went unpaid while the government took credit.
  • Some argue, as Sarabhai once did, that real problems on Earth come first.
Part 20

Our take

Sixty years ago, a borrowed rocket left a church by the sea. In 2023, an Indian lander set itself down on the Moon, after a crash that the whole world saw. It did it for less than the cost of one launch of a bigger country’s Moon rocket. That is a real achievement, and the engineers earned it.

Other things are true too. ‘South pole’ was stretched. The 2019 crash report is still secret. And HEC’s workers deserved an answer about their wages, not only a fact check.

Sarabhai said India had no fantasy of the Moon. He wanted space to serve people on Earth. Now his name is on the Moon. The test for what comes next is whether ISRO can keep serving both.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. Where did India’s first rocket go up from in 1963?

  2. Who is the Vikram lander named after?

  3. Whose rocket launched Aryabhata in 1975?

  4. What happened to Russia’s Luna-25?

  5. What did Pragyan’s LIBS instrument confirm near the south pole?

  6. How high did Vikram rise in its surprise hop?

  7. Which day is India’s National Space Day?

Play: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

When did Chandrayaan-3 land on the Moon?

The Vikram lander touched down at 6:04 pm India time on 23 August 2023, after a 40-day journey that began at Sriharikota on 14 July. The Pragyan rover rolled out a few hours later. India became the fourth country to make a soft landing on the Moon, after the Soviet Union, the United States and China.

Did Chandrayaan-3 land on the Moon’s south pole?

No, but near it. Vikram landed at about 69.4 degrees south, about 600 km from the pole, NASA said. NASA counts the polar region as 80 to 90 degrees south, and China’s Ouyang Ziyuan says 88.5 to 90. It was still the first soft landing that far south.

How much did Chandrayaan-3 cost?

About Rs 615 crore, according to former ISRO chairman K. Sivan, roughly $75 million. Russia’s Luna-25 cost at least 12.6 billion roubles, The Bell reported. NASA’s inspector general put each launch of its Artemis Moon rocket and capsule at about $4.1 billion.

What did Chandrayaan-3 find?

Pragyan’s LIBS instrument confirmed sulphur in the soil near the south pole, the first such measurement on the spot. Vikram’s ChaSTE probe found the surface at about 70°C and below minus 10°C just 8 cm down. Its seismometer recorded a possible moonquake. Pragyan’s APXS data, published in Nature in 2024, supports the idea of an ancient magma ocean.

Why did Chandrayaan-2’s lander crash?

The government told the Lok Sabha in November 2019 that Vikram slowed down more than designed in the second braking phase, putting it outside the limits for its final braking. It hard-landed within 500 metres of its target. ISRO’s Failure Analysis Committee report was never published.

What is the Shiv Shakti point?

It is the name Prime Minister Modi gave to Chandrayaan-3’s landing spot on 26 August 2023. The International Astronomical Union approved ‘Statio Shiv Shakti’ on 19 March 2024. Chandrayaan-2’s crash site was named Tiranga point, and 23 August became National Space Day.

What comes after Chandrayaan-3?

These are plans, not facts yet. Gaganyaan’s uncrewed G1 test, with the robot Vyommitra, was aimed at the end of 2026, with astronauts to follow. Chandrayaan-4, approved in September 2024, is meant to bring Moon soil back to Earth around 2028. The government has also set goals of a space station by 2035 and an Indian on the Moon by 2040.

How we wrote this. We built this story from ISRO’s own records, statements to Parliament, NASA’s published images and reports, the scientific papers in Science and Nature, and the newspaper and fact-check reports listed with this story. The TrendingPunjabi desk wrote it in our own words with the help of an AI model. Sources differ on small details: the exact landing minute (6:03 or 6:04 pm), the height of the 2019 failure, and the cost figures, which are estimates. Whether Vikram landed ‘near the south pole’ depends on how the polar region is defined, and we set out each definition. The link between HEC’s unpaid workers and Chandrayaan-3 is disputed by the government. Quotes from Hindi speeches are as reported in English. Gaganyaan, Chandrayaan-4 and later missions are plans, not facts. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources

  1. ISRO: Dr. Vikram Ambalal Sarabhai (1963–1971)
  2. The South First: 60th anniversary of India’s first rocket launch: the fishworkers who gave their church
  3. The Tribune: 50 years ago, India’s first satellite Aryabhata launched
  4. Science: Character and spatial distribution of OH/H2O on the surface of the Moon seen by M3 on Chandrayaan-1 (Pieters et al., 2009)
  5. Scroll.in: ISRO chief hugs Modi, breaks down after space agency loses contact with Vikram
  6. The Wire: Chandrayaan-2: Vikram hard-landed within 500 metres of landing site, says government
  7. NASA / Arizona State University: Vikram impact site found (LROC, 3 December 2019)
  8. The News Minute: ISRO denies RTI on Vikram lander failure report
  9. DNA: Chandrayaan-3 has a ‘failure-based design’: ISRO chief S. Somanath explains
  10. Space.com: Russia says its Luna-25 lander has crashed into the Moon
  11. The Bell: Russia loses its first-ever lunar station
  12. The Quint: ‘India is on the Moon’: highlights of the historic landing
  13. Business Standard: Chandrayaan-3 becomes the world’s most viewed live stream
  14. The Week: Vikram lander makes soft-landing on Moon again, undergoes hop test
  15. Nature: Chandrayaan-3 APXS elemental abundance measurements at lunar high latitude (Vadawale et al., 2024)
  16. NASA: NASA’s LRO observes Chandrayaan-3 landing site
  17. narendramodi.in: Text of PM’s address to Team ISRO on the success of Chandrayaan-3
  18. The Tribune: International Astronomical Union approves Chandrayaan-3 landing site name ‘Shiva Shakti’
  19. Business Standard (Bloomberg): Top Chinese scientist claims India’s Moon landing nowhere near south pole
  20. Scroll.in: No salaries in last 18 months: workers who made parts for ISRO launches protest
  21. Alt News: No, BBC did not criticise Chandrayaan-3: old clip viral
  22. NASA Office of Inspector General: NASA’s management of the Artemis missions (IG-22-003)
  23. Takshashila Institution: Department of Space: demand for grants analysis
  24. PMIndia (PIB): India goes to Moon again: Cabinet approves Chandrayaan-4
  25. Space.com: India delays first Gaganyaan astronaut launch to 2027
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India