Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev: The Wrong Man, the Bombs That Missed and the Gallows a Day Early
A boy with a bottle of Jallianwala soil. A British officer shot by mistake, and a Punjabi head constable killed in the chase. Bombs thrown to miss. A 116-day fast. A tribunal built to convict, and a hanging moved up a day. Here is what Gandhi did and did not do, the British case, and the fight over Bhagat Singh’s name in Lahore.
In short
- Bhagat Singh was born in 1907 in Banga, Lyallpur district, now in Pakistan. He turned revolutionary as a teenager, after Jallianwala Bagh and the hanging of Kartar Singh Sarabha.
- In 1928 Lala Lajpat Rai died after a police lathi charge in Lahore. To avenge him, the HSRA shot the wrong officer, John Saunders. Head constable Chanan Singh was killed in the chase.
- In 1929 Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt threw bombs meant not to kill in Delhi’s Central Legislative Assembly. Then they waited to be arrested. A special tribunal later sentenced Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru to death for the Saunders killing.
- Gandhi asked the Viceroy first to suspend the sentences, then to commute them, or make them lighter. But he did not make them a condition of the Gandhi–Irwin Pact. The three were hanged on 23 March 1931, a day early, and secretly cremated at Hussainiwala.
At a glance
Hanged 1931- Who
- Bhagat Singh (23), Sukhdev Thapar (23) and Shivaram Rajguru (22), of the Hindustan Socialist Republican Association (HSRA)
- Hanged
- 23 March 1931, Lahore Central Jail, about 7 pm (some accounts say 7:30), a day ahead of schedule
- Convicted of
- The murder of Assistant Superintendent of Police John Saunders, by a special tribunal set up by ordinance, 7 October 1930
- Killed in 1928
- John Saunders, 21, shot in Lahore on 17 December 1928; head constable Chanan Singh, shot dead chasing the attackers, by most accounts by Chandrashekhar Azad
- Assembly bombs
- 8 April 1929, Delhi, thrown by Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt; nobody killed
- Cremated
- In secret, on the Sutlej at Hussainiwala near Ferozepur, now the National Martyrs Memorial
- Remembered
- Shaheedi Diwas, 23 March, in India; small commemorations in Lahore, where petitions to honour him have been turned down
In this story · 14 parts
- Apr 1919A bottle of soil
- Sep 1928A meeting in the ruins
- 30 Oct 1928The lathis at Lahore
- 17 Dec 1928The wrong man, and the man who gave chase
- 8 Apr 1929Bombs that were meant to miss
- 13 Sep 1929Hunger
- 7 Oct 1930A trial without the accused
- 5–6 Oct 1930Why I am an atheist
- 5 Mar 1931Gandhi and the Viceroy
- 23 Mar 1931A day early
- 2 Feb 1931Hero or terrorist?
- 2014–2025A case reopened in Lahore
- 1961–2022Two Punjabs, one face
- Part 14Our take
A bottle of soil
Jallianwala Bagh, Amritsar
Amritsar, April 1919. A few days after the firing stopped at Jallianwala Bagh, a schoolboy from Lyallpur district walked into the walled garden. The bullet marks were fresh on the bricks. He scooped up earth darkened with blood. He pressed it into a small glass bottle.
His name was Bhagat Singh. He was 11 (some accounts say 10, others 12). He took the bottle home. As the journalist P. Sainath tells it, he and his sister emptied it at a spot in their grandfather’s garden. They grew flowers there every year. (Our full story of the massacre is here.)
He was born on 27 September 1907 (some records say the 28th) in Banga, in Lyallpur district. It was a canal-colony village, a farming settlement on land watered by new canals. Today Lyallpur is Faisalabad, in Pakistan. The family’s roots were in Khatkar Kalan, in the Doaba. Rebellion ran in the house. When he was born, his father, Kishan Singh, was in jail over the 1907 protests against the Canal Colonisation Bill. That same year his uncle Ajit Singh had been deported to Mandalay with Lala Lajpat Rai.
His boyhood hero was Kartar Singh Sarabha, the Ghadar Party’s teenage editor. Sarabha was hanged in Lahore in 1915, at 19. Bhagat Singh carried his photograph.
He went to the DAV School in Lahore. Then Gandhi called on students to quit government-aided schools and colleges. Bhagat Singh moved to the National College that Lajpat Rai had founded. He read everything: Irish rebels, Russian anarchists, Marx, Lenin. When his family fixed his marriage, he ran away to Kanpur. He worked at a press under a false name and joined the Hindustan Republican Association. In March 1926 he helped start a youth group in Lahore, the Naujawan Bharat Sabha. He became its secretary.
A meeting in the ruins
Delhi
Delhi, September 1928. A group of young men met among the broken walls of Feroz Shah Kotla, the 14th-century fort. They gave their old party a new word. It became the Hindustan Socialist Republican Association, the HSRA. Chandrashekhar Azad would command its armed wing. He was the one leader the police had never caught.
Most were students in their early twenties who argued about Bakunin, the Russian anarchist, over tea. Their goal was a socialist republic. Their method included the pistol.
The young men (ages in December 1928)
- Bhagat Singh21From Banga, Lyallpur district. Writer, organiser and the group’s loudest voice
- Sukhdev Thapar21Born in Ludhiana in May 1907; his father died three months before. Bhagat Singh’s friend from the National College and a key organiser in Lahore
- Shivaram Rajguru20Born at Khed near Pune in August 1908; Khed is now Rajgurunagar
- Chandrashekhar AzadCommander of the HSRA; signed its leaflets ‘Balraj’
- Batukeshwar Dutt18From Bengal; threw the Assembly bombs with Bhagat Singh
- Jatindra Nath DasBomb-maker from Calcutta; died on hunger strike in 1929
- Durgawati Devi‘Durga Bhabhi’, wife of the HSRA’s thinker Bhagwati Charan Vohra; got Bhagat Singh out of Lahore
The lathis at Lahore
Lahore, 30 October 1928. The Simon Commission arrived. It had come to recommend how India should be governed, and it did not have a single Indian member. Lala Lajpat Rai led the march against it. He was 63, and people called him the ‘Punjab Kesari’, the Lion of Punjab.
Lahore’s police superintendent, James A. Scott, ordered a lathi charge, an attack with long bamboo sticks. Accounts of the day say he struck Lajpat Rai himself. That evening, bruised, Rai spoke to a meeting at Mochi Gate. The blows, he said, were ‘the last nails in the coffin of British rule in India’.
He died on 17 November 1928. Doctors believed the beating had hastened his death. When the matter reached the British Parliament, the government denied any role.
Here is the twist. Bhagat Singh had fallen out with Lajpat Rai. He thought Rai had drifted into communal politics, the politics of one religious community against another. The historian Bipan Chandra records what his circle did. They printed Browning’s poem The Lost Leader as a pamphlet, with Rai’s photograph on the cover. But the police had beaten India’s senior leader in the street. That was an insult they would not swallow. The HSRA decided Scott would die.
The wrong man, and the man who gave chase
Lahore
Lahore, 17 December 1928, at about 4 pm. A young officer walked out of the district police office towards his motorcycle. Jai Gopal had been posted to watch for Scott. He gave the signal. He had picked the wrong man.
The officer was John Poyntz Saunders, an assistant superintendent still on probation. He was 21, born in Peterborough in England two months before Bhagat Singh. Rajguru fired first. Then Bhagat Singh fired several more shots into the fallen officer. The post-mortem counted eight wounds.
The shooters ran for the grounds of DAV College across the road. One policeman ran after them. He was head constable Chanan Singh, a Punjabi Sikh. Most accounts say Azad, covering the escape, shot him. He died there.
In 2022 a law student went to the Punjab and Haryana High Court, citing a book. The student said Azad had warned the constable again and again, and aimed at his thigh. By this account, Chanan Singh bled to death because everyone was busy with Saunders. No court has tested that story. Either way, a man who was not the target, and had beaten nobody, was dead. In 2022 the Punjab Police Rules still carried a memorial fund in the names of Saunders and Chanan Singh. The student wanted it scrapped as an insult to the freedom fighters.
Next morning, handwritten leaflets appeared on Lahore’s walls. Lajpat Rai had been avenged, they said. They called Saunders the agent of the most tyrannical government in the world. A copy in Bhagat Singh’s handwriting was later shown in court.
Sorry for the death of a man.HSRA leaflet pasted up in Lahore, 18 December 1928, signed ‘Balraj’
Two days after the shooting, Sukhdev knocked on Durgawati Devi’s door. Bhagat Singh cut his hair and shaved his beard. He put on Western clothes and a hat. With Durga Bhabhi and her infant son beside him, he boarded a train. He looked like a young gentleman travelling with his wife and child. Rajguru carried the bags as their servant. The disguise worked.
Bombs that were meant to miss
Delhi
Delhi, 8 April 1929. Two young men sat in the visitors’ gallery of the Central Legislative Assembly, the law-making body of British India. Below them, the House was dealing with two bills the revolutionaries hated: the Public Safety Bill and the Trade Disputes Bill. Sir John Simon himself was watching from the President’s gallery.
Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt threw two bombs onto empty benches. They went off with a roar and a cloud of smoke. Leaflets fluttered down. The two shouted ‘Inquilab Zindabad’, Long live the revolution. The Urdu poet Hasrat Mohani had coined the slogan in 1921. Then they stood still, waiting to be arrested.
Nobody was killed. A few members were slightly hurt, among them the Finance Member, Sir George Schuster.
It takes a loud voice to make the deaf hear.HSRA leaflet thrown in the Assembly, 8 April 1929
The same leaflet said its authors held human life sacred. You could kill individuals, it said, but not ideas. Their statement in court was read out on 6 June. Revolution, it said, was ‘not the cult of the bomb and the pistol’. On 12 June 1929, Sessions Judge Leonard Middleton sentenced both men to transportation for life, to be served in a far-off prison.
That might have been the end. But on 15 April police had raided an HSRA bomb factory in Lahore. They arrested Sukhdev, Kishori Lal and Jai Gopal. Jai Gopal, and later Hans Raj Vohra, turned approver: they became witnesses for the Crown. Suddenly the Saunders file had names. Rajguru was caught in Pune later that year.
The .32 Colt used on Saunders, The Tribune reports, went on its own journey. It was last seen at the police academy in Phillaur in 1969. In 2016 it was traced to a weapons school of the BSF, India’s border force, in Indore. In 2017 it went on display at Hussainiwala.
Hunger
Lahore
In jail, Bhagat Singh found that European prisoners got better food, clothes and books than Indian political prisoners. In June 1929 he stopped eating. Others joined him. They wanted decent food, books and newspapers, and no forced labour.
The Saunders trial opened in Lahore’s Borstal Jail on 10 July 1929. He was carried into court on a stretcher.
Jatindra Nath Das would not give up. On 13 September 1929 he died in Lahore jail, after 63 days without food. In the Central Legislative Assembly, a Bombay lawyer rose to defend the strikers. One day he would found Pakistan.
The man who goes on a hunger strike has a soul.Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Central Legislative Assembly, 1929
Nehru visited the strikers. The Viceroy, Lord Irwin, cut short his summer in Simla. On 5 October, after 116 days, Bhagat Singh ate again. The Congress had asked him to, and so had his own father.
A trial without the accused
Lahore
The magistrate’s court in Lahore became a stage. The accused sang and shouted slogans. On 21 January 1930 they walked in wearing red scarves for Lenin Day. Then one of them threw a slipper at the approver Jai Gopal. The magistrate ordered handcuffs. The prisoners refused, were beaten, and boycotted the court.
The government ran out of patience. On 1 May 1930, Lord Irwin issued an ordinance, an emergency law. It created a special tribunal of three High Court judges. The tribunal could go ahead without the accused in the room. There was no appeal except to the Privy Council in London, the empire’s highest court. The government’s stated reason was to finish a trial. The accused, it said, were deliberately wrecking it.
Within days the tribunal ordered the prisoners handcuffed and taken out. The only Indian judge, Agha Haidar, put on record that he had nothing to do with that order. On 21 June 1930, as the jurist A.G. Noorani has documented, he was removed from the tribunal.
The prosecution listed 607 witnesses and examined 457. The accused called none and cross-examined none, because they refused to recognise the court. Five approvers testified against their old comrades.
Bhagat Singh wanted no defence at all. His father petitioned the tribunal on his behalf. On 4 October 1930 the son answered in an open letter.
I feel as though I have been stabbed at the back.Bhagat Singh to his father, Kishan Singh, 4 October 1930
Three days later, on 7 October 1930, the tribunal sentenced Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru to death. Others got transportation for life or prison terms. Three were acquitted. The ordinance itself lapsed on 31 October. Neither the Assembly nor Parliament had ever approved it. On 11 February 1931 the Privy Council refused to interfere. On 24 February Justice Bhide of the Lahore High Court threw out a habeas corpus plea. Such a plea claims a prisoner is being held unlawfully.
For the Raj, the British government of India, the case was simple. Two policemen had been shot dead in Lahore. Bomb factories had been found. The accused were proud of what they had done. The law said murder meant the rope.
Why I am an atheist
Lahore
Lahore jail, early October 1930. A Muslim jailer arranged an unusual meeting. Bhai Randhir Singh, a devout Sikh and Ghadar veteran, was about to be released. He sat down with the young prisoner. By most accounts he told Bhagat Singh that fame had made him proud, and that pride stood between him and God.
On 5 and 6 October 1930, Bhagat Singh wrote his answer, Why I Am an Atheist. An atheist is someone who does not believe in God. The essay was published after his death, in The People of Lahore on 27 September 1931.
It is not an angry essay. He admits that faith would make his last days easier, and he turns it down anyway. He asks why an all-powerful God would allow hunger and exploitation. He cites Darwin. He argues that belief grew out of human fear. To start praying now, with the noose in sight, would be, he wrote, ‘an act of degradation and demoralization’.
Sikh tradition remembers that meeting differently. Bhai Randhir Singh wrote a prison memoir, Jail Chitthian. In it he says Bhagat Singh told him he had been an atheist until then. But a new spiritual awareness, Bhagat Singh said, had come to him. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism records his account. The essay, dated the very next days, says the opposite. Readers can weigh both.
Gandhi and the Viceroy
Delhi
New Delhi, 17 February 1931. Gandhi walked into the Viceroy’s House to begin talks with Lord Irwin. Civil disobedience had filled the jails, and both sides wanted a truce. In a Lahore cell, three young men were waiting to be hanged. What Gandhi did for them is still one of the angriest arguments in Indian history. Here is the record.
What Gandhi did, 1931
- 18 FebGandhi raises the case, saying it has nothing to do with the talks, and asks Irwin to suspend the executions. Irwin reports to London that Gandhi did not plead for commutation.
- 5 MarThe Gandhi–Irwin Pact is signed. Political prisoners are freed, except those convicted of violence. The three are not covered.
- 19 MarGandhi raises it again. Irwin’s minutes say he weighed it ‘with most anxious care’ and refused to postpone.
- 20–22 MarGandhi sees Home Secretary Herbert Emerson, then Irwin on 21 and 22 March.
- 23 Mar, morningGandhi writes to Irwin asking for commutation, citing public feeling, peace and the chance of judicial error.
- 23 Mar, eveningThe three are hanged.
Two more facts matter. Bhagat Singh did not want mercy. He refused to sign a clemency appeal, a plea for mercy. In their last weeks the three asked to be shot by firing squad, as prisoners of war, rather than hanged. And the Congress Working Committee had agreed, Gandhi later wrote, not to make their reprieve a condition of the truce.
Did Gandhi do enough?
Gandhi’s critics
- His leverage, his power to bargain, was greatest before the pact was signed. He chose not to make the three men’s lives a condition.
- Irwin’s own report says Gandhi first asked only for a postponement, not commutation to a lighter sentence.
- After the hangings, Gandhi said staying the executions ‘was no part of the truce’ (26 March 1931).
- Subhas Chandra Bose wrote that Gandhi did not want to identify himself with revolutionary prisoners.
Gandhi’s defenders
- He raised the case at least five times in five weeks. He wrote again on the morning of the hanging (historian Chander Pal Singh, <i>Gandhi Marg</i>, 2010).
- Asking for suspension was tactics. On 18 February Irwin said it was ‘certainly worth considering’.
- The men refused to seek mercy, and Gandhi opposed the death penalty on principle.
- Irwin had made up his mind. A clause in the pact would likely have sunk the truce without saving them.
What the Viceroy said
- Irwin wrote that he could see no case for commutation that could not be made just as strongly for any other violent crime.
- The sentence came from a lawful tribunal, and the Privy Council had refused to interfere.
- He refused postponement, his minutes say, partly because it would look like a trick on the Congress.
Days after the hanging, Gandhi arrived in Karachi for the Congress session. Young men met him with black flags. The Congress passed a resolution praising the courage and sacrifice of the three. In the same resolution it said again that it rejected political violence. Gandhi told the session he had wanted to save them.
The way of violence can only lead to perdition.Gandhi, Karachi Congress, March 1931
Readers’ poll
Did Gandhi do enough to save Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
A day early
The hanging was set for the morning of 24 March 1931. Instead, the jail moved it up by about 11 hours, to the evening of 23 March.
That afternoon Bhagat Singh was reading a book about Lenin. At about 7 pm (some accounts say 7:30), the three were walked to the gallows. Bhagat Singh was 23, Sukhdev 23, Rajguru 22. By accounts gathered afterwards, they went shouting slogans against British imperialism.
No regular magistrate would supervise. An honorary magistrate from Kasur, Nawab Muhammad Ahmad Khan Kasuri, signed the papers. Lahore has a long memory. In 1974 Kasuri was shot dead in an ambush meant for his son. Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was convicted of ordering it, and hanged in 1979. In 2024 Pakistan’s Supreme Court said Bhutto had not had a fair trial.
Then came the part Punjab has never forgiven. This is the Ferozepur district administration’s account. The jail’s back wall was broken open. The bodies were driven out in secret to the bank of the Sutlej near Ferozepur. Several accounts say they were cut up first. At Hussainiwala they were burned without rites. What remained went into the river.
Villagers saw the fire. The next day relatives and comrades recovered what they could and carried it back to Lahore. There a procession of mourners took it for last rites on the Ravi.
Shops shut across north India. Nehru later wrote that Bhagat Singh had become a symbol: ‘the act was forgotten, the symbol remained’.
Hero or terrorist?
Lahore
Karnal, July 2022. A sitting MP from Punjab told reporters what he thought of Bhagat Singh. Simranjit Singh Mann of the Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) called him a terrorist. Bhagat Singh had killed a young English officer, Mann said, and an Amritdhari, or baptised, Sikh constable, Chanan Singh. And he had bombed the Assembly. Punjab’s AAP ministers demanded an apology. BJP leaders sought a police case. Mann did not back down.
It was not the first fight over the word. In 2016 Bhagat Singh’s family objected to a Delhi University reference book. It was India’s Struggle for Independence by Bipan Chandra and others, and it called him a ‘revolutionary terrorist’. His nephew Abhey Singh Sandhu pointed out that even the British judgment had not used the word. The book’s defenders said historians meant a method, not an insult.
Bhagat Singh answered the charge himself. He did it in a note to young activists, seven weeks before he died.
Apparently I have acted like a terrorist. But I am not a terrorist.Bhagat Singh, ‘To Young Political Workers’, 2 February 1931
In the same note he called mere bomb-throwing useless and sometimes harmful. He asked for patient organising of workers and peasants. He never gave up the pistol. But by the end he no longer believed it could free India on its own.
The argument had raged in his lifetime. In December 1929 the HSRA tried to blow up Lord Irwin’s train near Delhi. After that, Gandhi wrote ‘The Cult of the Bomb’. The HSRA answered with ‘The Philosophy of the Bomb’, written by Bhagwati Charan Vohra.
Three views of the gun
The revolutionaries
- Peaceful protest got Lajpat Rai beaten in the street. A regime that ruled by force could be met with force (HSRA leaflets).
- They chose symbols, and took care not to kill in the Assembly. They said they held human life sacred.
- Revolution meant remaking society, with no place for ‘individual vendetta’ (their court statement, 1929).
- Saunders was a mistake, and Chanan Singh was never the target. Their leaflet said they were sorry for a man’s death.
The colonial state
- Two policemen were murdered in Lahore, one of them an Indian who had beaten nobody.
- Bomb factories in Lahore and Saharanpur showed an organised armed conspiracy.
- The accused were wrecking a lawful trial, so a tribunal was needed to finish it.
- A political motive did not make murder different from any other violent crime, as Irwin put it.
Gandhi and the Congress
- Violence brings repression and puts ordinary people in the line of fire.
- They admired the courage and sacrifice of the young men while rejecting their method (Karachi resolution, 1931).
- Only mass non-violent struggle could bring the Raj down and keep a free India decent.
Readers’ poll
Was the HSRA right to take up arms against British rule?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
A case reopened in Lahore
Lahore
Lahore, 2014. On a court’s order, police went into the old records of the Anarkali police station. They came out with an 85-year-old Urdu document: the FIR, the first police report, on the Saunders killing. It was registered at 4:30 pm on 17 December 1928 against ‘two unknown gunmen’. Bhagat Singh’s name is not in it.
The man who asked for it is Imtiaz Rashid Qureshi, a Lahore lawyer whose family came from Abohar at Partition. His Bhagat Singh Memorial Foundation wants the Lahore High Court to reopen the case and set aside the sentence. It also wants Bhagat Singh given posthumous state honours. Qureshi says the tribunal hanged him without letting his lawyers cross-examine some 450 witnesses. A judge referred the petition for a larger bench in 2013. In September 2023 the High Court objected that it was not maintainable for one. We found no ruling on the merits.
The record cuts both ways. An FIR against unknown gunmen is normal when attackers escape. The witnesses went unchallenged largely because the accused refused to take part. And Bhagat Singh never claimed innocence. A leaflet in his own hand defended the killing. What his supporters can fairly say is that the tribunal was built to convict.
The fight over his name in Lahore is fiercer still. The gallows stood where Shadman Chowk is today. In 2012 the city planned to name the chowk, the square, after him. The Tehreek-e-Hurmat-e-Rasool, linked to Jamaat-ud-Dawa, objected. Pakistan’s squares should honour Muslims, it said. A trader’s petition got the High Court to stop the notification.
In January 2025 the Lahore corporation finally said no. It relied on a report by a retired naval officer that called Bhagat Singh a criminal: ‘In today’s terms he was a terrorist’. Justice Shams Mehmood Mirza of the Lahore High Court dismissed the foundation’s petition. Qureshi said he would go to the Supreme Court. We could not confirm that he has.
Yet weeks earlier, on 30 December 2024, a Bhagat Singh Gallery had opened at Poonch House in Lahore. Punjab’s Chief Secretary, Zahid Akhtar Zaman, opened it. It is full of papers from his trial. Small groups gather in Lahore every 23 March, at times under tight security because of threats. In September 2025 the foundation called him ‘a shared hero of both India and Pakistan’.
Readers’ poll
Should Lahore name Shadman Chowk after Bhagat Singh?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
Two Punjabs, one face
Hussainiwala
Khatkar Kalan, 16 March 2022. A sea of yellow turbans filled the fields. Bhagwant Mann took the oath as Punjab’s chief minister in Bhagat Singh’s ancestral village. He asked his supporters to wear basanti, spring yellow, in Bhagat Singh’s memory. A portrait of Bhagat Singh in a yellow turban went up in his office.
Historians winced. The scholar Chaman Lal has spent decades on Bhagat Singh’s papers. He says only four genuine photographs exist, and in none is he wearing a yellow or saffron turban. The most famous one, in a felt hat, was taken in Delhi in 1929. The family called the row trivial. His ideas mattered, they said, not the colour of a turban.
Everybody claims him. The left quotes his Marx. Sikh groups point to his family and to Bhai Randhir Singh’s memoir. The Congress, the BJP and AAP all hang his picture. An 18-foot bronze of him has stood in Parliament since 2008. On 28 September 2022 Chandigarh’s airport at Mohali took his name.
At Hussainiwala, his cremation ground ended up on Pakistan’s side of the 1947 border. India got it back in 1961 by handing over 12 villages near the Sulemanki headworks. A memorial was opened in 1968. In the 1971 war, Pakistani troops overran it and carried off the busts of the three. They were later recovered through diplomatic channels. Batukeshwar Dutt, who died in 1965, asked to be cremated beside his friends. So did Bhagat Singh’s mother, Vidyawati.
Cinema made him a star. Manoj Kumar played him in Shaheed (1965). Its songs ‘Mera Rang De Basanti Chola’ and ‘Sarfaroshi Ki Tamanna’ are still sung every 23 March. In 2002 three Bhagat Singh films came out within two weeks. Rajkumar Santoshi’s The Legend of Bhagat Singh, with Ajay Devgn, won the National Award for the best Hindi film. Bobby Deol’s 23rd March 1931: Shaheed opened the same day. Both lost money. Rang De Basanti (2006) made him the conscience of a generation of college students.
Our take
Strip away the posters, and three things are true at once.
First, Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru set out to kill a man, and they killed the wrong one. Their commander shot dead a Punjabi constable who was doing his job. Saunders was 21. Chanan Singh’s name barely survives. A story that leaves them out is a legend, not history.
Second, the Raj answered them with a tribunal built to convict. An ordinance took away the right of appeal. An Indian judge was removed after he objected. The hanging was moved up, and the bodies were burned in the dark. A government sure of its justice does not get rid of its prisoners like smuggled goods.
Third, the young man outgrew the gun. By 1931 he was writing that bombs alone were useless. He was calling for unions, study and patience. He went to the gallows at 23, refusing mercy and refusing God. He left behind a jail notebook of ideas that still start arguments in Lahore and Ludhiana.
That is why both Punjabs still fight over him. Nobody fights over a statue that has nothing to say.
Readers’ poll
What should Bhagat Singh be remembered for most?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
Test yourself
8 questions on this story
-
Who was the HSRA’s real target in Lahore on 17 December 1928?
They meant to kill James A. Scott, who ordered the lathi charge on Lala Lajpat Rai. Jai Gopal signalled the wrong man.
-
Which policeman was shot dead while chasing the attackers?
Head constable Chanan Singh, a Punjabi, was killed in the chase. Most accounts say Chandrashekhar Azad shot him.
-
How many people did the Assembly bombs of 8 April 1929 kill?
Nobody. The bombs were thrown onto empty benches, and only a few members were slightly hurt.
-
Who coined the slogan ‘Inquilab Zindabad’?
Hasrat Mohani coined it in 1921. Bhagat Singh and Dutt made it famous in the Assembly.
-
How long had Jatin Das gone without food when he died in Lahore jail?
He died on 13 September 1929, after 63 days. 116 days is how long Bhagat Singh’s own fast lasted.
-
What does the 1928 FIR on the Saunders killing, found in Lahore in 2014, say?
It was registered at 4:30 pm on 17 December 1928 against two unknown gunmen, because the attackers had escaped.
-
Which essay did Bhagat Singh write in jail in October 1930?
He wrote it on 5 and 6 October 1930, after Bhai Randhir Singh told him fame had made him proud.
-
Where were the three secretly cremated?
Their bodies were taken out of Lahore jail in secret and burned on the Sutlej near Ferozepur. The National Martyrs Memorial stands there now.
Play: which came first?
Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.
Questions people ask
When were Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev hanged?
On the evening of 23 March 1931, in Lahore Central Jail. That was about 11 hours earlier than the date set, 24 March. Their bodies were secretly cremated on the Sutlej at Hussainiwala, near Ferozepur.
Why were Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev hanged?
A special tribunal convicted them of murdering Assistant Superintendent of Police John Saunders in Lahore on 17 December 1928. Viceroy Lord Irwin had set it up by ordinance. It sentenced them to death on 7 October 1930. There was no appeal except to the Privy Council, which refused to interfere.
Did Gandhi try to save Bhagat Singh?
The record shows Gandhi raised the case with Lord Irwin on 18 February and again on 19, 21 and 22 March 1931. He wrote to him on the morning of the hanging. At first he asked only for suspension, not commutation. He did not make it a condition of the Gandhi–Irwin Pact. Historians still argue over whether he did enough.
Who was Chanan Singh?
A Punjabi head constable of the Lahore police. He chased the HSRA men after Saunders was shot on 17 December 1928. He was shot dead, by most accounts by Chandrashekhar Azad.
Has a Pakistani court cleared Bhagat Singh’s name?
No. The Bhagat Singh Memorial Foundation has asked the Lahore High Court to reopen the case and set aside the sentence. But in September 2023 the court objected to forming a larger bench to hear it. We found no ruling on the merits.
Was the Assembly bomb meant to kill?
Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt said not. On 8 April 1929 they threw two low-power bombs onto empty benches. They threw leaflets and waited to be arrested. Nobody was killed. A few members, including Sir George Schuster, were slightly hurt.
How we wrote this. We built this story from the trial records, the revolutionaries’ own leaflets, letters and essays, and the reports and books listed below. The TrendingPunjabi desk wrote it in our own words with the help of an AI model. Where sources disagree, we say so. They disagree on Bhagat Singh’s birth date (27 or 28 September 1907); his age at the Jallianwala visit (10, 11 or 12); the time of the hanging (7 or 7:30 pm); who fired the shot that killed Chanan Singh, and how he died; and what Bhagat Singh said to Bhai Randhir Singh. Bipan Chandra’s account of the ‘Lost Leader’ pamphlet is from his book India’s Struggle for Independence. Labels such as ‘terrorist’ and ‘criminal’ are reported as what named people said, not as our description. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.
Sources
- The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Punjabi University: Bhagat Singh (1907–1931), by Emily C. Brown
- The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Punjabi University: Randhir Singh, Bhai (1878–1961), by Gurdev Singh Deol
- Marxists Internet Archive: Bhagat Singh archive: the 1929 Assembly leaflet, court statement, letter to his father, Why I Am an Atheist, To Young Political Workers
- The Anarchist Library: Beware, Ye Bureaucracy (HSRA leaflet, 18 December 1928)
- People’s Archive of Rural India: Our spirit did not break, their empire did, by P. Sainath
- LiveLaw: Legal proceedings that led to the martyrdom of Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru, by Akash Vajpai
- Dawn: A revolutionary’s case, by A.G. Noorani
- mkgandhi.org: What Mahatma Gandhi did to save Bhagat Singh, by Chander Pal Singh (Gandhi Marg, 2010)
- Swarajya: Strange lapses of our eminent historians
- The Tribune: HC notice on plea over memorial fund in Saunders’ name
- The Tribune: Bhagat Singh’s pistol back finally
- The Tribune: Nationalism’s forgotten corner (Hussainiwala)
- The Tribune: Pakistani court objects to reopening case of Bhagat Singh’s sentencing
- Outlook: This Pakistani lawyer is trying to prove Bhagat Singh’s ‘innocence’ in 88-year-old case
- SikhNet (PTI): Renaming of Lahore chowk after Bhagat Singh put on hold
- Gulf News: Bhagat Singh remembered in Pakistan on 87th death anniversary
- The Tribune (PTI): Lahore High Court turns down plea for Bhagat Singh Chowk
- The Tribune: Lahore MC rejects proposal to rename chowk after Bhagat Singh
- The Tribune: Bhagat Singh’s 118th birth anniversary celebrated in Lahore
- Al Jazeera: Pakistan top court says ex-PM Bhutto, hanged in 1979, was denied fair trial
- The Tribune: Sangrur MP Simranjit Singh defends his statement calling Bhagat Singh ‘terrorist’
- The News Minute (PTI): DU book terms Bhagat Singh a ‘revolutionary terrorist’, kin demand changes
- Deccan Herald: Wrongful Bhagat Singh portrait in Bhagwant Mann’s office sparks row
- The Tribune: Chandigarh airport named after Bhagat Singh
- Wikipedia: Bhagat Singh
All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India