Porus and Alexander: The Night Crossing, the Elephants and the King Who Would Not Bow
A Taxila king who opened the door. A river in monsoon flood. A crossing hidden by a storm, elephants that broke Alexander’s lines, and a wounded king who asked to be treated as a king. This is the full story of Alexander in Punjab. Every word of it comes from writers on the invaders’ side, centuries later, and people still fight over who really won.
By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 21 min read 19 views WhatsApp
In short
- In 326 BC Alexander crossed the Indus into Punjab. Ambhi, king of Taxila, welcomed him with silver, cattle and elephants. He also gave Alexander troops to use against his rival, Porus.
- Porus held the Jhelum, swollen by the monsoon. After weeks of fake moves, Alexander crossed some 27 km upstream on a stormy night. He beat Porus’s son. Then he fought Porus’s army and elephants in one of his hardest battles.
- Porus was wounded and captured. The Greek writers say he asked to be treated ‘as a king’. Alexander gave him his kingdom back, and more. Soon after, Alexander’s worn-out army refused to cross the Beas, and turned back.
- Everything we know comes from Greek and Roman writers, centuries later. Indian sources say nothing. No surviving evidence backs the claims that Porus, or Chandragupta Maurya, beat Alexander. But Porus did come out of the war stronger.
At a glance
326 BC- When
- 326 BC. Arrian says the month Munychion (April–May); many historians prefer June or July, in the monsoon
- Where
- The Jhelum river (the Greeks’ Hydaspes), Punjab, in today’s Pakistan; the exact spot is lost
- Who
- Alexander of Macedon, with Ambhi (Taxiles), king of Taxila, against Porus, king of the land between the Jhelum and the Chenab
- Forces
- Porus: 20,000 to over 50,000 infantry and 85 to 200 elephants, depending on the source. Alexander: perhaps 40,000 or more at the river; about 11,000 in the crossing force
- Toll
- Arrian: about 23,000 Indians and about 310 of Alexander’s men killed. Diodorus: 12,000 Indians killed and 9,000 captured, about 1,000 of Alexander’s men killed
- Outcome
- Alexander won the battle; Porus kept his kingdom and gained more. Weeks later Alexander’s army refused to cross the Beas
- Sources
- Only Greek and Roman writers, 290 to 460 years later: Diodorus, Curtius, Plutarch, Arrian, Justin. No Indian source mentions Alexander or Porus
In this story · 15 parts
- 326 BCThunder on the Jhelum
- Part 2Who told us this story
- Spring 326 BCThe king who opened the door
- 326 BCThe king across the river
- 326 BCA game of nerves
- 326 BCAcross in the storm
- 326 BCThe elephants charge
- 326 BC‘Treat me as a king’
- Part 9Who really won?
- 326 BCThe army that said no
- 325 BCAlone on the wall
- 323–303 BCAfter Alexander
- Part 13Six claims, checked
- 327–303 BCFrom the Indus to the Maurya empire
- Part 15Our take
Thunder on the Jhelum
Jhelum river (Hydaspes)
Night on the west bank of the Jhelum, early in the summer of 326 BC. The river is in flood, brown and fast. It is wider than an arrow can fly. Rain comes down in sheets. Each flash of lightning shows men in a wood, stuffing leather hides with hay and sewing them shut.
They are Macedonians, Greeks, Persians and horsemen from Central Asia, thousands of kilometres from home. Their king is Alexander of Macedon. He is 29 or 30 years old, and he has already beaten the Persian empire. The stuffed hides are rafts. His plan is to cross before dawn, hidden by the storm, and land behind the army waiting on the far bank.
On that far bank sleeps the army of a Punjabi king. The Greeks called him Poros. We know him as Porus. He has elephants, and Alexander’s horses will not face them.
By the next evening the two kings would stand face to face. One of the most famous conversations of the ancient world would follow. Or so the story goes. And that is the first thing to know about this story. Almost every word of it was written down by the invaders’ side, and centuries later.
Who told us this story
No book written in India at the time mentions Alexander. None mentions Porus. No Sanskrit text, no Buddhist one, no inscription. In India’s own records, the most famous invasion of its ancient past might never have happened.
Everything we know comes from Greek and Roman writers, and none of them was there. Some men who were there did write memoirs: Alexander’s general Ptolemy, the engineer Aristobulus, the admiral Nearchus and the helmsman Onesicritus. Every one of those books is lost. What survives are later books that used them:
- Diodorus of Sicily, who wrote in Greek about 290 years after the battle.
- Quintus Curtius Rufus, a Roman who wrote in Latin, perhaps 350 to 400 years after.
- Plutarch, the Greek biographer, around 100 AD, some 425 years after.
- Arrian, a Greek officer of the Roman empire, about 460 years after. He is usually trusted most. He says which eyewitness he follows, and tells us when they disagree.
- Justin, a Roman who cut an older, longer history down to a short one, later still.
A word on names. ‘Porus’ is a Greek ear’s version of an Indian name. Many historians think it means the king of the Pauravas, the descendants of the ancient Puru clan of the Rigveda; the scholar Michael Witzel is one. The king of Taxila was called ‘Taxiles’, the man of Taxila; Curtius calls him Omphis and Diodorus Mophis, which Indian writers render as Ambhi. Our sources say Ambhi and Porus were old enemies.
The king who opened the door
In the spring of 326 BC Alexander’s army crossed the Indus on a bridge of boats near Hund, upstream of Attock. Gifts were waiting, Arrian says. They came from the king of Taxila: 200 talents of silver, 3,000 oxen, more than 10,000 sheep for sacrifice and 30 elephants. A talent was a heavy weight of silver. With the gifts came 700 horsemen and an offer to hand over his city.
Taxila stood near today’s Rawalpindi. It was the biggest city between the Indus and the Jhelum, a trading town where roads from Central Asia met. Its new king had made his choice before the invader even arrived.
Plutarch tells their meeting as a scene. The king of Taxila asks Alexander why the two of them should fight. Alexander has not come to take their water or their food. If I am richer than you, the king says, I am ready to share. If I am poorer, I will gladly take your favours.
Why must we war and fight with one another, AlexanderThe king of Taxila, as Plutarch tells it
Alexander loved it. Gifts went back and forth, each king trying to outdo the other. In the end, Plutarch says, Alexander gave him a thousand talents in coin. His own officers grumbled. Taxila’s king kept his throne and gained land. In return he gave Alexander 5,000 soldiers for the march against Porus.
Was Ambhi a traitor? Many Indian textbooks and speeches remember him that way, as the man who opened Punjab’s door. His defenders reply that there was no India to betray in 326 BC. There were only small kingdoms that fought each other all the time. And Taxila had seen what happened to cities that resisted.
It had. A few months earlier, at Massaga in the Swat valley, Indian mercenaries had surrendered. They were soldiers who fought for pay, and the deal was that their lives would be spared. Arrian says they then tried to slip away by night, so Alexander surrounded their hill and cut them down. Plutarch and Diodorus say he simply broke his word.
And this act adheres like a stain to his military career.Plutarch, Life of Alexander 59, on Massaga
Readers’ poll
Ambhi of Taxila welcomed Alexander instead of fighting. What do you make of that?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
The king across the river
Jhelum river (Hydaspes)
Porus ruled the rich land between the Jhelum and the Chenab. It was a doab, the land between two rivers. Today it holds Gujrat, Mandi Bahauddin and Sargodha. The geographer Strabo later wrote that it had almost 300 cities.
Porus refused to come and bow. Alexander’s envoys summoned him. He would meet Alexander, he answered, Curtius says, but at his border and under arms. Then he brought his army to the Jhelum and lined its eastern bank.
The Greek writers make him a giant. Arrian gives his height as a little over five cubits, which would be over two metres. A cubit was the length of a forearm. Plutarch is more modest: four cubits and a span, about six foot three. Either way, Porus sat on his tallest elephant in a coat of mail. He was meant to be seen.
How big was his army? The sources cannot agree. That tells you something about every number in this story.
Porus’s army, according to
- Arrian30,000 infantry, 4,000 cavalry, 300 chariots, 200 elephants
- Diodorusmore than 50,000 infantry, about 3,000 cavalry, over 1,000 chariots, 130 elephants
- Curtiusabout 30,000 infantry, 300 chariots, 85 elephants
- Plutarch20,000 infantry, 2,000 cavalry
Modern historians think Alexander brought perhaps 40,000 men or more to the river. But he faced a problem that no number of men could solve. The Jhelum was in flood.
A game of nerves
Jhelum river (Hydaspes)
Arrian explains why. It was the season, he says, when the sun turns towards the summer solstice, the longest day of the year. Heavy rain fell all over India, and the snows melted in the mountains. In winter a man could wade the river. In summer he could not.
So Alexander played games. He had his boats from the Indus cut into pieces. A small boat made two pieces. A galley, a big warship with oars, made three. Carts dragged the pieces overland, and his men put them back together on the Jhelum. He piled up grain in his camp. Porus’s spies would report that the Macedonians meant to wait for winter.
Night after night his horsemen rode up and down the bank. They shouted and lit fires, as if they were about to cross. Each time, Porus marched his elephants along to meet them. In the end he stopped bothering. That was the point.
When was the battle? Arrian dates it to the Athenian month Munychion, roughly late April to May 326 BC. But his own description of a swollen river and monsoon rain fits June or July better, and many modern historians put it there. The exact spot is lost too. The river has moved over 2,300 years; Arrian’s translator E.J. Chinnock thought the victory town of Nicaea might be Mong and Bucephala Jalalpur, and others prefer sites near Jhelum city.
Across in the storm
Jhelum river (Hydaspes)
The real crossing was planned further up the river. The spot was a wooded headland and an island, about 150 stadia, some 27 km, upstream of the main camp. Alexander left his general Craterus in the camp with a large force and clear orders. Do not cross unless Porus takes his elephants away. The elephants, Arrian has Alexander say, are the only thing that stops the horses landing.
Then came the storm. Rain and thunder drowned the clank of armour and the shouted orders. At first light the hides and boats pushed off. Porus’s sentries saw them only once they were past the island.
Then came a mistake. The men had not landed on the far bank. They were on another island, cut off by a channel. They found a ford, a place shallow enough to wade. The water came up to the men’s chests and the horses’ necks, and they struggled across. Alexander had about 5,000 horsemen and 6,000 foot soldiers with him, Arrian says.
Porus sent his son to stop them. Here even the eyewitnesses disagreed, and Arrian, to his credit, tells us so. Aristobulus said the son came with only about 60 chariots while Alexander was still crossing. He rode past, instead of attacking the men climbing out of the water. Ptolemy, whom Arrian follows, said 2,000 horsemen and 120 chariots. Others said the son wounded Alexander himself and killed his horse, Bucephalus. Arrian does not believe them.
All agree on the end. The chariots stuck fast in the rain-soaked clay. Alexander’s horsemen cut the force to pieces, and Porus’s son was killed. About 400 Indian horsemen died with him. Now the father had to move.
The elephants charge
Jhelum river (Hydaspes) On the History of Punjab timeline →
Porus faced a terrible choice. Across the river, Craterus was getting ready to cross. Downstream, Alexander had already landed. Porus left a few elephants behind to frighten Craterus’s horses. With the rest of his army he marched to meet the king.
He found firm, sandy ground and drew up a line meant to be unbreakable. The elephants stood in front, a plethron (about 30 metres) apart, like towers on a wall. Behind them stood the foot soldiers, ready to push into the gaps. Horsemen and chariots guarded the two ends of the line.
Alexander looked at the elephants and would not attack them head on. He struck at Porus’s left wing with his horsemen. He sent a second force riding round behind it. Attacked from both sides, the Indian horsemen fell back on their own elephants.
Then the elephants charged. Arrian usually writes like an accountant. But he says this battle was unlike any Alexander had fought. Wherever the animals could turn, they tore into the Macedonian phalanx, the tight block of spearmen, dense as it was. Soldiers stabbed at the beasts and threw javelins at their drivers. With their drivers dead and their bodies wounded, the elephants began to panic. They trampled their own side as much as the enemy.
At last, worn out, they backed away, still facing the enemy, Arrian says. They moved like ships rowing backwards, making a shrill piping sound. Alexander closed the ring. Plutarch quotes Alexander’s own letters: the Indians held out until the eighth hour of the day.
How many died? Arrian says nearly 20,000 Indian foot soldiers and 3,000 horsemen. On Alexander’s side he counts about 80 foot soldiers, 10 horse archers, 20 Companion cavalry, his best horsemen, and 200 other riders. Diodorus says more than 12,000 Indians were killed and 9,000 captured, with about 1,000 dead on Alexander’s side. Two of Porus’s sons died, Arrian says, and almost all his commanders.
Modern historians treat Arrian’s count of under 400 dead for the winners with deep suspicion. The British historian A.B. Bosworth warned against taking the Greek accounts at their word. Elephants that broke a phalanx do not leave 80 dead.
‘Treat me as a king’
Jhelum river (Hydaspes) On the History of India timeline →
Porus did not run. Arrian sets him against the Persian king Darius, who fled the battlefield twice. Porus fought on as long as any group of his men still stood. Then an arrow or a javelin struck his right shoulder, the one place his mail did not cover. Only then did he turn his elephant away.
Alexander wanted him alive. He sent a messenger to stop him, and he chose, of all people, the king of Taxila. Porus saw his old enemy riding up, Arrian says. He turned his elephant and hurled a javelin at him. Taxiles galloped off just in time.
Alexander sent more messengers. The last was an Indian named Meroes, an old friend of Porus. Porus listened to him. He was faint with thirst. He climbed down from his elephant and drank some water. Then he told Meroes to take him to Alexander.
Alexander rode out to meet him. Arrian says he admired the Indian king’s height and good looks, and saw that he did not seem broken. He asked Porus how he wished to be treated.
Treat me, O Alexander, in a kingly way!Porus, in Arrian’s Anabasis 5.19 (E.J. Chinnock’s translation)
Alexander was pleased. That would happen for his own sake, he said. But what did Porus want for himself? Everything, Porus answered, was in that one request. Plutarch tells it in two words: ‘Like a king.’
Look at how Arrian brings the story in: ‘The report goes.’ Even he was not sure it was more than a good tale. It is just the kind of line that grows in the telling, and this one had 450 years to grow. But what came next is not in doubt. Porus kept his kingdom, and got more land on top.
Alexander’s horse Bucephalus died after the battle. Arrian says it was old age and exhaustion, at about 30. Others said it was wounds. Alexander founded two towns on the river. One was Nicaea, ‘Victory’, on the battlefield. The other was Bucephala, named for the horse. Neither has been found for certain. And the fight over the victory was only beginning.
Who really won?
In India today, this question starts arguments. Online, and in some popular books, you will read that Porus won and the Greeks covered it up. Here is the case each side makes.
The Hydaspes: who won?
The Greek and Roman writers, and most historians
- Every ancient account that survives says Alexander won. That includes Diodorus and Curtius, who used different sources from Arrian.
- Alexander struck coins in Babylon showing a horseman attacking an elephant. He claimed the victory himself.
- He founded a city called ‘Victory’ on the field. Porus then fought on his side at Sangala.
- The same writers praise Porus’s courage. That would be odd if they were hiding his win, says the classics writer Spencer McDaniel.
Writers who say Porus won, or was not beaten
- Every account comes from the invaders’ side, written centuries later. By nature, they take one side.
- Arrian’s 80 dead foot soldiers are hard to believe. Diodorus’s higher numbers hint at a much bloodier fight.
- Porus lost no land. He kept his kingdom and gained more, as an ally rather than a subject.
- Within weeks Alexander’s army refused to go further. Plutarch says the struggle with Porus blunted their courage.
A view in the middle
- Shiva Sairam, in a 2022 University of Leeds thesis, argues that both men could claim a kind of victory.
- On this view Alexander won the battlefield and Porus won the peace: a bigger kingdom and his enemy’s respect.
- Bosworth and others accept that Alexander won, but warn that the Greek numbers are badly inflated.
Readers’ poll
Who came out ahead at the Hydaspes?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
The army that said no
Beas river (Hyphasis) On the History of Punjab timeline →
Alexander did not stop to argue. He marched east, across the Chenab and the Ravi, deeper into Punjab. Some peoples gave in. Others fought. Sangala was a town of the Kathaioi, and its site is now lost. There, Arrian says, 17,000 Indians were killed and more than 70,000 captured. Porus came to the siege with 5,000 Indians and his remaining elephants. Now he was fighting for Alexander. When it was over, Alexander razed the town to the ground.
Then the army reached the Beas, which the Greeks called the Hyphasis. It stood somewhere upstream of where the river now meets the Sutlej. By then the men had been marching for eight years. Diodorus says rain had fallen for 70 days, with thunder and lightning that never stopped. Their Greek clothes had rotted away, and they wore Indian cloth. Their horses’ hooves were worn down.
And there were rumours. Beyond the river, the soldiers heard, lay the Ganga. Beyond the Ganga were the Nanda kings of Magadha. Diodorus gives the Nanda king 200,000 foot soldiers, 20,000 horsemen, 2,000 chariots and 4,000 elephants. Plutarch makes it 6,000 elephants. Porus himself, Diodorus says, told Alexander that this king was a barber’s son, hated by his people.
Alexander called his officers together and asked them to go on. Nobody spoke. At last an old general stood up. He was Coenus, who had fought beside Alexander from the start. He said what the army felt. They had done enough. They wanted to see their families. The king should lead a fresh army another time. The officers wept and clapped.
Alexander was furious. He would go on, he said, with whoever would follow. He shut himself in his tent for three days, waiting for the army to change its mind. It did not. The camp sat in silence. Then the sacrifices for crossing the river gave bad signs. Alexander announced that the army would turn back.
The soldiers wept for joy and blessed him, Arrian says, because he had let himself be beaten by them alone. On the bank of the Beas they built twelve altars, each as tall as a tower. They marked the end of the world’s greatest conquest. Not one has ever been found. Coenus fell ill and died soon after.
Readers’ poll
Were Alexander’s soldiers right to refuse to cross the Beas?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
Alone on the wall
Multan
The way home lay south, down the Jhelum and the Indus to the sea. Before the fleet left, Alexander made Porus king of all the conquered land between the Jhelum and the Beas. Arrian says it held seven nations and more than 2,000 towns.
Downriver lived the Malli, who refused to give in. In the winter of 326 to 325 BC Alexander stormed their towns one after another. One of them is often placed near today’s Multan, though nobody knows for sure. There his men were too slow with the ladders. Alexander grabbed one himself. He climbed it under his shield and stood alone on top of the wall.
Behind him, the ladders broke under the weight of his guards. Arrows came from every side. So he jumped down into the citadel, among the enemy. Only three men followed him. One was Peucestas, carrying a sacred shield taken from Troy. The others were the bodyguard Leonnatus and a veteran named Abreas.
Abreas was shot in the forehead and killed. Then an arrow went through Alexander’s breastplate into his chest. Ptolemy wrote, Arrian says, that air hissed out of the wound with the blood. Alexander fought on until he fainted. He fell on his shield, with Peucestas standing over him.
At last his soldiers broke in and saw him lying there. They went mad. Arrian is blunt: they killed everyone in the town, not sparing even a woman or a child. Alexander lived after the arrowhead was cut out. But he was never fully well again.
After Alexander
Alexander’s hold on Punjab barely outlasted his march out of it. Philip, the governor he left in the north, was murdered by his own mercenaries. Alexander put Taxila’s king and a Greek officer, Eudemus, in charge. In June 323 BC, in Babylon, Alexander died of a fever. He was 32.
Porus did not live long either. Diodorus says Eudemus killed him by treachery, probably between 321 and 315 BC. Then Eudemus marched west with 120 of his elephants, to fight in the wars between Alexander’s generals. It is a grim end for the king who was treated as a king.
Into the gap stepped a young man the Greeks called Sandrocottus. In 1793 the British scholar William Jones worked out who he was: Chandragupta Maurya. Plutarch says Chandragupta saw Alexander as a youth. Later he said Alexander could easily have taken the Ganga plains, because their king was hated and low-born.
An old story says Chandragupta met Alexander and offended him. It comes from a misreading. The best manuscripts of Justin say he offended ‘Nandrum’, the Nanda king, not ‘Alexandrum’. But Justin does say that after Alexander’s death, Chandragupta led a rising against the Greek governors in India. By around 317 to 312 BC Punjab was part of his growing empire.
In about 305 to 303 BC Seleucus, one of Alexander’s generals, came back across the Indus to take the east back. He failed. Under the peace, Chandragupta got land west of the Indus, and Seleucus got 500 war elephants. Seleucus sent an ambassador, Megasthenes, to the Maurya capital at Pataliputra. (Our long read on the Mauryas tells what came next.) Some writers have tried to match Porus with Parvataka. Parvataka is a northern king, Chandragupta’s ally, in the Sanskrit play Mudrarakshasa, written much later. Nothing proves the match.
Six claims, checked
Twenty-three centuries later, Porus and Alexander are still in politics. In November 2021 Yogi Adityanath, Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh, said history called Alexander great, though Chandragupta Maurya had defeated him. In October 2013 Narendra Modi, then the BJP’s candidate for prime minister, spoke at a rally in Patna. He put Taxila in Bihar and spoke of Alexander being beaten there. Bihar’s chief minister, Nitish Kumar, pointed out that Taxila is in Pakistan. Here are the commonest claims, checked.
Porus defeated Alexander at the Hydaspes
Why people believed it
Porus kept his kingdom, the Greek army soon refused to march on, and the only accounts come from the invaders’ side.
What the record shows
Every ancient account that survives says Alexander won. His own coins show the victory. Porus then fought for Alexander at Sangala. A 2022 Leeds thesis argues Porus ‘won the peace’, not the battle.
BustedNo surviving evidence backs it. What is true: Porus fought hard and came out with more land.
Alexander lost only about 300 men
Why people believed it
It is Arrian’s count, and Arrian is the most trusted ancient writer.
What the record shows
Arrian lists about 310 dead. Diodorus says about 1,000. Arrian himself says the elephants broke the phalanx. Historians such as A.B. Bosworth treat the Greek numbers as exaggerated.
UnprovenAlmost certainly too low. Nobody knows the true toll.
Porus said ‘Treat me as a king’
Why people believed it
It is the most famous line of the whole campaign, in both Arrian and Plutarch.
What the record shows
Arrian brings it in with ‘The report goes’. Plutarch has a shorter version. No eyewitness text survives.
Still openAn old story, widely told. It may have been polished. What is certain is the generous treatment Porus got next.
Porus’s son wounded Alexander and killed Bucephalus
Why people believed it
Some ancient writers said so, and it is popular online.
What the record shows
Arrian records this version and rejects it, following Ptolemy. He says Bucephalus died of old age and exhaustion. Plutarch says most writers blamed wounds.
UnprovenA minority ancient version. The horse died around the time of the battle; how it died is disputed.
Chandragupta Maurya defeated Alexander
Why people believed it
Yogi Adityanath said it in 2021, and it is widely repeated.
What the record shows
No source has the two fight. Chandragupta pushed out Alexander’s governors after 323 BC. Around 305–303 BC he beat Alexander’s general Seleucus. Fact-checkers such as BOOM said the two never met in battle.
BustedFalse as stated. Chandragupta did beat Alexander’s successors, the generals who split his empire.
Alexander reached the Ganga and was beaten in Bihar
Why people believed it
It was said at a rally in Patna in 2013.
What the record shows
Every ancient source says the army turned back at the Beas in Punjab, hundreds of kilometres from the Ganga.
BustedFalse. The Nandas of Bihar frightened the army, but never fought it.
From the Indus to the Maurya empire
The Punjab campaign, step by step
- Spring 327 BCAlexander crosses the Hindu Kush into what is now eastern Afghanistan.
- 327–326 BCMassaga, Aornos and the Swat valley. The surrendered mercenaries are cut down at Massaga.
- Spring 326 BCThe army crosses the Indus near Hund. Taxila’s king welcomes Alexander.
- Summer 326 BC*The night crossing of the Jhelum and the battle with Porus.
- 326 BCSangala falls. The army refuses to cross the Beas; twelve altars are raised.
- Winter 326–325 BCThe fleet sails down the Jhelum. Alexander is nearly killed at a Malli town.
- June 323 BCAlexander dies at Babylon.
- c. 321–315 BCEudemus kills Porus.
- c. 317–312 BCChandragupta Maurya takes Punjab.
- c. 305–303 BCSeleucus gives up the east for 500 elephants.
* Arrian gives the Athenian month Munychion (April–May). Many historians prefer June or July.
Our take
Strip away the speeches and the slogans, and the record still tells an extraordinary story. A Punjabi king was warned that the most feared army on earth was coming. He refused to bow. He held the line of his river through a monsoon. He fought on after his son was killed and his elephants ran mad. His enemy admired him enough to give him back his kingdom.
Alexander won the battle. Every source we have says so, and he struck coins to prove it. But Porus won something too. The men who wrote the story were all on Alexander’s side, and even they could not hide it. Their pages are full of his courage.
The deeper lesson is about evidence. We know this story only through the conqueror’s writers, centuries later. India’s silence left a hole, and slogans now rush to fill it. The honest answer respects both men. The invader won the field. The defender won his enemy’s respect. And within twenty years the Greeks had gone from Punjab, pushed out by an Indian empire.
Test yourself
8 questions on this story
-
What did the Greeks call the Jhelum river?
The Jhelum was the Hydaspes. The Beas was the Hyphasis, the Chenab the Acesines and the Ravi the Hydraotes.
-
Which king welcomed Alexander with gifts, including 30 elephants?
Arrian says the king of Taxila, Ambhi, whom the Greeks called Taxiles, sent silver, cattle, sheep and 30 elephants.
-
What helped hide Alexander’s night crossing of the Jhelum?
Arrian says a furious storm of rain and thunder drowned the noise as the army got ready.
-
Who finally persuaded the wounded Porus to come to Alexander?
Porus threw a javelin at the king of Taxila. He listened to his friend Meroes.
-
What did Alexander name the town he founded on the battlefield?
Nicaea stood on the battlefield. Bucephala, named for his horse, was where the crossing started.
-
At which river did Alexander’s army refuse to go further?
The army refused at the Beas, which the Greeks called the Hyphasis. Twelve altars were raised there.
-
Where was Alexander nearly killed by an arrow?
He leapt alone into a Malli citadel, often placed near Multan, and was shot through the chest.
-
What did Seleucus receive from Chandragupta Maurya in their peace deal?
Around 305–303 BC Seleucus gave up land west of the Indus in return for 500 elephants.
Questions people ask
Who won the Battle of the Hydaspes?
Every ancient account that survives says Alexander won, and he struck coins to celebrate it. But Porus fought so hard that Alexander gave him back his kingdom and added more land. So some modern writers argue that Porus ‘won the peace’. The surviving sources give no support to the claim that Porus won the battle.
Where was the Battle of the Hydaspes fought?
On the Jhelum river, which the Greeks called the Hydaspes, in Punjab, in today’s Pakistan. Nobody knows the exact spot. Suggestions range from near Jhelum city to Jalalpur and Mong.
What did Porus say to Alexander?
Alexander asked how he wished to be treated. In Arrian’s account Porus replied, ‘Treat me, O Alexander, in a kingly way.’ Plutarch gives it as ‘Like a king’. Arrian begins the story with ‘the report goes’, so it may have been polished in the telling.
Who was Ambhi of Taxila?
He was the king of Taxila. The Greeks called him Taxiles, and Curtius and Diodorus call him Omphis or Mophis. He welcomed Alexander with gifts and troops. He was an old enemy of Porus.
Why did Alexander turn back at the Beas?
His army refused to go on. The men had marched for eight years. Diodorus says it had rained for 70 days. And they heard of huge Nanda armies beyond the Ganga. After three days in his tent, and bad omens, Alexander gave in.
Did Chandragupta Maurya fight Alexander?
No source says so. Plutarch says Chandragupta saw Alexander as a youth. After Alexander died in 323 BC, Chandragupta pushed out the Greek governors. Around 305–303 BC he beat Alexander’s general Seleucus, who gave up land for 500 elephants.
How we wrote this. We built this story from the ancient texts and the modern studies and reports listed below. The TrendingPunjabi desk wrote it in our own words with the help of an AI model. Every account of this war was written by Greek and Roman authors, between about 290 and 460 years after it. They used eyewitness memoirs that are now lost. No Indian source of the time mentions Alexander or Porus. The ancient writers disagree on the size of Porus’s army, on the death tolls, on what happened to Porus’s son and to Bucephalus, and on the month of the battle. Modern historians disagree on where it was fought. We give each version and say whose it is. Quotations from Arrian and Plutarch are from public-domain and Loeb English translations. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.
Sources
- Project Gutenberg: The Anabasis of Alexander, by Arrian (E.J. Chinnock’s translation, 1884), Books 5 and 6
- LacusCurtius, University of Chicago: Life of Alexander, chapters 59–61, by Plutarch (Loeb translation)
- LacusCurtius, University of Chicago: Life of Alexander, chapters 62–65, by Plutarch (Loeb translation)
- LacusCurtius, University of Chicago: Library of History, Book 17, by Diodorus of Sicily (Loeb translation)
- Wikipedia: Battle of the Hydaspes (citing Arrian, Curtius, Diodorus, Plutarch and J.F.C. Fuller)
- Wikipedia: Porus (citing A.B. Bosworth, Michael Witzel, H.C. Raychaudhuri and Waldemar Heckel)
- Wikipedia: Indian campaign of Alexander the Great
- Wikipedia: Chandragupta Maurya (citing Justin, Plutarch, Strabo, Thomas Trautmann and Sushma Jansari)
- University of Leeds, White Rose eTheses: Warfare, Diplomacy and Elephants: A Reinterpretation of the Battle of the Hydaspes and its Consequences, by Shiva Sairam (MA thesis, 2022)
- Tales of Times Forgotten: Did King Porus Defeat Alexander the Great?, by Spencer McDaniel
- BOOM: Yogi Adityanath claims Chandragupta Maurya defeated Alexander: fact check
- Deccan Herald: Yogi’s call for terming Chandragupta ‘great’ triggers row
- Business Standard: Modi: Stumbling on history (IANS comment)
- India TV: Nitish takes jibe at Modi’s mistakes on history
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatchPaid placement · Promote your video
All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India