1. Home
  2. History
  3. People
  4. Vallabhbhai Patel
Biography

Sardar Patel: The Farmers’ Leader Who Became India’s Iron Man

A Gujarati farmer’s son taught himself law, gave up a rich practice to lead the farmers of Kheda and Bardoli, and stepped aside for Nehru in 1946. As Home Minister he faced the Partition killings, brought more than 500 princely states into India, sent the army into Hyderabad and banned the RSS, and India still argues over every one of those choices.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 20 min read WhatsApp

1875–1950about 75 years

India’s first Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister, who led the farmers of Bardoli and brought the princely states into India

Born
31 October 1875, Nadiad, Gujarat
Died
15 December 1950, Birla House, Bombay
Also known as
Sardar Patel · Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel · Iron Man of India · Vallabhbhai Jhaverbhai Patel
Sardar Patel: The Farmers’ Leader Who Became India’s Iron Man
Photo: Government of India work · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • Vallabhbhai Patel was born at Nadiad, Gujarat, on 31 October 1875, the date he gave himself; he taught himself law and became a barrister in London.
  • He gave up his practice to lead the Kheda farmers in 1918, and in 1928 won the Bardoli tax campaign, where the women of Bardoli named him ‘Sardar’.
  • In 1946 twelve of fifteen Pradesh Congress Committees nominated him for Congress president, but he withdrew at Gandhi’s request and Nehru led the interim government.
  • As Home Minister he faced the Partition killings in Punjab and Delhi in 1947, and as Minister for the States, with V.P. Menon, brought more than 500 princely states into India.
  • He sent the army into Hyderabad in September 1948 and rejected the Sunderlal report on the killing of Muslims that followed; his ministry banned the RSS after Gandhi’s murder and lifted the ban in 1949.
  • He died in Bombay on 15 December 1950. He was given the Bharat Ratna in 1991, and the 182-metre Statue of Unity was unveiled in his honour in 2018.

At a glance

1875–1950
Born
31 October 1875 (the date he entered himself; it was never officially recorded), Nadiad, Gujarat
Died
15 December 1950, Birla House, Bombay, aged 75, after a second heart attack
Parents
Jhaverbhai Patel and Ladba, Leva Patidar farmers from Karamsad; one of six children
Married
Jhaverba, who died in 1909; he never remarried
Children
Maniben Patel (born 1903) and Dahyabhai Patel (born 1905)
Studied
Taught himself law to become a pleader; barrister of the Middle Temple, London
Offices
President of the Indian National Congress (Karachi, 1931); Home Minister from 1946; Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for the States, 1947–1950
Known for
Kheda (1918) and Bardoli (1928) satyagrahas; integrating the princely states; the RSS ban of 1948; the IAS and IPS
Honours
Bharat Ratna (1991, after his death); Statue of Unity (2018); his birthday is National Unity Day
In this story · 12 parts
  1. 1875–1909A note in the courtroom
  2. 1910–1917The wrong Mr V.J. Patel
  3. 1917–1927Kheda: giving it all up
  4. 1928Bardoli, and the name ‘Sardar’
  5. 1930–1939In jail with Gandhi
  6. 1942–1945‘The opportunity of a lifetime’
  7. Apr 1946–Jun 19471946: the post he gave up
  8. Aug–Nov 1947Fire in Punjab
  9. 1947–1949Five hundred kingdoms
  10. 1948–1949Gandhi’s last afternoon, and the RSS ban
  11. 1949–15 Dec 1950The last letter
  12. 1950–todayThe Iron Man, and who owns him
Part 1

A note in the courtroom

Nadiad

A court in Gujarat, 1909. A lawyer is cross-examining a witness when someone hands him a note. He reads it, folds it, puts it in his pocket and carries on. He wins the case. Only when the court rises does he tell anyone what the note said. His wife, Jhaverba, had died that day in a Bombay hospital after an operation for cancer.

That is how people who were there remembered Vallabhbhai Patel. He was 33. He never married again.

He was born in Nadiad, in what is now Kheda district of Gujarat. Nobody wrote the date down. When he sat his school-leaving exam he entered his birthday as 31 October 1875, and that is the date India still keeps. His father, Jhaverbhai, and mother, Ladba, were Leva Patidar farmers from Karamsad, a village near Anand. He was one of their six children.

He was not a star pupil. He went to school in Nadiad, Petlad and Borsad, often living with other boys away from home, and passed his matriculation late, at 22. His elders thought he would end up in some ordinary job. A story told about him all his life says that as a boy he lanced his own painful boil without a flinch, while the barber who was meant to do it stood trembling. It is a family legend, but it is the kind people told about him.

He had his own plan. He borrowed law books from other lawyers, taught himself, and passed the law exams within two years. He set up home in Godhra with Jhaverba, and later practised in Borsad and Anand. Their daughter, Maniben, was born in 1903 and their son, Dahyabhai, in 1905. When plague swept Gujarat he nursed a sick friend, caught it himself, sent his family away and recovered alone in an empty house.

Part 2

The wrong Mr V.J. Patel

London

His dream was to become a barrister in England. He saved for years. When the passport and ticket finally came, they were addressed to ‘V.J. Patel’. His elder brother, Vithalbhai Jhaverbhai Patel, had the same initials and the same dream. It would be a disgrace, Vithalbhai said, for an elder brother to follow a younger one. Vallabhbhai let him go first.

His own turn came after Jhaverba died. At 36 he sailed for London and joined the Middle Temple. He finished a 36-month course in 30 months and came top of his class, though he had never been to college.

Back in India he settled in Ahmedabad and became one of the city’s most successful barristers. He wore English suits and played a sharp game of bridge. He meant to get rich and educate his children in English schools. He had agreed with Vithalbhai that his brother would go into politics while he earned for the family.

Part 3

Kheda: giving it all up

Kheda On the History of India timeline →

Mohandas Gandhi had settled in Ahmedabad, and in 1917 he led the Champaran struggle for indigo farmers in Bihar. In September Patel spoke at Borsad in support of Gandhi’s petition for self-rule. In October Patel met him for the first time, at a political conference in Godhra, and became secretary of the Gujarat Sabha, a local political body.

Kheda district had lost its crop to heavy rain in 1917. By the rules, farmers whose harvest had failed this badly should not have had to pay the land tax that year. The officials collected it anyway. Gandhi backed a campaign but was busy in Champaran, and asked for someone from Gujarat to give his whole time to it. Patel said yes. It meant giving up his practice and his plans.

In 1918 he went village to village, telling farmers what refusing to pay would cost them: their cattle, their pots, perhaps their land. They refused anyway. The government seized property and arrested many. In the end it suspended the tax for the year. Patel came out a hero in Gujarat.

Now he threw himself in. When Gandhi called for non-cooperation in 1920, Patel threw his English clothes on a bonfire in Ahmedabad and he and his children switched to khadi. As president of the Gujarat Congress, a post he held until 1945, he signed up some three lakh members. As head of Ahmedabad’s municipality in 1922, 1924 and 1927 he spread electricity and drains, and led relief when floods drowned Kheda in 1927.

Part 4

Bardoli, and the name ‘Sardar’

Bardoli

Bardoli, Surat district, 1928. The government of Bombay had raised the land tax in the taluka by 22 per cent, though famine had hit Gujarat. The farmers came to Patel. He warned them they could lose everything, and said he would not lead them unless every village agreed. They agreed.

From February he ran the campaign like a general. He split the taluka into zones, each with a leader and volunteers, and planted informers near the officials. The government sent bands of Pathans to seize cattle and houses. Farmers locked their buffaloes inside their homes. A volunteer with a bugle watched every road. When the bailiffs came, he blew, and the whole village vanished into the fields. Houses and land were put up for auction, and almost nobody in Gujarat would bid.

A black-and-white photograph of a meeting under a decorated cloth canopy, with Gandhi sitting cross-legged in a white cap and a man in white seated on a bench beside him, and other men and women around them
Gandhi and Patel (in white, beside him) at Bardoli during the satyagraha of 1928. Photographer unknown.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In August the government gave in. It cancelled the increase, brought back the village officers who had resigned and returned the land and goods it had seized. During the struggle and after it, the women of Bardoli began calling Patel ‘Sardar’: leader, chief. The name stuck so firmly that India still uses it more than his own.

Part 5

In jail with Gandhi

Poona On the History of India timeline →

In March 1930, as Gandhi set out on the Salt March, Patel was arrested at the village of Ras and tried without a lawyer or a witness. In 1931 he presided over the Congress at Karachi, which promised a free India fundamental rights, a minimum wage and an end to untouchability.

In January 1932 the British arrested Gandhi and Patel again and locked them up together in Yerwada jail at Poona. For months they were together. Gandhi taught him Sanskrit. They read the epics and joked. Gandhi’s secretary, Mahadev Desai, wrote down their talks. When Gandhi fasted that September against separate electorates for the untouchables, Patel nursed him and refused food himself. The fast ended with the Poona Pact, signed by Gandhi’s great opponent on the question, B.R. Ambedkar.

In October 1933 Vithalbhai died in Geneva. The British offered Patel a short release to attend the cremation. He refused it. He came out of jail in July 1934.

Over the next years he became the Congress’s organiser-in-chief. He raised the money, chose candidates for the elections of 1934 and 1936–37 and kept the party’s ministries in line. He clashed with the young Jawaharlal Nehru over socialism in 1936, and in 1939 led the senior leaders against Subhas Chandra Bose. Bose’s supporters said Patel was acting like an autocrat. His admirers said he was holding the Congress together.

Part 6

‘The opportunity of a lifetime’

Bombay On the History of India timeline →

Bombay, Gowalia Tank maidan, 7 August 1942. More than a lakh of people have come to hear the Congress leaders. Patel had pushed harder than anyone in the Working Committee for an all-out campaign to drive the British out. He had said he would resign if it was not approved. Now he told the crowd that when the leaders were arrested, every Indian must do his utmost, within non-violence. “This is going to be the opportunity of a lifetime,” he said, in the words reported from that day.

Two days later he was arrested with the rest of the Working Committee and taken to Ahmednagar Fort. He spent almost three years there. He spun cloth, played bridge, read and gardened, and grieved for Mahadev Desai and Kasturba Gandhi, who both died in detention. He was freed on 15 June 1945. By then the British were getting ready to leave.

Part 7

1946: the post he gave up

New Delhi

In April 1946 the Congress had to choose a new president. Whoever held the post, as things turned out, would be asked to lead India’s interim government. Gandhi had told Maulana Azad, the outgoing president, that if asked he would prefer Jawaharlal Nehru.

The Pradesh Congress Committees, which by the rules nominated the president, saw it differently. Twelve of the fifteen named Patel. None named Nehru. J.B. Kripalani found a few Working Committee members to propose Nehru. Then Gandhi asked Patel to withdraw. He did. Nehru became president, and later that year head of the interim government, with Patel as Home Minister.

A black-and-white photograph of three men seated close together on a white mattress on a stage, Nehru in a white cap on the left, Gandhi bare-chested in the middle and Patel in a white shawl leaning in from the right, with a large painted poster behind them
Nehru, Gandhi and Patel at the All India Congress Committee meeting in Bombay in 1946. Photograph by Kulwant Roy.Photo: Kulwant Roy · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Was he cheated? People have argued about it ever since, often for reasons that have more to do with today’s politics than with 1946.

Patel or Nehru? The 1946 argument

Patel should have led India

  • Twelve of fifteen Pradesh Congress Committees nominated him, and none nominated Nehru; Nehru’s election was due to Gandhi’s intervention, wrote Nehru’s own biographer Michael Brecher, and Patel was ‘robbed of the prize’.
  • Maulana Azad wrote in India Wins Freedom that not backing Patel in 1946 was one of the great mistakes of his life.
  • C. Rajagopalachari wrote in 1971 that it would have been better if Nehru had been Foreign Minister and Patel Prime Minister.

Nehru was the right choice, and Patel agreed

  • The historian Rajmohan Gandhi, Patel’s biographer, says the committees were choosing a party president, not a prime minister, and Patel had been ill and was 14 years older.
  • Gandhi’s reasoning, as Rajmohan Gandhi gives it, was that Nehru would not take second place but Patel would, and that the two would pull together like ‘two oxen yoked to the governmental cart’.
  • In a speech at Indore in October 1950, Patel himself said Gandhi’s choice of Nehru had been right.

Readers’ poll

Should Patel have been India’s first Prime Minister?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

As Home Minister in the interim government, Patel came to believe that the Muslim League’s ministers would block the Congress at every turn, while killings spread from Calcutta to Punjab. He became one of the first Congress leaders to accept Partition. At the meeting of June 1947 that voted on it, he put it bluntly: “The choice is between one division and many divisions.”

Part 8

Fire in Punjab

Amritsar On the History of Punjab timeline →

On 31 August 1947 Patel flew to Jullundur to try to protect and evacuate East Punjab’s Muslims. On the way there and back, he wrote to Nehru the next day, he saw several villages on this side of the Sutlej in flames. He admitted the savagery in East Punjab as well as in the West. On 3 September he flew to Lahore, where he, Nehru, Jinnah and Liaquat Ali Khan looked together at what their quarrel had done.

Then Delhi caught fire too. Refugees poured in from West Punjab with stories of murder. Muslims were killed in the capital’s streets, including one near Patel’s own house. On 7 September he had orders issued to shoot rioters on sight. When some Sikh and Rajput soldiers attacked Muslims instead of protecting them, he brought in troops from the Madras regiment. He kept in close touch with Master Tara Singh, whose word counted with angry Sikhs. His secretary, V. Shankar, recalled the day Patel wrapped his shawl round his neck and went to the shrine of Nizamuddin Auliya, where frightened Muslims were sheltering. He spent three quarters of an hour there and told the police officer that, on pain of dismissal, he would hold him responsible if anything happened.

That autumn he went to Amritsar, where reports said Sikh bands were preparing to attack Muslim refugee convoys heading west. He met Sikh and Hindu leaders, and then spoke to a huge crowd of refugees.

Here, in this same city, the blood of Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims mingled in the bloodbath of Jallianwala Bagh.Vallabhbhai Patel to refugees at Amritsar, autumn 1947, as reported

He asked them to let the convoys pass in peace and give a truce for the exchange of refugees. To attack helpless people, he said, was no fight at all. Accounts say the convoys crossed Amritsar safely after that.

A black-and-white photograph of a bald older man in a white dhoti and shawl smiling at a man in a white cap and long dark coat, with a young woman in a patterned sari beside them, in a garden
Patel with Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi in New Delhi, November 1947. Government of India Photo Division.Photo: photodivision.gov.in · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Not everyone saw him as a peacemaker. Maulana Azad and other Muslim leaders accused him of caring more for Hindu and Sikh refugees than for Muslims, and of being happy to see Muslims leave. Hindu and Sikh leaders accused him of going too easy on Pakistan. His biographer Rajmohan Gandhi puts it this way.

Vallabhbhai’s was a Hindu heart. He was, unquestionably, roused more by a report of fifty Hindu or Sikh deaths than by another of fifty Muslim deaths. But his hand was just.Rajmohan Gandhi, <em>Patel: A Life</em> (1990), as excerpted in Scroll
Part 9

Five hundred kingdoms

Patiala On the History of India timeline →

Patel was 71. On top of Home, he had taken charge of a new States Department in July 1947. Its job was the hardest on the map. More than 560 princely states, from Hyderabad, as big as Britain, to Kathiawar holdings of a few acres, would in law be free to go their own way when the British left.

His secretary, V.P. Menon, drafted the documents and did most of the bargaining. Patel invited the rulers to lunch and tea at his house, appealed to their patriotism, and made sure they knew that Delhi held the railways, coal and posts they depended on. Lord Mountbatten, the last Viceroy, used his charm on the princes. The deal on offer was simple: hand over only defence, foreign affairs and communications, and keep the rest. By 15 August 1947 almost every state inside India’s borders had signed.

Three did not. In Junagadh, a Hindu-majority state on the Gujarat coast, the Nawab joined Pakistan. India blockaded it, the Nawab fled to Karachi, and on 13 November 1947 Patel spoke to a crowd at Bahauddin College and visited the ruined Somnath temple, promising to rebuild it. In Kashmir, Maharaja Hari Singh signed only when raiders from Pakistan were near Srinagar in October 1947. Patel and the Defence Minister, Baldev Singh, ran the military effort, including a road from Pathankot. Speaking at Junagadh, Patel even said India would have agreed to Kashmir going Pakistan’s way if Pakistan had agreed about Hyderabad.

Then came the second stage: merging the small states into bigger units. In Punjab, Patiala and seven other states became the Patiala and East Punjab States Union, PEPSU. Patel inaugurated it at Patiala on 15 July 1948, swearing in Maharaja Yadavindra Singh as its Rajpramukh, or governor.

A black-and-white photograph of a bearded man in a white turban and white coat standing at a microphone, beside an older bald man in glasses reading from a paper
Patel swears in the Maharaja of Patiala as Rajpramukh, inaugurating the Patiala and East Punjab States Union at Patiala on 15 July 1948. Photographer unknown; published in V.P. Menon’s book in 1956.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Hyderabad, ruled by the Nizam and in the grip of the Razakar militia, held out longest. Nehru wanted talks first; Patel, by most accounts, had little patience for them. On 13 September 1948 the army went in. India called it a police action; the army called it Operation Polo. In about 108 hours it was over.

What came after is the darkest page of Patel’s record. A goodwill mission that Nehru sent under Pandit Sunderlal estimated that at least 27,000 to 40,000 Muslims were killed during and after the operation, some by soldiers. Patel rejected the report. A goodwill mission was never the government’s business, he wrote, and its findings lacked ‘balance and proportion’; the killings, officials said, were a reaction to Razakar crimes. The report was kept from the public for decades. The scholar A.G. Noorani called Patel’s objections disingenuous.

Junagadh, Kashmir’s signature in the night, PEPSU and the fall of Hyderabad are told in full in our long read <a href="/news/princely-states-integration-patel-hyderabad-junagadh-full-story">How 560 Kingdoms Became India: Patel, Menon, Junagadh, Kashmir and the Fall of Hyderabad</a>.

By 1949 the map of more than 550 states had become 14 units. That, above all, is why India calls Patel the Iron Man.

Part 10

Gandhi’s last afternoon, and the RSS ban

New Delhi On the History of India timeline →

Delhi, Birla House, Friday 30 January 1948. Patel had been quarrelling with Nehru over Kashmir, the princes and much else, and had asked Gandhi to let him leave the government. That afternoon they talked for a long time. Gandhi told him to stay: free India needed both men. The talk made Gandhi late for his prayer meeting. Minutes after Patel left, Nathuram Godse shot Gandhi dead.

Critics said Patel’s Home Ministry had failed to protect Gandhi, and he wrote out his resignation. His secretary persuaded him not to send it. Nehru wrote to remind him of their thirty years together, and the two men stood side by side in public. Within two months Patel had a serious heart attack. He blamed the grief he had bottled up.

On 4 February 1948 his ministry banned the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the RSS, to ‘root out the forces of hate and violence’, as its order said. Patel, who ran the investigation, told Nehru the RSS was not involved in the murder itself. But in a letter that September he told the RSS chief, M.S. Golwalkar, that its speeches had been full of communal poison, that the country had lost Gandhi as a final result of that poison, and that RSS men had distributed sweets after his death.

The RSS has always said it had nothing to do with the murder, that Godse had left it, and that the ban was lifted because no evidence was found against it. The ban was lifted on 11 July 1949, after Golwalkar agreed to a written constitution promising loyalty to the Constitution and the flag and no place for violent or secret methods.

The plot, the trial and the long argument over who was to blame are told in our long read <a href="/news/gandhi-assassination-1948-full-story">Who Killed Gandhi</a>.

He was shaping the new Constitution too. He chaired the Assembly’s committees on minorities and on fundamental rights. On 25 May 1949 he asked the Assembly to drop reserved seats for religious minorities, and keep them only for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The committee, he said, felt a special responsibility for the feelings of the Sikh community, which had suffered so much from the partition of Punjab. He also fought to protect the new Indian Administrative Service and Indian Police Service, which he called a steel frame. A civil servant, he had told probationers in April 1947, must not take part in politics or in communal quarrels.

The people in his life

  • Jhaverbhai Patel and LadbaHis parents, farmers of the Leva Patidar community from Karamsad
  • JhaverbaHis wife; died in a Bombay hospital in 1909
  • Maniben PatelHis daughter, born 1903; his companion and nurse in his last years
  • Vithalbhai PatelHis elder brother and fellow politician, who went to England in his place; died in Geneva in 1933
  • Mohandas GandhiHis leader for thirty years; asked him to step aside for Nehru in 1946
  • Jawaharlal Nehru56 in 1946Prime Minister; partner, rival and fellow builder of the new state
  • V.P. MenonSecretary of the States Department, who did most of the bargaining with the princes
  • M.S. GolwalkarRSS chief, with whom he corresponded over the 1948 ban
Part 11

The last letter

Bombay On the History of India timeline →

On 29 March 1949 a small Indian Air Force plane carrying Patel, Maniben and the Maharaja of Patiala from Delhi to Jaipur lost an engine and came down in the Rajasthan desert. Nobody was hurt. Patel walked with the others to a village and found the local officials. When he came back to Parliament, members gave him a standing ovation that stopped business for half an hour.

His body was failing. In 1950 he and Nehru clashed again, over who should be President and who should lead the Congress. China marched into Tibet that October. On 7 November 1950 Patel sent Nehru a long letter of warning. China, he wrote, did not see India as a friend.

Even though we regard ourselves as friends of China, the Chinese do not regard us as their friends.Vallabhbhai Patel to Jawaharlal Nehru, 7 November 1950

Twelve years later, in 1962, China and India went to war. Patel did not see it. After 2 November 1950 he was mostly in bed. On 12 December he was carried onto a plane in a chair and flown to Bombay. Nehru, Rajagopalachari, Rajendra Prasad and Menon saw him off at the Delhi airport.

On 15 December 1950 he had a second heart attack and died at Birla House, Bombay. He was 75. He had asked to be cremated like a common man, at Sonapur, where his wife and brother had been cremated, and that is where a crowd of about a million people followed him. The next day more than 1,500 officers of the civil and police services gathered at his house in Delhi and pledged their loyalty to India. Nehru declared a week of national mourning.

Part 12

The Iron Man, and who owns him

Kevadia

For decades Patel’s memory was quieter than Nehru’s. He was given the Bharat Ratna only in 1991, forty years after his death. His daughter Maniben lived on in a Bombay flat and ran his memorial trust. On his advice, Kheda’s dairy farmers had set up their own co-operative, which grew into Amul.

Then he became a giant, in every sense. In 2014 the government made his birthday, 31 October, Rashtriya Ekta Diwas, National Unity Day. On 31 October 2018 Prime Minister Narendra Modi unveiled the Statue of Unity near the Sardar Sarovar dam on the Narmada. At 182 metres it is the tallest statue in the world.

A giant bronze statue of a man in a long shawl and dhoti standing on a tall base, seen from a wide paved walkway lined with white pillars and visitors, under a hazy sky
The Statue of Unity near Kevadia, Gujarat, 182 metres tall, unveiled on Patel’s birthday in 2018. Photographed by Snehrashmi in December 2018.Photo: Snehrashmi · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Today every party wants him. The BJP celebrates him as the strong, practical patriot Nehru overshadowed. The Congress reminds people that he was a lifelong Congressman, Gandhi’s loyal lieutenant, and the Home Minister who banned the RSS. Both are true. In Telangana, people still argue over what to call 17 September 1948: liberation, integration, or a day of grief.

Claim 1

Patel was elected Prime Minister in 1946 and Gandhi overturned the vote

Why people believed it

Twelve of fifteen Pradesh Congress Committees nominated him.

What the record shows

They nominated him for Congress president, not prime minister. Whoever was president was likely to lead the interim government. Gandhi asked Patel to withdraw and he did.

Still openHalf true. He was the party’s choice for president; there was no vote for prime minister.

Claim 2

Patel would have kept all of Kashmir if Nehru had let him

Why people believed it

He ran the military effort and opposed taking the dispute to the UN.

What the record shows

He did advise against going to the UN. But at Junagadh in November 1947 he said India would have agreed to Kashmir going to Pakistan if Pakistan had agreed about Hyderabad.

UnprovenNot proven, and his own words point both ways.

Claim 3

Patel was anti-Muslim

Why people believed it

Muslim leaders, Azad among them, accused him of partiality in 1947.

What the record shows

He spoke harshly to Muslims and Hindus alike, guarded the Nizamuddin shrine and ordered rioters shot; he also dismissed the Sunderlal report on the killing of Muslims in Hyderabad.

Still openArgued over to this day; his biographer says his heart was Hindu and his hand just.

Claim 4

Patel was a friend of the RSS

Why people believed it

Today’s RSS and BJP honour him.

What the record shows

His ministry banned the RSS in 1948, and he wrote that its communal poison led to Gandhi’s death. He lifted the ban in 1949 once it adopted a written constitution.

BustedBusted. He banned it and criticised it sharply.

Claim 5

Operation Polo was bloodless

Why people believed it

The fighting was over in about 108 hours, with light Indian losses.

What the record shows

The government’s own Sunderlal mission estimated at least 27,000 to 40,000 Muslims killed during and after it.

BustedBusted.

Readers’ poll

What was Patel’s greatest achievement?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Vallabhbhai Patel, 1875–1950

  1. 31 Oct 1875Born at Nadiad, Gujarat (the date he gave himself).
  2. 1909His wife Jhaverba dies; he carries on with his case.
  3. 1910–1913Studies at the Middle Temple, London; tops his class.
  4. Oct 1917Meets Gandhi at Godhra.
  5. 1918Leads the Kheda farmers’ refusal to pay tax.
  6. 1928Wins the Bardoli satyagraha; becomes ‘Sardar’.
  7. 1931Presides over the Karachi Congress.
  8. 1932–1934In Yerwada jail with Gandhi.
  9. 7 Aug 1942Speaks at Gowalia Tank; arrested two days later.
  10. Apr 1946Nominated for Congress president by 12 of 15 committees; withdraws for Nehru.
  11. Aug–Sep 1947Home Minister through the Partition killings.
  12. 1947–1949Brings the princely states into India; PEPSU inaugurated 15 July 1948.
  13. 4 Feb 1948His ministry bans the RSS after Gandhi’s murder.
  14. 13–17 Sep 1948Operation Polo in Hyderabad.
  15. 7 Nov 1950Warns Nehru about China.
  16. 15 Dec 1950Dies at Birla House, Bombay, aged 75.
  17. 1991Bharat Ratna, awarded after his death.
  18. 31 Oct 2018The Statue of Unity is unveiled.

He read the note in court, put it in his pocket and finished the case. That was the man: grief kept for later, the job done first. India is still arguing about the jobs he did. It is also still living inside the map he drew.

Test yourself

6 questions on this story

  1. Who gave Vallabhbhai Patel the title ‘Sardar’?

  2. Why did Patel’s brother go to England before him?

  3. How many Pradesh Congress Committees nominated Patel for Congress president in 1946?

  4. Which union of Punjab states did Patel inaugurate at Patiala in July 1948?

  5. What was the army’s name for the takeover of Hyderabad in 1948?

  6. What did Patel warn Nehru about in his letter of 7 November 1950?

Questions people ask

When was Sardar Patel born?

His birthday is given as 31 October 1875, at Nadiad in Gujarat. The date was never officially recorded; he entered it himself on his school-leaving exam papers. India marks it as National Unity Day.

How did Sardar Patel die?

He died of a heart attack, his second, at Birla House in Bombay on 15 December 1950, aged 75. He had been ill for more than a year.

Why is Vallabhbhai Patel called Sardar?

Sardar means leader or chief. The women of Bardoli began calling him that during and after the 1928 campaign he led against a rise in the land tax.

Why is Patel called the Iron Man of India?

For the firmness with which, as Home Minister and Minister for the States, he brought more than 500 princely states into India between 1947 and 1949, using persuasion, money and, in Hyderabad, the army.

Why did Patel not become Prime Minister?

In 1946 twelve of fifteen Pradesh Congress Committees nominated him for Congress president, whose holder was expected to lead the interim government. Gandhi preferred Nehru and asked Patel to withdraw, and he did. Historians still argue over whether it was a lost chance or the right decision.

Did Sardar Patel ban the RSS?

Yes. His Home Ministry banned the RSS on 4 February 1948, after Gandhi’s assassination. He said the RSS was not involved in the murder itself but blamed its communal poison for the atmosphere. The ban was lifted on 11 July 1949 after the RSS adopted a written constitution.

How tall is the Statue of Unity?

182 metres, the tallest statue in the world. It stands near the Sardar Sarovar dam in Gujarat and was unveiled on 31 October 2018.

What did Patel do for Punjab?

He toured East Punjab during the 1947 killings and appealed to refugees at Amritsar to let Muslim convoys pass, and on 15 July 1948 he inaugurated PEPSU, the union of Patiala and the other East Punjab princely states.

How we wrote this. Researched from Rajmohan Gandhi’s biography Patel: A Life (as excerpted in Scroll), the Constituent Assembly debates, the government communiqués and letters on the RSS ban reproduced by The Wire, Patel’s letter of 7 November 1950, the published accounts of the 1946 Congress election by Michael Brecher, Maulana Azad and Rajmohan Gandhi, our own long reads on the princely states, Gandhi’s assassination, Quit India and the Partition of Punjab, and the other sources listed below, and written in our own words by the TrendingPunjabi desk with the help of an AI model. Where sources disagree we say so: his birth date (the one he gave himself); the story of the boil, which is family legend; what the 1946 nominations meant; the exact date and words of his Amritsar speech in the autumn of 1947, which we give as reported; the Hyderabad death toll, which ranges from a few thousand to far higher, the Sunderlal mission’s estimate being at least 27,000 to 40,000; and whether the RSS ban was lifted on Patel’s terms or the RSS’s. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Vallabhbhai Patel
  2. Wikipedia: Kheda Satyagraha
  3. Wikipedia: Bardoli Satyagraha
  4. Scroll.in: ‘I say bitter things to Hindus and Muslims alike’: extract from Rajmohan Gandhi’s Patel: A Life
  5. ThePrint: Jawaharlal Nehru’s election as India’s first prime minister wasn’t unanimous
  6. The News Minute: Was Nehru unanimously elected as India’s first Prime Minister? (citing Rajmohan Gandhi, Azad and Michael Brecher)
  7. The Tribune: Congress cites Rajmohan Gandhi to set Nehru-Patel record straight
  8. Wikipedia: Political integration of India
  9. Wikipedia: Annexation of Hyderabad
  10. The Wire: When Sardar Patel took on the ‘forces of hate’ and banned the RSS
  11. Wikipedia: Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh
  12. Constitution of India archive (CLPR): Constituent Assembly Debates, 25 May 1949
  13. The Quint: Patel’s letter to Nehru on Tibet: ‘Chinese do not regard us as friends’
  14. Friends of Tibet: Sardar Patel’s letter to Pandit Nehru, 7 November 1950 (full text)
  15. Statue of Unity: Statue of Unity (official site)
  16. Wikipedia: Statue of Unity
  17. Wikipedia: Maniben Patel
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India