1. Home
  2. History
  3. Gandhi’s assassination
History

Who Killed Gandhi: The Fast, the Bomb, the Ten Lost Days and the Shots at Birla House

A fast for Delhi’s Muslims. Fifty-five crore for Pakistan. A bomb ten days before the end, and a police force that was handed a name and did nothing. This is the full story of 30 January 1948: the men from Poona, the Red Fort trial, Gandhi’s sons who asked for mercy, the RSS ban, the Kapur Commission and the modern cult of Godse, told from every side.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 22 min read 3 views WhatsApp

Who Killed Gandhi: The Fast, the Bomb, the Ten Lost Days and the Shots at Birla House
Photo: Hideyuki KAMON · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • On 30 January 1948 Nathuram Godse shot Gandhi dead at his evening prayer meeting at Birla House, Delhi. Twelve days earlier Gandhi had ended a fast for peace between Delhi’s Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims.
  • Ten days before the killing, a Punjabi refugee, Madanlal Pahwa, set off a blast at the same spot and was caught. He gave the police enough to trace Godse. The Kapur Commission later blamed the police for lethargy and inefficiency.
  • Godse and Narayan Apte were hanged at Ambala on 15 November 1949, though Gandhi’s sons Manilal and Ramdas asked for mercy. Savarkar was acquitted. The Kapur Commission later pointed to ‘Savarkar and his group’.
  • The RSS was banned for 17 months and never charged. Whether Godse had left it is still disputed. His glorification by some Hindu nationalists is still a political fight.

At a glance

30 Jan 1948
When
30 January 1948, about 5.17 pm; an earlier attempt failed on 20 January
Where
The prayer ground at Birla House (now Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi
Killed
Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, 78, shot three times with a Beretta pistol
Killer
Nathuram Godse, 37, editor of the Poona paper Hindu Rashtra
Trial
Special Court, Red Fort, verdict 10 February 1949; East Punjab High Court, Simla, 21 June 1949
Hanged
Nathuram Godse and Narayan Apte, Ambala Central Jail, 15 November 1949
Life terms
Vishnu Karkare, Madanlal Pahwa and Gopal Godse, released October 1964
Acquitted
V.D. Savarkar (at trial); Dattatraya Parchure and Shankar Kistayya (on appeal). Digambar Badge was pardoned as approver
RSS
Banned 4 February 1948, ban lifted 11 July 1949; never charged
Inquiry
Kapur Commission, appointed 1966, reported 30 September 1969
In this story · 17 parts
  1. 20 Jan 1948A bang at the back wall
  2. 1948Who’s who
  3. 9 Sep 1947Delhi, the winter of the refugees
  4. 13–18 Jan 1948The last fast
  5. 15 Jan 1948Fifty-five crore
  6. Jan 1948The men from Poona
  7. 20–30 Jan 1948Ten days of warnings
  8. 30 Jan 1948Friday, 5.17 pm
  9. 31 Jan–4 Feb 1948The light has gone out
  10. 1948–49The Red Fort trial
  11. 21 Jun 1949Appeal in the hills
  12. 15 Nov 1949The sons who asked for mercy
  13. 4 Feb 1948–11 Jul 1949The ban
  14. 1966–69The Kapur Commission
  15. 2014–2026Godse’s long afterlife
  16. Part 16Claims, myths and what the record says
  17. Part 17Our take
Part 1

A bang at the back wall

Birla House (Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi

Birla House, New Delhi, Tuesday 20 January 1948. A frail old man sits on a low wooden platform in the garden of a businessman’s mansion. He is talking to a few hundred people about peace. He is 78. Two days earlier he ended a fast that nearly killed him.

Then, against the back wall behind him, something explodes. Smoke rises. People scramble.

Mahatma Gandhi barely looks round. At first, his secretary Pyarelal later told an inquiry, Gandhi took it for army practice nearby. Only afterwards did he say aloud what it was: a plot to kill him.

The police caught one man on the spot. He was Madanlal Pahwa, a 20-year-old refugee from West Punjab. Gandhi asked them not to harass him. He called him a misguided youth, who should be won over with persuasion and affection.

Madanlal talked. There were others, he told the police. He spoke of a man from Ahmednagar, and of the editor of a Marathi paper in Poona. The others had fled.

Ten days later, one of them came back with a pistol. This is the story of those ten days, and of the men who planned the murder. It is the story of the trial and the hangings. And it is the story of a fight over blame that India is still having.

Part 2

Who’s who

The accused, and the man they killed

  • Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi78The Mahatma. Living at Birla House, Delhi, since September 1947
  • Nathuram Vinayak Godse37Editor of the Poona paper Hindu Rashtra, earlier Agrani. Fired the shots. Hanged 1949
  • Narayan Dattatraya Apte36Godse’s partner on the paper, a former teacher. Hanged 1949
  • Vishnu Ramkrishna KarkareRan a guest house in Ahmednagar. Life term, released 1964
  • Madanlal Kashmirilal Pahwa20Refugee from Pakpattan, West Punjab. Set off the 20 January blast. Life term, released 1964
  • Gopal Vinayak GodseNathuram’s younger brother. Life term, released 1964
  • Digambar Ramchandra BadgePoona arms dealer. Turned approver and was pardoned
  • Shankar KistayyaBadge’s servant. Convicted, then acquitted on appeal
  • Dr Dattatraya Sadashiv ParchureGwalior doctor and Hindu Mahasabha man. Convicted, then acquitted on appeal
  • Vinayak Damodar Savarkar64Hindutva ideologue and former Hindu Mahasabha president. Tried and acquitted
Part 3

Delhi, the winter of the refugees

Birla House (Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi On the History of Punjab timeline →

Gandhi had meant to go to Punjab. He reached Delhi from Calcutta on 9 September 1947. Sardar Patel, the Home Minister, told him what was happening in the capital itself. So he stayed.

Delhi that winter was a city of people who had lost everything. Hindu and Sikh families had fled the massacres in West Punjab. They slept in camps and on pavements. They slept in homes and mosques that Delhi’s Muslims had abandoned or been driven from. The Muslims who stayed were crowded into a few quarters, afraid to step out. Our long read on the Partition of Punjab tells how that exodus began.

Every evening at five, Gandhi held a prayer meeting in the Birla House garden. Anyone could walk in. Hindu, Muslim and Christian prayers were read. Some in the crowd objected loudly to the verses from the Quran.

His message never changed. Muslims who chose India must be safe in India. Mosques that had been seized must be given back. To refugees who had lost everything, it sounded like taking the other side.

An old black and white photograph of a crowd seated on the ground in a garden at an outdoor prayer meeting, with Gandhi among them
One of Gandhi’s evening prayer meetings in the garden of Birla House, New Delhi, December 1947 or January 1948.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Part 4

The last fast

Mehrauli shrine of Qutbuddin Bakhtiar Kaki

On 12 January 1948, at his prayer meeting, Gandhi made an announcement. He would begin a fast the next day, with no set end. He meant it, he said, to quicken conscience, not deaden it. He would end it only when peace returned to Delhi.

He was 78 and had fasted many times. But within days his doctors were alarmed. Crowds gathered outside Birla House. Some prayed. According to evidence before the later Kapur Commission, others shouted a different slogan at Hindu Mahasabha meetings that month. It was marta hai to marne do: if he is dying, let him die.

Black and white photograph of Gandhi lying on a cot under a white sheet during his fast, with people seated around him
Gandhi during his last fast, Delhi, 13–18 January 1948.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

On 18 January more than a hundred people came to his bedside. They spoke for Delhi’s communities, and they brought a signed pledge. Rajendra Prasad led them. Among those who signed were the Hindu Mahasabha, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and the Jamiat-ul-Ulema-e-Hind. Pakistan’s High Commissioner, Zahid Hussain, was in the room. They made four promises. The first was about the Urs, the yearly festival at the shrine of the Sufi saint Khwaja Qutbuddin Bakhtiar Kaki in Mehrauli. It would be held as before. Muslims could move freely in Subzi Mandi, Karol Bagh and Paharganj. Occupied mosques would be returned. And Muslims who had fled could come home.

Then Gandhi broke his fast, with a glass of orange juice.

Black and white photograph of Gandhi, bare-chested with a shawl, among a crowd of men at a shrine
Gandhi at the shrine of Qutbuddin Bakhtiar Kaki in Mehrauli on 27 January 1948, three days before he was shot. Its reopening was one of the promises that ended his fast.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Part 5

Fifty-five crore

Birla House (Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi On the History of India timeline →

Into all this fell a sum of money. It is still argued over on Indian social media every January.

When British India was divided, its cash had to be split too. On 8 December 1947 India and Pakistan agreed on Pakistan’s share of the cash balances: 75 crore rupees. Twenty crore had already been paid. Then tribal fighters backed by Pakistan’s army poured into Kashmir, and Indian troops were fighting them. So India decided to hold back the last 55 crore. Patel defended the decision in public.

Lord Mountbatten, the Governor-General, told Gandhi it was wrong to withhold money India had agreed to pay. Gandhi agreed. On 15 January, two days into the fast, the government announced it would carry out the cash agreement immediately. Its statement spoke of sharing the world-wide anxiety over the fast.

So did Gandhi fast to make India pay Pakistan? Not in his own words. His announcement, and the pledge that ended the fast, are about peace in Delhi. But the money was paid because of the fast. And his killers saw it that way.

Readers’ poll

Was India right to pay Pakistan the 55 crore in January 1948, in the middle of the Kashmir war?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 6

The men from Poona

Poona (Pune) On the History of Punjab timeline →

In Poona, two hundred kilometres from Bombay, two men ran a small Marathi daily. Nathuram Godse, 37, was its editor. Narayan Apte was its manager. Apte was a science graduate and former schoolteacher, who had served in the Royal Indian Air Force during the war. The paper started in 1944 as Agrani. It was renamed Hindu Rashtra to escape closure. Savarkar had kept it alive with donations. He was the founder of the idea of Hindutva, ‘Hindu-ness’, and their political hero.

Godse had been in the RSS in the 1930s, and in the Hindu Mahasabha. In 1942 he formed a small group of his own, the Hindu Rashtra Dal. To these men, Partition was Gandhi’s fault, and his concern for India’s Muslims was betrayal.

They had met Gandhi before. In July 1944 a group of Poona youths heckled him at Panchgani. The Times of India named their spokesman as N.D. Apte. Gandhi’s followers later said Godse rushed at him with a dagger. The Kapur Commission found only the report of heckling.

Others joined. There was Vishnu Karkare, an orphan who ran a guest house in Ahmednagar. There was Digambar Badge, a Poona arms dealer, and his servant Shankar Kistayya. And there was Gopal Godse, Nathuram’s brother.

And there was Madanlal Pahwa. He was born in 1927 at Pakpattan, in Montgomery district of West Punjab, now in Pakistan. In 1947 he crossed the new border in a refugee caravan. He found his family again at Ferozepur. Decades later he gave interviews to the scholar Ashis Nandy’s team. He said he had attacked Muslims in Gwalior and Bombay before Karkare took him up in Ahmednagar. Partition made him; the plot used him.

On 13 January, the day the fast began, the plotters began to move. By 20 January seven of them were in Delhi: Godse, Apte, Karkare, Badge, Kistayya, Gopal Godse and Madanlal. Here was the plan. A blast at the back wall would cause panic. Then would come grenades and pistol shots at the old man on the platform.

It fell apart. Madanlal lit the guncotton slab, a block of explosive. Badge, it was later said, lost his nerve. Nobody threw a grenade or fired a shot. Everyone else fled, and Madanlal was caught.

Part 7

Ten days of warnings

Bombay (Mumbai)

This is the hardest part of the story. And all of it is in the official record.

That night, Madanlal talked to the Delhi police. There was a gang, he said. One man was from Ahmednagar. Another was the editor of a Poona paper, Agrani or Hindu Rashtra. There was only one such editor: Nathuram Godse.

On 21 January, in Bombay, a Hindi professor named Jagdish Chandra Jain went to see two men. One was the Premier, B.G. Kher, the head of Bombay’s government. The other was the Home Minister, Morarji Desai. Weeks earlier Madanlal had confided the plan to Jain, and Jain had told no one in authority. Now he did. The Kapur Commission found that Desai passed it on with ‘commendable promptitude’ to Deputy Commissioner J.D. Nagarvala. That night Nagarvala put a watch on Savarkar’s house.

The watch caught nobody. Godse and Apte were in Bombay and Poona for days. Then they went north again. In Gwalior they collected a Beretta pistol. By 29 January they were in Delhi.

In Delhi the police put more men at Birla House. They asked to search everyone coming into the prayer meetings. Gandhi would not allow it. Without searches, the police said, they could not spot one man with a small pistol in a crowd. The Kapur Commission did not accept that excuse.

Either it was sheer inefficiency or lack of will.Pyarelal, Gandhi’s secretary, to the Kapur Commission, on the police failure to trace Madanlal’s associates

The commission listed three great failures of the Delhi police. They gave Gandhi no unobtrusive protection, the quiet kind that does not show. They posted no Bombay officers who knew the plotters by sight, to act as spotters. And they made no effort to identify the owner of Hindu Rashtra and set the Poona police on his trail. The commission called the watch on Savarkar’s house ‘most inefficient’. And it agreed with a senior official, R.N. Banerjee: the police had been guilty of lethargy and inefficiency.

Part 8

Friday, 5.17 pm

Birla House (Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi On the History of India timeline →

Friday, 30 January. Gandhi spent the late afternoon in a long talk with Sardar Patel. It was part of his effort to keep Patel and Prime Minister Nehru working together. The talk made him late for prayer. He hated that.

He came out leaning on his grandnieces, Abha and Manu. Manu later recorded how he scolded the two girls. They were his timekeepers.

I do not like being late for the prayer meeting.Gandhi, 30 January 1948, as recorded by Manu Gandhi

He walked up the few steps into the prayer ground. A man in a khaki jacket pushed forward through the crowd. Manu thought he wanted to touch Gandhi’s feet, and told him they were late. By her account, he pushed her aside. Then Nathuram Godse fired three shots at point-blank range, into Gandhi’s chest and stomach. Manu’s watch said 5.17.

Gandhi fell. Herbert Reiner, a young American vice-consul, grabbed the gunman by the shoulders. Men of the Royal Indian Air Force and the police took the pistol from him. Godse did not try to run. Apte and Karkare had been in the crowd. They slipped away.

He was carried inside Birla House. Within the half-hour he was dead. Most eyewitnesses say his last words were ‘He Ram’, O God.

A line of stone footprints set into a lawn, leading across the garden of Gandhi Smriti
At Gandhi Smriti, the old Birla House, stone footprints trace Gandhi’s last walk to the prayer ground.Photo: Hideyuki KAMON · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Part 9

The light has gone out

Raj Ghat, Delhi

That night Nehru spoke to the country on the radio.

The light has gone out of our lives.Jawaharlal Nehru, radio broadcast, 30 January 1948

Across India, people waited in dread to hear who the killer was. Had he been a Muslim, many feared, the killing of 1947 would have started again. Then word came that he was a Hindu from Maharashtra. That news spared India a return to the killing.

The next day huge crowds followed his body to Raj Ghat, on the Yamuna, for the cremation.

Then came another kind of revenge. This story usually leaves it out. Godse was a Chitpavan Brahmin, from a Brahmin community of Maharashtra’s Konkan coast. In Poona, Satara, Sangli and other towns, mobs attacked Brahmin families who had nothing to do with him. They looted and burned their homes. Morarji Desai later recorded that Brahmins were attacked, and their property destroyed, in several places. People were killed; nobody has an agreed count. In Bombay a crowd tried to set fire to Savarkar’s house, until the police arrived.

On 4 February the government banned the RSS. Police arrested Savarkar in Bombay. In mid-February they picked up Apte and Karkare there too.

Part 10

The Red Fort trial

Red Fort, Delhi

The trial was held in a special court set up inside the Red Fort in Delhi. The judge was Atma Charan. The charge sheet, the formal list of charges, was filed on 27 May 1948. Nine men stood in the dock. Three more were declared absconders, men on the run, and were never tried: Gangadhar Dandavate, Gangadhar Jadhav and Suryadeo Sharma.

On 21 June Digambar Badge was pardoned and turned approver. An approver is an accused who gives evidence against the others. Badge spoke of meetings and weapons. He spoke of a visit with Godse and Apte to Savarkar’s house in Bombay. His evidence became the spine of the prosecution, which called 149 witnesses.

On 8 November 1948 Godse read out a statement of 150 paragraphs. He said he alone had decided on the killing. He blamed Gandhi for Partition, and for what he called appeasement of Muslims. And he named the fast as the final provocation.

the accumulating provocation of 32 years culminating in his last pro-Muslim fastNathuram Godse, statement to the Special Court, 8 November 1948

The statement later spread widely in books, including one brought out by his brother Gopal. In 2017 the Central Information Commission ordered the National Archives to put it online.

Judgment came on 10 February 1949. Nathuram Godse and Narayan Apte were sentenced to death. Five more were convicted and given life terms: Karkare, Madanlal, Gopal Godse, Kistayya and Parchure. Savarkar was acquitted. The case against him rested on Badge alone. The judge held it would be unsafe to convict on an approver’s word without independent corroboration, other evidence to back it up.

A large white colonial-style building with a sloping red roof among pine trees on a hillside
Peterhoff in Shimla, once the seat of the East Punjab High Court, where the appeal was heard in 1949. The original building burned in 1981; this is the rebuilt version, now a hotel.Photo: Utkarshraj Atmaram · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Part 11

Appeal in the hills

Peterhoff, Shimla

The appeal went to the East Punjab High Court. After Partition the court had moved from Lahore to Peterhoff, an old viceregal lodge in Simla. Three Punjab judges heard the appeal from 2 May 1949: A.N. Bhandari, Achhru Ram and G.D. Khosla.

Nathuram Godse did not appeal against his death sentence. He appealed only against the conspiracy verdict. He insisted he had acted alone, and he argued his case in person.

Justice Khosla later wrote about the scene in court. The audience was visibly moved, he wrote, and women were in tears. Had they been the jury, he thought, they would have found Godse not guilty by an overwhelming majority. That was his comment on the power of the speech, not on the evidence. Khosla himself voted to uphold the conviction.

On 21 June 1949 the court upheld the convictions of five men: Nathuram Godse, Apte, Karkare, Madanlal and Gopal Godse. It acquitted two. One was Parchure, whose confession it would not trust, since he had taken it back. The other was Kistayya, against whom it found too little on the conspiracy. Two of the judges recommended leniency for the youngest, Gopal Godse and Madanlal, because of their age. The Privy Council in London refused leave to appeal.

Part 12

The sons who asked for mercy

Ambala Central Jail

Gandhi had preached against killing all his life. Two of his sons held to that.

Manilal Gandhi and Ramdas Gandhi asked for the death sentences on Godse and Apte to be commuted, changed to a lighter punishment. Ramdas also wanted to meet Godse. In June 1949 Nehru wrote to him, advising against the visit. He did not think it could serve any useful purpose, he wrote. Nehru, Patel and the Governor-General, C. Rajagopalachari, turned down the pleas for mercy.

Godse, for his part, had never appealed against his own death sentence. The family’s view has lasted. In 2015 Gandhi’s grandson Gopalkrishna Gandhi asked mercy for another condemned man. His opposition to the death penalty, he said, was a conviction against reprisal punishment, not a matter of any one case.

The morning of 15 November 1949, Ambala Central Jail, East Punjab. Nathuram Godse and Narayan Apte were led to the gallows. Godse called out ‘Akhand Bharat’, undivided India. Apte answered ‘Amar rahe’, may it live forever. They were hanged together.

Godse had asked that his ashes be kept. They were to be scattered in the Indus only in a reunited India. In 2015 his family in Pune told Business Standard it still kept the urn.

Readers’ poll

Gandhi’s sons asked for Godse and Apte to be spared. Should they have been hanged?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 13

The ban

Birla House (Gandhi Smriti), New Delhi

On 4 February 1948 the government banned the RSS. It said it wanted to root out the forces of hate and violence at work in the country. The RSS chief, M.S. Golwalkar, was arrested, and thousands of members were jailed.

Nehru suspected the RSS. Patel was the one who ran the investigation. On 27 February 1948 he wrote to Nehru that the RSS was not involved in the murder itself.

a fanatical wing of the Hindu Mahasabha directly under SavarkarSardar Patel to Nehru, 27 February 1948, on who hatched the conspiracy

But Patel did not let the RSS off. In July 1948 he wrote to Syama Prasad Mookerjee of the Hindu Mahasabha. The RSS and the Mahasabha, he wrote, had created an atmosphere in which such a tragedy became possible. In September he wrote to Golwalkar. RSS speeches, Patel wrote, were full of communal poison, and the country had lost Gandhi as a result. RSS men, he added, had distributed sweets after his death.

The RSS ban: what each side says

What the government said, 1948–49

  • Patel wrote that RSS and Mahasabha propaganda had created the atmosphere that made Gandhi’s murder possible.
  • Patel told Golwalkar the RSS had celebrated the death, with sweets distributed.

What the RSS said

  • Godse had left the RSS in the 1930s for the Hindu Mahasabha. Godse himself said in court that he had left.
  • No court charged the RSS, and Patel himself wrote that it was not involved in the murder.
  • According to its weekly <i>Organiser</i>, Golwalkar called the killing a national misfortune. He sent condolences to Nehru, Patel and Gandhi’s son Devdas, it says, and shut all shakhas, the RSS’s local branches, for 13 days of mourning.
  • The ban, it argues, was lifted because no evidence was found against the organisation.

In December 1948 the RSS launched a satyagraha, a peaceful protest, against the ban. In 1949 Golwalkar accepted a written constitution for the RSS. It promised loyalty to the Constitution and the flag. It had no place for people who believed in violent or secret methods. The ban was lifted on 11 July 1949.

Did Nathuram Godse ever really leave the RSS? That is still argued over. In 1994 his brother Gopal spoke to Frontline. All the Godse brothers had been in it, Gopal said. Nathuram’s denial in court, he said, was to protect the organisation, which was in deep trouble.

he did not leave the RSSGopal Godse on his brother, <i>Frontline</i>, January 1994

The journalist Dhirendra K. Jha has argued from RSS records that Godse stayed linked to it. The RSS has always said he left. In August 2026 Satyaki Savarkar spoke in a Pune court. He is Savarkar’s grandnephew and a grandson of Gopal Godse. Under cross-examination, he said that both brothers were active RSS members. An RSS worker has also brought a defamation case against Rahul Gandhi. It is over a 2014 speech in which he blamed the RSS for the murder. It was still being heard in Bhiwandi as we wrote.

Part 14

The Kapur Commission

Poona (Pune)

In October 1964 Gopal Godse, Karkare and Madanlal walked free. On 12 November there was a celebration for them in Pune. There G.V. Ketkar, a grandson of Bal Gangadhar Tilak, said something startling. Nathuram, he said, had told him of his plan to kill Gandhi months ahead. Parliament erupted.

A first inquiry was held under G.S. Pathak. Then Jivanlal Kapur, a retired Supreme Court judge, took over on 21 November 1966. He heard 101 witnesses, Morarji Desai and Nagarvala among them. He reported on 30 September 1969.

Kapur found that Ketkar had known of the danger in advance. He confirmed the police failures. And he heard what the trial court never did. Savarkar’s bodyguard, Appa Kasar, and his secretary, Gajanan Damle, had made statements, recorded in March 1948. They spoke of visits by Godse and Apte to Savarkar in January. Those statements were never produced at trial. Taken together, Kapur wrote, the facts pointed only to a conspiracy to murder ‘by Savarkar and his group’.

Savarkar had died in 1966 and could not answer. In 2018 the Supreme Court noted that this was a commission’s observation, and could not overturn his acquittal. In law, Savarkar is innocent. In history, the question is open.

On the RSS, Kapur wrote that it was anti-Gandhian in ideology. But its anti-Gandhism, he wrote, did not seem to go to the extent of personally harming Mahatma Gandhi. He recorded the view of R.N. Banerjee, the Home Secretary in 1948: the RSS as such were not responsible for the murder. The conspirators, Kapur found, came from the Hindu Rashtra Dal circle of Savarkar’s followers.

Part 15

Godse’s long afterlife

Gwalior

For decades, few in India said Godse’s name without shame. That has changed.

The Hindu Mahasabha has marked 30 January as ‘Shaurya Divas’, a day of valour. In 2017 it put a bust of Godse in a ‘temple’ in its Gwalior office, which the authorities had removed. On 30 January 2019 a Mahasabha leader, Pooja Shakun Pandey, was filmed in Aligarh. She fired an air pistol at an effigy of Gandhi before it was burned. Within a week she and her husband were arrested. In January 2021 a ‘Godse study centre’ opened in Gwalior. The district administration shut it within days.

May 2019. Pragya Singh Thakur was the BJP’s candidate in Bhopal. She was then an accused in the 2008 Malegaon blast case; a special court acquitted her in July 2025. She called Godse a patriot. Under pressure from her party, she apologised. Prime Minister Narendra Modi said he would never forgive her in his heart. She won the seat. That November she made a similar remark in the Lok Sabha, and apologised again.

Godse’s admirers call him a patriot who gave his life for an undivided India. His critics see nothing patriotic in shooting an old man at prayer. The BJP’s own leaders are among those critics.

When it comes to publishing Godse’s words, India has chosen openness. In 2017 the Information Commissioner, M. Sridhar Acharyulu, ordered the statement put online.

we cannot refuse disclosure or circulation of his opinionInformation Commissioner M. Sridhar Acharyulu, 2017

Readers’ poll

Should people who praise Nathuram Godse in public face legal action?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 16

Claims, myths and what the record says

Claim 1

Gandhi went on fast to force India to pay Pakistan 55 crore

Why people believed it

The government released the money during the fast, and Godse named the fast as his final reason.

What the record shows

His announcement, and the pledge that ended the fast, are about peace in Delhi, not money. But he did think India should pay. And the government paid during the fast, citing anxiety over it.

Still openHalf true. The money was not his stated condition, but the fast is why it was paid when it was.

Claim 2

Savarkar was found guilty of Gandhi’s murder

Why people believed it

His name is tied to the plot, and the Kapur Commission pointed at him.

What the record shows

The Special Court acquitted him in 1949 for want of corroboration, other evidence to back up the approver. In 1969 the Kapur Commission saw a conspiracy by him and his group, on evidence never put at trial. The Supreme Court said in 2018 that this cannot overturn the acquittal.

BustedFalse in law: he was acquitted. Historians still argue over his role.

Claim 3

Godse was an RSS member when he shot Gandhi

Why people believed it

Congress leaders have said so for decades; the RSS denies it.

What the record shows

Godse told the court he had left. His brother Gopal said in 1994 that he never left. Savarkar’s grandnephew said in court in 2026 that both brothers were active members. No court has ruled on it.

Still openDisputed. He was certainly in the RSS in the 1930s.

Claim 4

There was a fourth bullet and a second gunman

Why people believed it

A 2017 petition said a photograph and accounts suggested it.

What the record shows

The Supreme Court’s amicus, an adviser to the court, checked the record and the museum exhibits. The amicus found three wounds, three shots, one gunman. The court dismissed the petition on 28 March 2018.

BustedNo evidence.

Claim 5

Gandhi’s last words were ‘He Ram’

Why people believed it

It is carved on his memorial at Raj Ghat.

What the record shows

Manu Gandhi, Abha Gandhi and an eyewitness at the trial, Sardar Gurbachan Singh, said he said it. In 2006 his aide V. Kalyanam said he had not. He later explained that he simply had not heard it.

On the recordMost eyewitnesses say yes.

Part 17

Our take

The record is clear on what happened. A group of men planned for weeks to kill a 78-year-old man. They came from one political world: the Hindu Mahasabha and Savarkar’s circle. Their first attempt failed. Then the police were handed a name, a town and a newspaper. Still they did not stop them. That is a failure of the state, and the Kapur Commission said so.

The record is also clear that Gandhi chose his risks. He refused searches at his prayers. Delhi was full of Hindu and Sikh refugees who had lost everything. He fasted for its Muslims all the same, knowing how that looked to them. Their grief was real. So was the courage of a man who would not trade one community’s safety for another’s anger.

What is not settled is how far the blame travels beyond the men in the dock. Three places are argued over: Savarkar, who was acquitted; the RSS, banned and then allowed back; and the politics of hate that Patel described. Weigh the evidence yourself.

One thing should not be in doubt. Gandhi’s own sons asked that his killers be allowed to live. Whatever you think of Gandhi, there is nothing brave about shooting an unarmed old man on his way to prayer.

Readers’ poll

Who bears the most blame for failing to protect Gandhi?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. Who set off the blast at Birla House on 20 January 1948?

  2. What did the pledge that ended Gandhi’s fast promise about the shrine at Mehrauli?

  3. Where was the appeal in the Gandhi murder case heard?

  4. Where were Godse and Apte hanged?

  5. Why was Savarkar acquitted at the trial?

  6. What did Gandhi’s sons Manilal and Ramdas ask for?

  7. What did the Supreme Court say in 2018 about the ‘fourth bullet’ theory?

Play: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

Who killed Mahatma Gandhi?

Nathuram Vinayak Godse, a 37-year-old Hindu nationalist editor from Poona. He shot Gandhi three times at Birla House, New Delhi, at about 5.17 pm on 30 January 1948. He was convicted with others of murder and conspiracy, and hanged at Ambala on 15 November 1949.

Why did Godse kill Gandhi?

In his statement to the court, Godse blamed Gandhi for Partition and for what he called appeasement of Muslims. He said Gandhi’s last fast was the final provocation. That fast led India to release 55 crore rupees to Pakistan.

Was Savarkar convicted?

No. The Special Court acquitted him in February 1949. The evidence against him came only from the approver, Digambar Badge, with nothing independent to back it up. In 1969 the Kapur Commission saw a conspiracy by ‘Savarkar and his group’. But the Supreme Court said in 2018 that this cannot overturn the acquittal.

Was the RSS involved?

The RSS was banned from February 1948 to July 1949, but never charged. Sardar Patel wrote that the conspiracy was hatched by a wing of the Hindu Mahasabha under Savarkar, and that the RSS was not involved in the murder itself. He also blamed the RSS for spreading the hatred that made it possible. The Kapur Commission recorded the view that the RSS as such was not responsible.

Did Gandhi fast for the 55 crore?

His stated aim was peace in Delhi. The 55 crore was not among the terms on which he ended the fast. But he did think India should pay, and the government released the money during the fast, in response to it.

Who else was punished?

Vishnu Karkare, Madanlal Pahwa and Gopal Godse got life terms. They were released in October 1964. Dattatraya Parchure and Shankar Kistayya were convicted at trial, but acquitted on appeal.

How we wrote this. We built this story from the Supreme Court’s 2018 order, the Kapur Commission report of 1969, the trial and appeal records as summarised by LiveLaw, and the books, archives and newspaper reports listed below. The TrendingPunjabi desk wrote it in our own words with the help of an AI model. Sources disagree on several points: whether the 55 crore was a condition of Gandhi’s fast; whether Godse had left the RSS; Savarkar’s role (acquitted by the court, implicated by the Kapur Commission); Gandhi’s last words; the date the trial formally opened (27 May or 22 June 1948); and the toll of the attacks on Brahmins in Maharashtra in 1948. We give each version and say who holds it. Godse’s words are quoted only to report what he said in court. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of India: Pankaj Kumudchandra Phadnis v. Union of India, order of 28 March 2018 (on the trial record, the fourth bullet and the Kapur Commission)
  2. Ministry of Home Affairs, via Internet Archive: Report of the Commission of Inquiry into Conspiracy to Murder Mahatma Gandhi (Justice J.L. Kapur), 1969
  3. LiveLaw: Mahatma Gandhi Assassination Case: Key Facts
  4. The Wire: Gandhi’s Last Fast is a Lesson for India’s Present (the 18 January pledge and the 15 January communiqué)
  5. The Tribune: Mahatma Gandhi’s last fast: a stand for communal harmony
  6. mkgandhi.org (Gandhi Research Foundation and Bombay Sarvodaya Mandal): Did Gandhi fast for the payment of Rs 55 crore to Pakistan?
  7. Scroll.in: Gandhi assassination: Did Partition unhinge Nathuram Godse’s co-conspirator? by Ajaz Ashraf (on Ashis Nandy’s interviews with Madanlal Pahwa)
  8. Scroll.in: Nathuram Godse and Narayan Apte were the first convicts to be hanged in independent India, extract from Hang Till Death by Prateek Jain
  9. UCLA South Asia: The Politics of Gandhi’s Last Words, by Vinay Lal
  10. The Tribune: Never said Hey Ram weren’t Bapu’s last words: Gandhi’s PA
  11. The Wire: When Sardar Patel took on the ‘forces of hate’ and banned the RSS
  12. Social Scientist: The killing of Gandhi and the tales told thereafter, by Anil Nauriya (on Patel’s letter of 27 February 1948)
  13. Organiser: RSS and Mahatma Gandhi’s assassination: myths vs facts
  14. The Caravan: How M.S. Golwalkar and Vallabhbhai Patel ensured the RSS’s survival after Gandhi’s assassination, extract from Gandhi’s Assassin by Dhirendra K. Jha
  15. Sabrang India: Gopal Godse: ‘Nathuram did not leave the RSS’ (reprint of Frontline interview, January 1994)
  16. The South First: Godse was active RSS member, Savarkar’s grandnephew tells court
  17. Business Standard: Rahul appears in court over RSS defamation case
  18. Sabrang India: Gandhi’s son had pleaded for mercy for Nathuram Godse and Apte: Gopalkrishna Gandhi
  19. The Quint: GD Khosla didn’t write about being ‘pressured’ into giving Godse death sentence
  20. LiveLaw: Disclose Godse’s statement before court in Gandhi assassination trial: CIC
  21. Deccan Herald: Can’t forgive Pragya for Godse ‘deshbhakt’ remark, says Modi
  22. The Tribune: Pragya calls Godse ‘deshbhakt’ during Lok Sabha debate
  23. The Quint: Hindu Mahasabha leader arrested for shooting at Gandhi effigy
  24. Deccan Herald: Study centre named for Nathuram Godse closed in Madhya Pradesh
  25. Business Standard: We are the Godses
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India