Beant Singh Assassination: A Bomb at the Secretariat, a Tunnel Out of Jail, and a Death Sentence Still Waiting
At about 5 pm on 31 August 1995, a police constable with explosives under his uniform walked up to the Punjab Chief Minister’s car in Chandigarh. The blast killed him and 16 others. What followed was a jail tunnel, an arrest in Thailand, two death sentences and a mercy petition that has waited fourteen years. The full story, told from every side.
By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 20 min read 1 views WhatsApp
In short
- On 31 August 1995, Punjab Police constable Dilawar Singh blew himself up beside Chief Minister Beant Singh’s car at the Civil Secretariat in Chandigarh, killing Beant Singh and 16 others.
- Beant Singh’s supporters credit him and police chief K.P.S. Gill with ending Punjab’s armed movement; rights groups hold his government’s police responsible for killings and disappearances of those years.
- A special court in 2007 sentenced Balwant Singh Rajoana and Jagtar Singh Hawara to death and three others to life. In 2010 the High Court cut Hawara’s sentence to life for the rest of his life and confirmed Rajoana’s.
- Rajoana never appealed or asked for mercy. The SGPC filed a mercy petition in 2012 and his hanging was stayed. It has never been decided.
- In May 2023 the Supreme Court left the mercy plea to the Centre. Rajoana’s fresh plea for commutation, opposed by the Centre, was listed for hearing on 18 November 2026.
The case file
Plea pending- Where
- The porch of the Punjab Civil Secretariat, Capitol Complex, Chandigarh
- When
- Thursday 31 August 1995, about 5:05 pm (the High Court’s finding)
- Killed
- Chief Minister Beant Singh, 73, and 16 others; the bomber, Dilawar Singh, also died
- Claimed by
- Babbar Khalsa International (BKI), an armed Sikh group banned in India
- Death sentences
- Balwant Singh Rajoana and Jagtar Singh Hawara (special court, 2007). Hawara’s cut to life by the High Court in 2010
- Life terms
- Gurmeet Singh, Lakhwinder Singh, Shamsher Singh (2007); Paramjit Singh Bheora (2010); Jagtar Singh Tara (2018)
- Other outcomes
- Nasib Singh: 10 years under the Explosives Act. Navjot Singh: acquitted
- Still pending (Nov 2026)
- Rajoana’s 2012 mercy petition, never decided; his Supreme Court plea for commutation; Hawara’s appeal against his conviction
In this story · 17 parts
- 31 Aug 1995Five o’clock at the Secretariat
- Part 2Who’s who
- 25 Feb 1992The man in white
- 1992–1995Gill’s war, and its price
- Aug 1995Two constables and a belt
- Sep 1995The car nobody came back for
- 22 Jan 2004A tunnel under barrack 7
- 31 Jul 2007The verdict inside the jail
- 12 Oct 2010‘Borderline’
- 28 Mar 2012The date was 31 March
- 5 Jan 2015Pattaya, 2015
- 3 Dec 2019The commutation that wasn’t
- 3 May 2023The longest wait
- 14 Jun 2022A portrait in the museum
- Part 15Eight claims, checked
- Part 16Every side, in its own words
- Part 17Our take
Five o’clock at the Secretariat
Punjab Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh On the History of the Sikhs timeline →
Chandigarh, Thursday, 31 August 1995. The Punjab Civil Secretariat is a long grey wall of concrete, drawn by the French architect Le Corbusier. At about five in the afternoon the working day is ending. The Chief Minister, Beant Singh, is coming down to go home. He is 73, in his usual white turban. His car, a white Ambassador, waits under the porch.
He nearly had company. He and his principal secretary, J.S. Maini, had stepped into a lift together, Maini’s wife later told ThePrint. Just before the doors closed, a friend called Maini back. He went upstairs.
Outside, a young man in Punjab Police uniform walked towards the car. Nobody stopped him. He was one of their own. His name was Dilawar Singh. He was a constable, 25 years old, and under his uniform he wore a belt packed with explosives.
At about 5:05 pm he set it off. The blast tore through the porch. It killed Beant Singh and 16 other people, the High Court later found, and Dilawar Singh with them. More than a dozen were hurt.
Babbar Khalsa International, an armed Sikh group, soon said it had done it. Six days later, in Amritsar, police picked up a human rights worker named Jaswant Singh Khalra outside his home. That is a story we tell in Jaswant Singh Khalra: the man who counted Punjab’s disappeared. Both stories come from the same dark years.
Who’s who
Punjab Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh
The people in the case
- Beant Singh73Congress Chief Minister of Punjab, 1992–95. Killed in the blast
- Dilawar Singh25Punjab Police constable, the bomber. Died in the blast
- Balwant Singh RajoanaConstable, the back-up bomber. Death sentence 2007, confirmed 2010
- Jagtar Singh HawaraThe plot’s organiser, the prosecution said. Death sentence 2007, life without release from 2010. Appeal pending
- Jagtar Singh TaraEscaped 2004, caught in Thailand 2015, life term 2018
- Paramjit Singh BheoraEscaped 2004, caught 2006, life term 2010
- Lakhwinder SinghConstable. Life term 2007. On bail since 2023
- Gurmeet SinghLife term 2007. On bail since June 2023
- Shamsher SinghLife term 2007
- Nasib Singh10 years under the Explosives Act, already served
- Navjot SinghAcquitted, 2007
- K.P.S. GillPunjab’s police chief, 1988–90 and 1991–95. Died 2017
The man in white
Punjab Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh
Beant Singh was born in 1922 and studied at Government College, Lahore. He served briefly in the army, as his father had. After Partition his family settled in Bilaspur village near Doraha, in Ludhiana district. In 1959 he became the village sarpanch, its elected head. About ten years later he was in the Punjab Assembly.
He followed the Namdhari tradition, which is why he wore white and never touched meat or alcohol. He did drink tea. His grandson Gurkirat Singh Kotli told ThePrint he had ten to fifteen cups a day. About 2,000 people came to his house every day, by ThePrint’s account, and he tried to meet each one.
In February 1992 Punjab voted after years of President’s rule. Most Akali factions stayed away, and so did most voters. Official figures put the turnout at about 24 per cent. The Congress won 87 of the 117 seats. Beant Singh, elected from Jalandhar Cantonment, was sworn in on 25 February 1992.
Punjab was losing about 25 lives a day, ThePrint reported. His brief, as The Tribune’s Sanjeev Bariana put it, was simple.
Put an end to terrorism in Punjab.Beant Singh’s brief as Chief Minister, as described by The Tribune, 2024
Gill’s war, and its price
To see why some call Beant Singh the man who saved Punjab, and why two men died or risked death to kill him, you have to see those years. After Operation Blue Star and the November 1984 killings, which we tell in Punjab 1984: the real story, thousands of young Sikhs took up arms for Khalistan. In Punjab they were called kharkus, fighters.
The armed groups killed on a terrible scale, Hindus and Sikhs alike. Ajai Sahni of the Institute for Conflict Management counts 21,532 deaths from 1981 to 1995: 11,696 civilians, 1,746 security men and 8,090 fighters. About two in three of the civilians killed by the armed groups were Sikhs, he says.
Beant Singh kept the police chief he inherited, Kanwar Pal Singh Gill. Gill’s aim, as the journalist Shekhar Gupta records it, was to make a top fighter’s life shorter than six months. Beant Singh backed him, The Tribune says, against criticism from rights activists and the press.
The numbers fell fast. By Gupta’s figures, civilian deaths dropped from 2,591 in 1991 to 48 in 1993. By 1995 the armed movement was all but over. Gupta credits Beant Singh and Gill together.
There was another column in the ledger. Human Rights Watch and Ensaaf say the security forces detained, tortured, killed and ‘disappeared’ tens of thousands of Sikhs in those years, many in staged ‘encounters’. Human Rights Watch says a system of cash rewards for killing wanted men drove it. The CBI later counted 2,097 illegal police cremations in a single district, Amritsar.
Gurpreet Maini, the wife of Beant Singh’s secretary, put both sides in two sentences to ThePrint. ‘He was a good man, Beant Singh,’ she said. Then she added a second line.
I think that era was very controversial.Gurpreet Maini, to ThePrint
Readers’ poll
How should Punjab remember Beant Singh?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
Two constables and a belt
Punjab Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh
What follows is the plot as the prosecution told it and the courts accepted it. The prosecution said Babbar Khalsa International planned the killing. It named two of the group’s leaders, Wadhawa Singh and Mehal Singh, as the men behind it. Both were declared proclaimed offenders, absconders, and were never tried.
The man on the ground, the prosecution said, was Jagtar Singh Hawara. It called him the ‘king pin’ who arranged the plan, the money and the RDX, a military explosive. Shamsher Singh, a driver, was said to have fetched the RDX from Ajnala on his orders; he later took back his confession. RDX was recovered from Nasib Singh’s cattle shed and from Gurmeet Singh’s house in Mohali. The belt, the prosecution said, was made in Gurmeet’s room.
A second-hand Ambassador with the Delhi number DBA-9598 was bought in the name ‘Basant Singh’. The prosecution said ‘Basant Singh’ was Jagtar Singh Tara. Lakhwinder Singh, a police constable, had it painted white.
Then there were the two bombers. Dilawar Singh would go first. If he failed, a second constable would try: Balwant Singh Rajoana, who had joined the Punjab Police in 1987. Rajoana has never denied it. In his 1996 confession to a magistrate he said why, and what he did.
I tied the bomb on Dilawar’s body with my own hands.Balwant Singh Rajoana, judicial confession, 1996 (as reported by The Tribune)
He said they were driven by grief over Operation Blue Star and the killings of 1984. Experts told the trial the blast came from a belt worn by a man, not a device in the car.
The car nobody came back for
Punjab Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh
After the blast, an unlocked Ambassador with a Delhi number sat parked a little way off. Nobody came back for it. Police said it was the car bought for the plot.
The car led to a painter. According to The Tribune’s account of the trial, he said Lakhwinder Singh and three others had brought it to him on 26 August to be repainted. Lakhwinder, reports say, was the first to be arrested. Tara was picked up in Delhi on 13 September 1995. Rajoana was arrested in December. Hawara was in custody by the end of the year.
The case went to the Central Bureau of Investigation, the CBI. The trial was held by a special court in a courtroom inside Burail jail in Chandigarh, for safety. It would take eleven years and hear about 250 witnesses.
Rajoana sat through it without a lawyer, saying he had no faith in Indian courts. The others fought the case.
A tunnel under barrack 7
Burail jail, Chandigarh
Burail jail, the night of 21 January 2004. The television in barrack 7 stayed on until about 3 am. By 7 am, guards had found a hole in a field outside the walls.
Four men were gone: Jagtar Singh Hawara, Jagtar Singh Tara, Paramjit Singh Bheora, and their cook, a murder accused named Devi Singh. They had crawled out through a tunnel about 2.5 feet wide and, by various reports, 94 to 109 feet long. It ran from under Hawara’s sleeping place, beneath the barracks, a road and a wall’s foundation, to a carrot field.
The Tribune pieced together how. A weightlifting rod for a spade. A tap left running day and night to soften the earth and hide the noise. Mud flushed down the drains, and about 40 bags of it hidden behind curtains. Turbans for ropes. The work took at least a year, officials believed.
They also used the guards’ respect. Hawara and Bheora, as Amritdhari Sikhs, objected to others entering their cell, saying it would defile it, and it was kept out of routine checks.
The hunt took years. Hawara was arrested in Delhi in 2005, over his alleged role in twin blasts there. Delhi Police caught Bheora in 2006. Tara stayed free for eleven years. Devi Singh was never caught; police believe he is in Pakistan. In 2015 a court convicted Hawara and Bheora of the escape and acquitted 14 others, including five jail officials.
The verdict inside the jail
Burail jail, Chandigarh
On 27 July 2007, nearly twelve years after the blast, the special court found the accused guilty. On Tuesday 31 July, Additional District and Sessions Judge Ravi Kumar Sondhi passed sentence in the same jail.
- Balwant Singh Rajoana and Jagtar Singh Hawara: death. They and the next three were guilty of murder, attempt to murder and conspiracy, and of offences under the Explosives Act.
- Gurmeet Singh, Lakhwinder Singh and Shamsher Singh: life imprisonment.
- Nasib Singh: ten years under the Explosives Act, the most that law allows. He had already spent more than eleven years in custody, so he walked free.
- Navjot Singh: acquitted.
Beant Singh’s son, Tej Parkash Singh, spoke for the family, his mother Jaswant Kaur nodding beside him. They wanted death for all five.
The death penalty for Hawara and Balwant Singh is good.Tej Parkash Singh, Beant Singh’s son, 31 July 2007
Bheora, re-arrested after the escape, was tried on his own. On 30 March 2010 the same judge gave him life for conspiracy in the assassination. His lawyer said he would appeal.
‘Borderline’
Death sentences in India must be confirmed by a High Court. On 12 October 2010, Justices Mehtab S. Gill and Arvind Kumar of the Punjab and Haryana High Court gave their ruling.
Rajoana had not appealed. He had said he would gladly accept death.
I have no regret of being a part of this murder.Balwant Singh Rajoana, as recorded by the Punjab and Haryana High Court, 2010
The judges confirmed his death sentence. They confirmed the life terms of Lakhwinder, Gurmeet and Shamsher. Hawara was different. He was the organiser, the court said, but he had kept himself outside the main action, and the evidence of where he was on 30 and 31 August was sketchy.
A borderline case for death sentence to be awarded.Punjab and Haryana High Court, on Jagtar Singh Hawara, 12 October 2010
So Hawara got life, with a condition: he was never to be released. He took his case to the Supreme Court. In November 2026, Outlook reports, that appeal has still not been decided. In court the Centre has said appeals by other convicts are pending there too.
The date was 31 March
Patiala Central Jail
Early in 2012, a Chandigarh judge, Shalini Nagpal, fixed a date for Rajoana’s hanging: 31 March, at Patiala Central Jail, where he was held. Then something unusual happened. The jail superintendent, L.S. Jakhar, sent the warrant back, twice. The trial had been in Chandigarh, he argued, so it was not Patiala’s job. The judge issued him a contempt notice.
On 23 March, the jathedar of the Akal Takht, Giani Gurbachan Singh, declared Dilawar Singh a ‘Qaumi Shaheed’, a martyr of the community, and Rajoana a ‘Zinda Shaheed’, a living martyr. Sikh groups called a shutdown. The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, the SGPC, which runs the main gurdwaras, filed a mercy petition with the President under Article 72 of the Constitution. Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal went to see President Pratibha Patil.
Rajoana himself did not ask for mercy. As The Tribune noted at the time, he had not sought clemency for what he did.
On Wednesday 28 March, three days before the date, the Union Home Ministry stayed the hanging. It would wait for the Supreme Court’s orders in the pending appeals, or for the President’s decision, whichever came later. In Rajoana Kalan, his village near Raikot, people burst crackers.
Not every voice in Beant Singh’s family was angry. His grandson Gurkirat Singh Kotli, then the MLA for Khanna, told The Tribune the stay would ensure long-term peace.
Pattaya, 2015
Pattaya, Thailand
On the evening of Monday 5 January 2015, Thai police and soldiers raided a house in East Pattaya, near the Siam Country Club. Inside they found a man who had entered Thailand on a Pakistani passport as ‘Gurmeet Singh’. He was Jagtar Singh Tara, eleven years on the run. The raid followed a tip from India, the Pattaya Mail reported.
On 16 January he was handed to Punjab Police. His trial was held in the same courtroom inside Burail jail. In January 2018, reports said, he admitted his part in a letter to the court.
On 17 March 2018 Additional District and Sessions Judge J.S. Sidhu sentenced him to life until his natural death. The CBI had asked for death, calling it the ‘rarest of the rare’. The judge did not agree. Tara said he was satisfied. He said he did not regret killing Beant Singh. He did regret, he said, the 16 innocent people who died with him.
The commutation that wasn’t
In September 2019, ahead of Guru Nanak’s 550th birth anniversary, The Tribune reported that the Home Ministry had approved changing Rajoana’s death sentence to life, as an act of grace. Eight other Sikh prisoners were to be freed. The Akali Dal took credit. Beant Singh’s grandson Ravneet Singh Bittu, then a Congress MP, was furious.
A black day in the history of Punjab.Ravneet Singh Bittu on the reported commutation, September 2019
On 3 December 2019, Bittu stood up in the Lok Sabha and asked why Rajoana had been pardoned. Home Minister Amit Shah told him not to go by media reports.
No pardon has been given.Amit Shah, Union Home Minister, Lok Sabha, 3 December 2019
The Akali Dal called Shah’s words very unfortunate. The sentence was never formally commuted, as the court cases since have shown. Rajoana stayed on death row.
The longest wait
Supreme Court, New Delhi
In 2020 Rajoana went to the Supreme Court himself. The long delay, his lawyers argued, violated his right to life. On 3 May 2023 a bench of Justices B.R. Gavai, Vikram Nath and Sanjay Karol said no to commuting his sentence. They gave a reason Rajoana could not argue with.
The petitioner himself never submitted any mercy petition.Supreme Court of India, 3 May 2023
The Home Ministry had given the court three reasons for waiting. The SGPC, not Rajoana, had filed the petition. Other convicts’ appeals were still pending. And a decision could affect national security or law and order. The court said putting it off amounted to turning it down for now.
Within the domain of the Executive to take a call on such sensitive issues.Supreme Court of India, 3 May 2023
Rajoana came back with a fresh plea in 2024. What followed was a long run of hearings:
Rajoana’s plea in the Supreme Court
- 25 Sep 2024The court asks the Centre, Punjab and Chandigarh to respond.
- 4 Nov 2024No interim release. ‘Decide it either way or we will consider it,’ the bench tells the Centre.
- 18 Nov 2024The court sends the plea to the President with a two-week limit, then puts that order on hold the same day at the Solicitor General’s request.
- 25 Sep 2025‘The question is why didn’t you hang him till now?’ a bench led by Justice Vikram Nath asks the Centre.
- Jan 2026A ‘last chance’ for the Centre to decide.
- 22 Apr 2026Two weeks to explain the delay on affidavit, no more extensions.
- Aug 2026The plea goes to a three-judge bench.
- 7 Oct 2026The Centre calls a decision ‘not conducive’ in Punjab’s situation. The bench will hear the plea on merits.
- 28 Oct 2026The Centre opposes commutation outright. Listed for 18 November 2026.
On 28 October, Additional Solicitor General K.M. Nataraj was blunt.
I don’t think such a prayer can be granted.K.M. Nataraj, for the Centre, Supreme Court, 28 October 2026
Mukul Rohatgi, for Rajoana, said his client had been in custody for 30 years, and that the mercy petition was still pending. His plea says he has spent more than 15 years on death row.
What is pending, as of 19 November 2026: (1) the SGPC’s mercy petition of March 2012, never decided by the government; (2) Rajoana’s Supreme Court plea to commute his death sentence to life, opposed by the Centre and listed for hearing on 18 November 2026, which we have found no report of; (3) Hawara’s appeal against his conviction, and his separate plea to move from Tihar to a jail in Punjab, listed for 22 February 2027. Rajoana’s death sentence stands, stayed since 2012.
Readers’ poll
Balwant Singh Rajoana has spent 30 years in custody and more than 15 on death row, and has never asked for mercy. What should happen?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
A portrait in the museum
Amritsar
For one part of Punjab, the bombers are heroes. On 14 June 2022 the SGPC hung a portrait of Dilawar Singh in the Central Sikh Museum in the Golden Temple complex, citing the Akal Takht’s 2012 edict. The SGPC president, Harjinder Singh Dhami, said Dilawar had done something specific.
Put an end to the atrocities and gross human right violations.Harjinder Singh Dhami, SGPC president, on Dilawar Singh, June 2022 (as reported by ThePrint)
In November 2015 a Sarbat Khalsa, a gathering of Sikhs at Chabba near Amritsar, named Hawara acting jathedar of the Akal Takht. The SGPC called its decisions null and void. Sikh groups have campaigned for years for the ‘Bandi Singhs’, Sikh prisoners they say have served more than a life sentence. Hawara and Rajoana are among the best-known names.
For another part of Punjab, they are killers. Beant Singh’s family stayed in politics. Bittu, now a BJP Union minister, accuses the Akali Dal of honouring the men who killed his grandfather. Each 31 August the family remembers a chief minister who, to them, gave his life to stop the killing. And the families of 16 other people remember loved ones who happened to be standing near his car.
Readers’ poll
In 2022 the SGPC put a portrait of Dilawar Singh in the Central Sikh Museum. What is your view?
Tap an answer to see what other readers think.
Eight claims, checked
Beant Singh and K.P.S. Gill ended Punjab’s armed movement
Why people believed it
His family, the Congress and many Punjabis who lived through 1991 say so.
What the record shows
Civilian deaths fell from 2,591 in 1991 to 48 in 1993, by Shekhar Gupta’s figures. Rights groups say the same years saw the worst disappearances.
On the recordTrue that the killing ended on their watch. Whether the price was justified is the argument.
His government let the police kill thousands of innocent young men
Why people believed it
Rights groups, Sikh bodies and the bombers themselves say so.
What the record shows
The CBI counted 2,097 illegal police cremations in Amritsar district. Courts have convicted policemen for staged encounters and for Jaswant Singh Khalra’s murder. No court ever examined Beant Singh’s own orders.
Still openPolice crimes of those years are proven in court. Beant Singh’s personal role was never tested.
The bombing was revenge for 1984 and the police killings
Why people believed it
It is the bombers’ own account, and the SGPC’s.
What the record shows
The courts accepted the confessions and convicted the plotters of murder. Sixteen other people died in the blast, and Tara said he regretted their deaths.
Still openThat is how the bombers explain it. The courts judged the act, not the cause.
Rajoana’s death sentence was commuted in 2019
Why people believed it
In September 2019 reports said the Home Ministry had approved it for Guru Nanak’s 550th anniversary.
What the record shows
Amit Shah told the Lok Sabha on 3 December 2019 that no pardon had been given. No order was issued. The Supreme Court in 2023 treated the mercy plea as still undecided.
BustedAnnounced in the press, never done.
Rajoana begged for mercy
Why people believed it
A mercy petition in his name has been pending since 2012.
What the record shows
The SGPC filed it. Rajoana never appealed, never sought clemency, and told the court he had no regret. The Supreme Court made the same point in 2023.
BustedFalse. Others asked for mercy for him.
Security let the bomber walk in
Why people believed it
Beant Singh’s grandson Gurkirat Singh Kotli told ThePrint that ‘security weren’t even checking people’.
What the record shows
Both bombers were serving constables, and the bomber was in uniform. We found no public report of a security inquiry or of anyone punished.
Still openThe lapse is plain. Who was to blame was never publicly settled.
Pakistan was behind the plot
Why people believed it
The author Abeer Kapoor writes that the plans were first made in Lahore. Indian agencies say BKI chief Wadhawa Singh lives in Pakistan.
What the record shows
The prosecution named Wadhawa Singh and Mehal Singh as instigators, but they were never tried. No court in this case has made a finding about Pakistan.
UnprovenAlleged, never tested in court.
Hawara was ‘the mastermind’
Why people believed it
Headlines have called him that for thirty years; others give the title to Tara.
What the record shows
The prosecution called Hawara the ‘king pin’. The High Court spared his life partly because he kept out of the main action.
Still openA headline word. The courts found a group plot.
Every side, in its own words
How to remember Beant Singh
Beant Singh’s family and supporters
- He took over a state losing about 25 lives a day and, they say, gave his life to end the killing.
- Shekhar Gupta credits him and Gill together with bringing the violence down from 2,591 civilian deaths in 1991 to 48 in 1993.
- Bittu called the reported 2019 commutation ‘a black day in the history of Punjab’ and accuses the Akali Dal of feting his grandfather’s killers.
- In 2007 his family asked for death sentences for all five men convicted.
His critics, rights groups and many Sikh bodies
- Human Rights Watch and Ensaaf say police under his government tortured, killed and ‘disappeared’ thousands of Sikhs.
- Critics say his orders cost the lives of many innocent young men, ThePrint reported.
- He took office on a turnout of about 24 per cent, with most Akali factions boycotting.
- The SGPC and the Akal Takht honour Dilawar Singh as a martyr who, in Dhami’s words, ended atrocities.
What the record shows
- Courts convicted BKI members of the bombing and confirmed the sentences in 2010 and 2018.
- The CBI counted 2,097 illegal police cremations in one district; courts have convicted policemen for staged killings.
- No court ever examined Beant Singh’s own orders.
- Both sides point to real, documented deaths.
What should happen to Rajoana
For keeping the death sentence
- The Centre told the Supreme Court in October 2026 that commutation should not be granted.
- The Home Ministry has said a decision could affect national security and law and order.
- Two courts upheld the sentence, and Rajoana says he has no regret.
- Bittu has opposed every move to free him.
For commuting it or freeing him
- Rohatgi says 30 years in custody and a 14-year wait on a mercy plea violate the right to life.
- The SGPC and groups such as the Qaumi Insaaf Morcha say the Sikh prisoners have served more than a normal life sentence.
- Gurmeet Singh argued in 2023 that life convicts elsewhere go free after 14 years; he was bailed after 27.
- Beant Singh’s grandson Kotli said in 2012 the stay would ensure long-term peace.
What the courts have said
- In 2023 the Supreme Court refused to commute, and noted he never sought mercy himself.
- It said the decision belongs to the executive.
- Since 2024 it has pressed the Centre again and again to decide, asking in 2025 why he had not been hanged.
- As of 19 November 2026 it has not ruled on his new plea.
Our take
Punjab tells this story in two ways, and both are true to the people telling them. In one, a 73-year-old man who drank ten cups of tea a day was murdered for ending a war that had killed thousands of Punjabis, most of them Sikhs. In the other, the head of a government whose police burned young men as ‘unidentified’ was punished by two men who felt nobody else would punish him.
The record does not let either story stand alone. The killing at the Secretariat was a murder, of Beant Singh and 16 people whose only fault was to be near him, and the courts have said so. The police crimes of his years are proven too, in other courts, against other men. Thirty-one years on, Beant Singh’s killers have been judged. The question of his government has never been put to any court. And one man still waits for a decision on a mercy plea he never asked for.
Test yourself
7 questions on this story
-
Where was Beant Singh killed?
The bomb went off in the porch of the Secretariat in Chandigarh’s Capitol Complex as he reached his car.
-
What was the bomber Dilawar Singh’s job?
He was a serving Punjab Police constable, and he walked up to the car in uniform. The back-up bomber, Balwant Singh Rajoana, was a constable too.
-
How did Hawara, Tara and Bheora get out of Burail jail in January 2004?
They dug a tunnel from their cell in barrack 7, under the walls, to a field outside. Reports put it at 94 to 109 feet.
-
What did the High Court do with Hawara’s death sentence in October 2010?
The judges called his case borderline for the death penalty and gave him life with no release.
-
Who filed the 2012 mercy petition for Rajoana?
The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee filed it. Rajoana never asked for mercy, which the Supreme Court pointed out in 2023.
-
Where was Jagtar Singh Tara caught in January 2015?
Thai police arrested him in Pattaya, where he had been living on a Pakistani passport in the name Gurmeet Singh.
-
What did Home Minister Amit Shah tell the Lok Sabha about Rajoana in December 2019?
Reports in September 2019 said his sentence would be commuted. Shah told the House not to go by media reports.
Quick check: which came first?
Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.
Questions people ask
Who killed Beant Singh?
Courts found that Dilawar Singh, a Punjab Police constable, killed Beant Singh as a suicide bomber on 31 August 1995, in a plot by members of Babbar Khalsa International. Balwant Singh Rajoana, the back-up bomber, and Jagtar Singh Hawara were sentenced to death in 2007; others were given life.
How many people died in the Beant Singh blast?
Beant Singh and 16 others were killed, according to the Punjab and Haryana High Court, and the bomber died too. Some reports say 17 others died with him.
Is Balwant Singh Rajoana still on death row?
Yes. His hanging was stayed in March 2012 on a mercy petition filed by the SGPC. That petition has never been decided. In 2019 reports said the Centre would commute his sentence, but Home Minister Amit Shah told Parliament no pardon had been given. In November 2026 his plea for commutation was still before the Supreme Court.
What happened to Jagtar Singh Hawara?
He was sentenced to death in 2007. In October 2010 the High Court changed it to life imprisonment for the rest of his life. He escaped from Burail jail through a tunnel in 2004 and was caught again in 2005. His appeal against the conviction is still before the Supreme Court.
Why do some Sikhs honour Beant Singh’s killers?
They see the bombing as a response to Operation Blue Star, the 1984 killings of Sikhs and the police killings of the early 1990s. In 2012 the Akal Takht called Dilawar Singh a ‘Qaumi Shaheed’ and Rajoana a ‘Zinda Shaheed’. Beant Singh’s family and supporters call the bombers murderers who killed 16 other people with him.
How we wrote this. Researched from the High Court judgment, court reports and the other sources listed below, and written in our own words by the TrendingPunjabi desk with the help of an AI model. Everyone named as convicted was convicted by the court and in the year we give; Navjot Singh was acquitted, and Wadhawa Singh and Mehal Singh were named by the prosecution but never tried. Where sources disagree we say so: the date of the 2007 sentence (reports give 27 July, 31 July and 1 August; we follow the reports that the court convicted on 27 July and sentenced on 31 July), the toll (the High Court says Beant Singh and 16 others; some reports say 17 others), the tunnel’s length (94 to 109 feet) and Tara’s fine (Rs 25,000 or Rs 35,000). Rajoana’s age is not firmly established in the record, so we leave it out. We found no report of what happened at the Supreme Court hearing listed for 18 November 2026. Words such as ‘terrorist’ and ‘martyr’ appear only in quotes, as the words of the people who used them. Shekhar Gupta’s figures come from his reporting for ThePrint, cited in our Khalra long read.
Sources
- Indian Kanoon: State (CBI) v. Jagtar Singh Hawara and others, Murder Reference No. 6 of 2007 (Punjab and Haryana High Court, 12 October 2010)
- TwoCircles.net (IANS): Two get death for Beant Singh killing; family not satisfied (31 July 2007)
- Oneindia: Hawara, Balwant get death in Beant assassination case (31 July 2007)
- The Tribune: ‘I tied the bomb’: Beant’s assassin was remorseless (May 2023)
- The Tribune: Supreme Court declines to commute Balwant Singh Rajoana’s death penalty (3 May 2023)
- The Tribune: The 109-ft-long tunnel which jail officials couldn’t spot
- The Tribune: Fourteen acquitted in 2004 Burail jailbreak case (August 2015)
- Sikh Siyasat News: Paramjeet Singh Bheora sentenced to imprisonment for life (30 March 2010)
- The Tribune: Centre stays Rajoana’s hanging (29 March 2012)
- Pattaya Mail: Fugitive terrorist bomber arrested in Pattaya (8 January 2015)
- The Tribune: Beant killer Tara jailed till death (17 March 2018)
- The Tribune: Beant Singh assassin Rajoana’s death sentence commuted (September 2019)
- Scroll.in: Convict’s death penalty not commuted, says Amit Shah (3 December 2019)
- The Tribune: SC asks President’s Secretary to place Rajoana’s mercy plea before her (18 November 2024)
- The Tribune: No relief to Rajoana as SC defers hearing (4 November 2024)
- The Tribune: If offence grave, why Rajoana not hanged till now, asks SC (25 September 2025)
- LawBeat: Supreme Court tells Centre to explain delay in Rajoana mercy plea decision (22 April 2026)
- ETV Bharat: ‘Not conducive’: Centre opposes Rajoana’s commutation plea (October 2026)
- ThePrint (PTI): Beant Singh assassination: Centre opposes Rajoana’s plea in SC (28 October 2026)
- Outlook: Hawara’s jail transfer plea revives Punjab’s Bandi Singhs demand (10 November 2026)
- ThePrint: Why Beant Singh assassin’s portrait is up in Golden Temple museum (June 2022)
- ThePrint: The former Punjab chief minister who fought terror and loved tea
- The Tribune: Sculptor of peace in Punjab (Sanjeev Bariana, 2024)
- Human Rights Watch and Ensaaf: Protecting the Killers: A Policy of Impunity in Punjab, India (October 2007)
- The Tribune: The real butchers of Punjab (Ajai Sahni)
