1. Home
  2. News
  3. Crime Files
  4. Priyadarshini Mattoo case
Crime Files

Priyadarshini Mattoo Case: A Year of Warnings, a Judge Who ‘Knew’, and a Father’s 20-Year Fight

In January 1996 a law student who had complained to the police again and again was killed in her Delhi home. The accused was a senior policeman’s son. A judge acquitted him while saying he knew he was guilty. Then came the campaign, the death sentence, the Supreme Court’s mercy, and a fight over his release that is still in court.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 20 min read WhatsApp

Priyadarshini Mattoo Case: A Year of Warnings, a Judge Who ‘Knew’, and a Father’s 20-Year Fight

In short

  • On 23 January 1996, law student Priyadarshini Mattoo, 25, was raped and murdered at her home in Vasant Kunj, Delhi, after a year of police complaints against Santosh Kumar Singh, a senior police officer’s son.
  • On 3 December 1999, Judge G.P. Thareja acquitted him on the benefit of the doubt, while saying, as reported, that he knew he was the man who committed the crime.
  • After a 2006 public campaign, the Delhi High Court convicted Singh of rape and murder on 17 October 2006 and sentenced him to death. The Supreme Court upheld the conviction on 6 October 2010 but gave life imprisonment.
  • The Sentence Review Board has repeatedly refused his early release. The High Court ordered a fresh look in July 2025; the Board refused again in late 2025, and his new challenge is pending.

The case file

Convicted
Victim
Priyadarshini Mattoo, 25, final-year LLB student at Delhi University, from a Kashmiri Pandit family
Where
Her family’s home in Vasant Kunj, south Delhi
When
Afternoon of 23 January 1996; her body was found at about 5:30 pm
Convicted
Santosh Kumar Singh, former law student and son of IPS officer J.P. Singh: rape and murder. Acquitted by the trial court (1999); convicted and sentenced to death by the Delhi High Court (2006); conviction upheld, death commuted to life, by the Supreme Court (2010)
Investigated by
Delhi Police for one day, then the CBI from January 1996
Now
Serving life. The Sentence Review Board has refused early release many times; his challenge to its late-2025 refusal is pending in the Delhi High Court, as far as reports show
In this story · 16 parts
  1. 23 Jan 1996An afternoon in Vasant Kunj
  2. Part 2A girl from Srinagar
  3. 1995A year of complaints
  4. 24 Jan 1996From the local police to the CBI
  5. 3 Dec 1999“I know he is the man”
  6. Part 6The two cases, side by side
  7. 23 Jul 2006Six quiet years, then a loud spring
  8. 17 Oct 2006Forty-two days
  9. 6 Oct 2010Life, not death
  10. 1996–2016A father who would not stop
  11. Part 11Who’s who
  12. 1 Jul 2025Life in prison, and the open jail
  13. Apr 2026Where it stands, November 2026
  14. 1995–2026Thirty years, step by step
  15. Part 15The claims, checked
  16. Part 16Our take
Part 1

An afternoon in Vasant Kunj

Vasant Kunj, Delhi

It was a Tuesday, 23 January 1996, a cold winter day in Delhi. In the morning, a 25-year-old law student named Priyadarshini Mattoo drove her parents to the Tis Hazari courts. She dropped them at about 10:15 and went on to her class at Delhi University’s Faculty of Law.

She was meant to have a policeman with her. For months, a head constable named Rajinder Singh had been her personal security officer, her PSO. That morning he was late. When he reached the law faculty, he saw someone he knew by sight: Santosh Kumar Singh, the young man she had complained about to the police again and again.

Priyadarshini, known to her family as Priya, came home to Vasant Kunj, in south Delhi, at about 1:45 pm. She told the PSO to come back at 5:30. Her father later told Gulf News she had lunch and lay down to rest, with her pet dog, Snoopy, beside her. The family’s domestic help, Virender Prasad, went out at about 2:30.

At about 4:50 pm, a neighbour named Kuppuswami saw Santosh Singh at her door. He was carrying a motorcycle helmet. Its visor, the neighbour told the court, was in one piece.

At about 5:30 pm, the PSO came back with another constable, Dev Kumar. They found Priya’s body under a double bed. The courts later found that she had been raped and strangled with the electric cord of a heater. The doctors counted 19 injuries. Near her body lay broken pieces of a helmet visor.

Early the next morning, at 3:45 am, a doctor examined Santosh Singh’s right hand. It was swollen. An X-ray showed a broken bone. Fourteen years and three courts later, that hand would still be part of the argument.

Part 2

A girl from Srinagar

Faculty of Law, University of Delhi

Priya’s family were Kashmiri Pandits. She finished school in Srinagar, and then, as violence grew in the Kashmir Valley, the family moved south to Jammu. She took a BCom at MAM College in Jammu, and later an MCom, and then came to Delhi to study law.

Her father, Chaman Lal Mattoo, was a retired chief engineer of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Works Department who, after retiring, worked with the charity Sulabh International. In Delhi the family lived in a house in Vasant Kunj that, reports say, belonged to her uncle. She drove her own Maruti car. Her father remembered her as a girl who talked all the way, full of life and laughter.

The Faculty of Law building at the University of Delhi, with students outside during student union elections
The Faculty of Law, University of Delhi, during student union elections in 1987. Priya was in the last year of her LLB at the university’s Campus Law Centre when she was killed.Photo: Jan Kranendonk (https://www.jankranendonk.nl) · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Santosh Kumar Singh was a little older. He had studied law at the same campus and passed out in 1994, the Supreme Court later noted, but he kept coming back on his motorcycle. His father, J.P. Singh, was a senior officer of the Indian Police Service. Reports describe him as an Inspector General of Police at the time, and later as a Joint Commissioner of Delhi Police. To the courts that mattered more than any other fact about the young man: his father was a very senior policeman.

Part 3

A year of complaints

Faculty of Law, University of Delhi

The Supreme Court set out the record of 1995 date by date. It reads like a warning nobody acted on.

1995, complaint by complaint

  1. 16 Feb 1995Priya files a police case at Maurice Nagar police station for outraging a woman’s modesty.
  2. 25 Feb 1995She complains again of being followed and harassed. Santosh Singh apologises and gives a written promise to stop.
  3. Later in 1995A complaint about an incident at the Khyber petrol pump. She withdraws it after another written promise.
  4. 16 Aug 1995He follows her home from the university. He is arrested and taken to Vasant Kunj police station.
  5. 30 Oct 1995He complains to the university that she is studying for two degrees at once, and sends reminders in December. Her fifth-semester LLB result is held back.
  6. 6 Nov 1995Another police case at Maurice Nagar police station.

Her father later told Gulf News what it was like at home: the young man followed her on his motorbike, banged on their door, and once took her car keys at a traffic signal. The family bought her the car to keep her safe. The police gave her a guard.

But the courts found the police did little more. Officers persuaded her, more than once, to settle for an apology. The trial judge called their conduct reprehensible, and the Supreme Court agreed. The university complaint fell apart too: she had finished her MCom in 1991, so she was not doing two courses at once. The High Court counted the harassment, from 1994 to January 1996, as the first link in the chain against him.

Two months after the last complaint, she was dead.

Part 4

From the local police to the CBI

New Delhi

The case was first registered by Inspector Lalit Mohan of Vasant Kunj police station, on her father’s complaint, as murder. It did not stay with him long. On 24 January 1996, the day after the killing, the Delhi government wrote to the Central Bureau of Investigation, the CBI, and asked it to take over. The reason was plain to everyone: the main suspect was the son of a senior police officer.

The CBI gathered its evidence. On 25 January it seized Santosh Singh’s helmet. The visor was broken. His hand had a fracture of the fifth metacarpal, a bone near the little finger, which a doctor called grievous, caused by a blunt weapon. Blood was taken from him at Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital on 28 January. Samples went to the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology in Hyderabad, where scientists including Dr Lalji Singh ran DNA tests. The CBI filed its chargesheet on 11 April 1996.

Santosh Singh said he had hurt his hand in a road accident on 14 January 1996, nine days before the killing, and produced treatment papers. He pleaded not guilty.

There was one more problem, and it would grow. Virender Prasad, the domestic help, was a natural witness to who came and went. The CBI did not bring him to court. Later, Outlook reported, a journalist found him living in his village in Bihar.

Part 5

“I know he is the man”

New Delhi

The trial was slow. Outlook’s chronology says arguments before the first judge closed in April 1998 amid talk of money changing hands, and the case moved to Additional Sessions Judge G.P. Thareja.

On 3 December 1999, Judge Thareja gave his verdict in a judgment that ran to about 450 pages. He acquitted Santosh Kumar Singh.

It was the way he did it that stunned India. As reported by Outlook, he said he knew the accused had done it, but the evidence put before him did not prove it.

I know that he is the man who committed the crime.Judge G.P. Thareja, 3 December 1999, as reported by Outlook

He gave Santosh Singh the benefit of the doubt. He held the DNA report could not be relied on, because of doubts about how the samples were handled. He said the rape charge was not proved. And he blamed the people who should have built the case. He found deliberate inaction by the police, said Inspector Lalit Mohan had been obliging the accused’s father, and said the CBI was responsible for how the case ended.

Four years later the same judge, G.P. Thareja, would sentence Sushil Sharma to death in the tandoor murder case.

Santosh Singh walked out. He married, had a daughter, and began to practise law in Delhi.

Part 6

The two cases, side by side

New Delhi

Here is each side’s case in its own best form, and what the final courts found.

The case for and against

What the prosecution (the CBI) said

  • He had stalked and harassed her for more than a year, and broke written promises to stop.
  • A neighbour saw him at her door at about 4:50 pm with a helmet whose visor was whole; broken visor pieces lay by her body.
  • His right hand had a fresh fracture hours after the killing.
  • DNA from Hyderabad matched him to the samples taken from her body and clothes.
  • Local police went soft on him because his father was their senior.

What Santosh Singh’s defence said

  • He pleaded not guilty, and the case rested on circumstances: nobody saw the crime.
  • His hand and helmet were damaged in a road accident on 14 January 1996, and he had treatment papers to show it.
  • The DNA samples could have been tampered with; the defence also said a blood group found did not match his.
  • The CBI never produced Virender Prasad, the one man inside the household that day.
  • In 1999 the trial court agreed the case was not proved, and acquitted him.

What the record shows (High Court 2006, Supreme Court 2010)

  • Both courts held all the key links proved, including the visor, the hand and the DNA.
  • The Supreme Court accepted the DNA report as scientifically accurate and found no tampering shown.
  • It held the hand injury was fresh, with no sign of healing, and was suffered during the crime.
  • No doctor from the accident treatment was ever brought to court to back the defence story.
  • It said the trial judge had been swayed by irrelevant considerations.
Part 7

Six quiet years, then a loud spring

India Gate, New Delhi

The CBI appealed to the Delhi High Court on 29 February 2000. Then, for six years, almost nothing happened. A file waited. Chaman Lal Mattoo kept writing letters and turning up at hearings.

What woke the case was another one. On 21 February 2006, a Delhi trial court acquitted everyone accused of killing Jessica Lal, the model shot at a Mehrauli party. A newspaper summed it up in four words, NO ONE KILLED JESSICA, and India’s anger exploded. You can read that story in our long read on the Jessica Lal case.

People began asking what happens when the accused is rich or powerful. The Mattoo case, stuck in the High Court, was the obvious second example.

In March 2006, after reading an article by Priya’s father, a young man started an online petition to the President and the Chief Justice of India asking for a retrial. Aditya Raj Kaul, later a television journalist, has written that it was him. Thousands signed and TV channels ran debates. Volunteers formed a group called Justice for Priyadarshini, backed by more than 25 student and women’s groups.

In July, her old schoolmate Indu Jalali spoke to reporters in Delhi.

Till date no concrete step has been taken to deliver justice.Indu Jalali, Priya’s schoolmate, July 2006
India Gate in New Delhi seen from the avenue in front of it
India Gate, New Delhi. Priya’s friends called a demonstration here for 23 July 2006, what would have been her birthday, to demand a retrial.Photo: Benison · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Her friends called a protest at India Gate for 23 July, her birthday, with others planned in Pune, Mumbai, Jammu and Srinagar. Kaul later wrote that a large demonstration took place that day. On 31 August 2006, the High Court began hearing the appeal day after day.

Part 8

Forty-two days

New Delhi

The bench was Justice R.S. Sodhi and Justice P.K. Bhasin. In the same year they would also reverse the Jessica Lal acquittal. They heard the Mattoo appeal daily, reserved judgment on 27 September, and gave it on 17 October 2006.

Santosh Singh was in the packed courtroom. By then he was a practising lawyer in his thirties, married, with a small daughter. The judges went through 13 circumstances, from the harassment and the broken promises to the visor, the hand and the DNA, and found every one proved. They called the trial court’s approach perverse.

has mauled justice, its decision has shocked the judicial conscience of this Court.Delhi High Court, 17 October 2006, on the 1999 acquittal

They were just as hard on the police. Officers had helped the accused at every stage, they said, always remembering he was the son of their superior. They spoke of “the softness shown by brothers in uniform”. They convicted Santosh Kumar Singh of rape and murder, and the CBI took him into custody in the courtroom.

Chaman Lal Mattoo had waited almost eleven years.

Finally, justice has been done.Chaman Lal Mattoo, October 2006, to Outlook

On 30 October came the sentence. The CBI’s lawyer, Additional Solicitor General Amarendra Saran, called it a rarest of rare case. Defence lawyer R.K. Naseem asked for mercy: Singh’s good conduct since 1996, his wife and two-year-old daughter, and an elder brother who needed care, Arab News reported. The judges said the crime was planned and grotesque, and that he had been given chances to change and had not taken them.

He shall be hanged till death.Delhi High Court, 30 October 2006
Part 9

Life, not death

Supreme Court of India

Santosh Singh appealed to the Supreme Court, and his death sentence was put on hold. Four years later, on 6 October 2010, Justices Harjit Singh Bedi and Chandramauli Kumar Prasad gave their answer.

The Supreme Court of India building in New Delhi, seen from beyond its outer wall
The Supreme Court of India. On 6 October 2010 it upheld Santosh Kumar Singh’s conviction but turned his death sentence into life imprisonment.Photo: Legaleagle86 at English Wikipedia. · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

On guilt, they agreed with the High Court on every point. They accepted the DNA report as scientifically accurate. They found the hand injury fresh, with no sign of healing, and held it was suffered in the attack. The trial judge, they wrote, had put his own opinion in place of the experts’, and had made remarks about a doctor that were very broad and defamatory.

On punishment, they stopped short of death. The case rested on circumstantial evidence. The High Court had overturned an acquittal. He was about 24 at the time. Since then he had married and had a daughter. His father had died a year after the conviction. Nothing showed he could not reform.

The judges also wrote about power. They warned against parents who are over-indulgent with their children, and against the “volatile and heady cocktail” of power and money. Weighing it all, they said, the scale leaned his way, but only just.

the balance sheet tilts marginally in favour of the appellantSupreme Court of India, 6 October 2010

The CBI said it was satisfied that the conviction stood. Priya’s father was not.

I am not satisfied with the sentence.Chaman Lal Mattoo, 6 October 2010, to DNA

The family’s lawyer, Ashok Bhan, said he would seek a review. The sentence stayed: life in prison.

Readers’ poll

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction but replaced the death sentence with life in prison. What is your view?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 10

A father who would not stop

New Delhi

Chaman Lal Mattoo is at the centre of this story. He was a displaced Kashmiri Pandit in his sixties, living in a city that was not his own, taking on a family with a senior policeman at its head.

He went to court hearings. He chased the CBI and its lawyers. He went on television again and again, which some said put the judges under pressure and others said was the only way anyone listened. He told Gulf News in 2006 that the police had destroyed clues and tampered with evidence for the accused’s father. That was his accusation; no court ever tried J.P. Singh, who died in 2007.

I sometimes spend time in Priya’s room to feel her presence.Chaman Lal Mattoo, 2006, to Gulf News

He thanked neighbours, strangers and the media for standing by the family, even on the day he called the 2010 sentence wrong.

Aditya Raj Kaul, the young man who started the 2006 petition, later wrote that Chaman Lal Mattoo died in October 2016. The fight passed to Priya’s brother, Hemant Mattoo.

Part 11

Who’s who

The people in the case

  • Priyadarshini Mattoo25Final-year law student at Delhi University. Killed at her home in Vasant Kunj on 23 January 1996
  • Chaman Lal MattooHer father, a retired J&K chief engineer. Fought the case for twenty years. Died in 2016, reports say
  • Hemant MattooHer brother. Opposes Santosh Singh’s early release
  • Santosh Kumar SinghFormer law student. Acquitted 1999; convicted of rape and murder by the Delhi High Court (2006), upheld by the Supreme Court (2010). Serving life
  • J.P. SinghHis father, a senior IPS officer. Never charged in the case. Died in 2007
  • G.P. TharejaAdditional Sessions Judge who acquitted Singh in 1999
  • R.S. Sodhi and P.K. BhasinDelhi High Court judges who convicted him and sentenced him to death in 2006
  • H.S. Bedi and C.K. PrasadSupreme Court judges who upheld the conviction and gave life instead of death in 2010
  • Rajinder SinghHead constable assigned as her personal security officer
  • Lalit MohanVasant Kunj police inspector who first handled the case; criticised by the courts
Part 12

Life in prison, and the open jail

Tihar Jail, Delhi

A life convict can ask to be let out early. In Delhi, that request goes to the Sentence Review Board, chaired by the Delhi Home Minister, with officials from the jails, police and government. Its advice goes to the Lieutenant Governor. Under Delhi’s 2004 policy, which applies to Singh, a case like his is considered after 20 years in prison, counting remission, the time taken off for good conduct.

Santosh Singh used his years inside. He studied for a Master of Laws, finishing the first part in 2014, and got parole in May 2019 to sit his final exam. From about 2019 he was in Tihar’s open jail, allowed out from 8 am to 8 pm to work as a legal consultant with a real estate company. By 2024 he had been out on parole 18 times and on furlough 19 times, the Board’s minutes record.

The main gate of Tihar Jail in Delhi
The main gate of Tihar Jail, Delhi. Santosh Kumar Singh has served his life sentence here since 2006, in recent years in its open jail.Photo: Zuck28 · CC0 · Wikimedia Commons

His lawyers told the High Court that the Board recommended his release on 6 September 2017, but the Lieutenant Governor sent the case back and the Board then said no.

After that came refusal after refusal. July 2019. 21 October 2021. 30 June 2023. Then 30 August and 18 September 2024. The 2024 minutes counted 21 years and two months in actual custody, or 28 and a half years with remission. The Board still said no. It pointed to the gravity, cruelty and perversity of the crime, strong objections from the police and the CBI, and a negative message to the public. It added that good conduct in jail was “not necessarily a barometer” of life outside.

Singh went to the Delhi High Court in 2023. On 1 July 2025, Justice Sanjeev Narula ruled for him. The Board, he held, had looked only at the crime. It had ignored the open jail, the degrees, a clean jail record and a favourable report from the Social Welfare Department, and given no real reasons. He quashed the refusal and sent the case back. He also laid down guidelines for the Board, including an assessment by mental health experts, and said victims’ families were being left out of the process.

The Mattoo family was angry. On what would have been Priya’s 55th birthday, her brother and the founders of the 2006 campaign went to Delhi Home Minister Ashish Sood, who chairs the Board.

Santosh Singh has shown no remorse.Hemant Mattoo, July 2025, to The Tribune

The All-India Kashmiri Samaj wrote to the Delhi government too, calling the case a symbolic fight for justice and dignity for the community.

Part 13

Where it stands, November 2026

New Delhi

The Board met again. In late 2025 it said no for a second time after the High Court’s order; most reports date the decision to 27 November 2025, and ThePrint reported that the Board called the crime premeditated, said release would set a bad example, and noted that Priya’s brother opposed it. Singh went back to the High Court.

He was out of jail on parole from 3 December 2025, reports say. On 19 March 2026, Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani refused to extend it and told him to surrender. At the same hearing, the court learned that Priya’s family had not been told about the case, and ordered that they be informed. Hemant Mattoo’s lawyer, Urvika Suri, asked to be heard.

On 16 April 2026, the judge spoke plainly from the bench, the Daily Pioneer reported. The Board, he said, seemed to be going on public perception. His lawyer, Mohit Mathur, said Singh had spent 31 years in custody, counting remission, and pointed to the release of Jessica Lal’s killer in 2020. The family’s lawyer opposed hurrying the hearing.

What he did was unacceptable and the system punished him.Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani, Delhi High Court, 16 April 2026, as reported

The judge also said the family had suffered a permanent loss. His petition was to be heard with similar cases; reports gave hearing dates of 20 April and 18 May 2026.

What is pending, as of 19 November 2026: Santosh Kumar Singh’s petition against the Sentence Review Board’s late-2025 refusal is before the Delhi High Court, as far as published reports show. We found no report of a ruling after April 2026. His conviction for rape and murder is final, and he has not been released early.

Readers’ poll

Santosh Singh has served more than 22 years in actual custody, with a good jail record, but the victim’s family opposes his release. What should happen?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 14

Thirty years, step by step

1995 to 2026

  1. 1994–1995Santosh Singh stalks and harasses Priya; police cases and written promises follow.
  2. 23 Jan 1996Priyadarshini Mattoo is raped and murdered at home in Vasant Kunj.
  3. 24 Jan 1996The case goes to the CBI.
  4. 3 Dec 1999Judge G.P. Thareja acquits Santosh Kumar Singh.
  5. Mar–Jul 2006After the Jessica Lal acquittal, an online petition and the Justice for Priyadarshini campaign.
  6. Oct 2006Delhi High Court convicts him of rape and murder and sentences him to death.
  7. 6 Oct 2010Supreme Court upholds conviction, commutes death to life.
  8. Oct 2016Chaman Lal Mattoo dies, Aditya Raj Kaul writes.
  9. 2017–2024The Sentence Review Board refuses early release again and again.
  10. 1 Jul 2025Delhi High Court quashes a refusal and orders a fresh look.
  11. 27 Nov 2025The Board refuses again, reports say.
  12. 2026His new challenge is heard; pending, as far as reports show.
Part 15

The claims, checked

Thirty years of television and petitions have left some famous claims. Here is what the record says.

Claim 1

The judge said he knew Singh was guilty, and let him go anyway

Why people believed it

It is the most quoted line of the case, repeated in petitions and on TV for years.

What the record shows

Outlook reported Judge Thareja’s words on 3 December 1999 as “I know that he is the man who committed the crime.” He acquitted on the benefit of the doubt, saying the evidence, especially the DNA, was not proved properly.

On the recordTrue, as reported. He blamed the investigators, not the facts.

Claim 2

His father’s rank protected him

Why people believed it

The accused was the son of a senior IPS officer, and the local police went easy on him.

What the record shows

The trial court, the High Court and the Supreme Court all criticised the police for favouring him. The High Court said officers never forgot he was their superior’s son. J.P. Singh himself was never charged in the case, and no court made a finding of crime against him. He died in 2007.

On the recordThe courts found the police went soft. No case against the father.

Claim 3

The DNA evidence was tampered with

Why people believed it

The defence argued it in 1999, and the trial court refused to rely on the DNA report.

What the record shows

The High Court found no gaps in the testing. The Supreme Court said no tampering or contamination was shown and accepted the Hyderabad lab’s report as scientifically accurate.

BustedRejected by both higher courts.

Claim 4

The hand injury came from a road accident

Why people believed it

Singh said he hurt his hand on 14 January 1996 and showed treatment papers.

What the record shows

No doctor from that treatment gave evidence. Doctors told the court the fracture was fresh, with no healing, and the Supreme Court held it happened during the attack.

BustedThe courts did not believe it.

Claim 5

The media campaign, not the evidence, convicted him

Why people believed it

The conviction came months after TV debates, petitions and marches, and critics of ‘trial by media’ have long argued that such campaigns put judges under pressure.

What the record shows

The High Court’s judgment rests on 13 circumstances from the trial record, and the Supreme Court, reviewing it calmly four years later, agreed on guilt. The campaign clearly sped up a hearing that had waited six years.

Still openThe campaign moved the date. The evidence decided the verdict.

Claim 6

He has already walked free, like Jessica Lal’s killer

Why people believed it

Manu Sharma was released early in 2020, and Singh has been out on parole many times and, from the open jail, out at work by day.

What the record shows

As of the latest reports we found, every request for early release has been refused, and his challenge to the latest refusal is pending in the Delhi High Court. Parole and the open jail are part of a sentence, not release.

BustedNot released early, as far as reports show.

Readers’ poll

Did the public campaign of 2006 help justice, or put pressure on the courts?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 16

Our take

The Mattoo case is often told as a story about one bad verdict. It is really about a year of warnings. Two police cases, a written apology, an arrest and a security guard: the system knew. It still did not stop a young man with a powerful father, whom she had reported again and again.

It is also about courts reading one record two ways. A trial judge saw a case spoiled by the people who built it. Two higher courts saw a chain with no gaps. All of them said the police had failed her.

And now it is a story about what a life sentence means. The family says the man who killed Priya has never shown remorse. The man says he has changed, and the High Court has seen signs of it. Both of those things can be argued. What cannot be argued is the date at the start of it all: 23 January 1996, an afternoon in Vasant Kunj, and a student who had asked for help again and again.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. What was Priyadarshini Mattoo studying when she was killed?

  2. What protection had the police given her before the murder?

  3. What did a neighbour see Santosh Singh carrying at her door at about 4:50 pm?

  4. Which agency investigated the case from the day after the killing?

  5. In which year did the trial court acquit Santosh Singh?

  6. Which other case’s acquittal in February 2006 helped revive the Mattoo case?

  7. What did the Supreme Court do in October 2010?

Quick check: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

What happened in the Priyadarshini Mattoo case?

Priyadarshini Mattoo, a 25-year-old Delhi University law student, was raped and murdered at her home in Vasant Kunj on 23 January 1996. Santosh Kumar Singh, a former student who had harassed her for over a year, was convicted of the crime by the Delhi High Court in 2006.

Why was Santosh Singh acquitted in 1999?

Judge G.P. Thareja held that the evidence, especially the DNA report, was not proved properly and gave him the benefit of the doubt. He blamed the police and the CBI, and was reported as saying he knew Singh was the man who committed the crime.

Was Santosh Singh sentenced to death?

Yes. The Delhi High Court sentenced him to death on 30 October 2006. On 6 October 2010 the Supreme Court upheld his conviction but changed the sentence to life imprisonment.

Who was Santosh Kumar Singh’s father?

J.P. Singh, a senior Indian Police Service officer. The courts said local police favoured the accused because of his father’s rank. J.P. Singh was never charged in the case and died in 2007.

Is Santosh Singh out of jail?

He has not been released early, as far as published reports show. He was moved to Tihar’s open jail and has had parole, but the Sentence Review Board has refused early release many times. His challenge to its late-2025 refusal is pending before the Delhi High Court.

Who fought for justice for Priyadarshini Mattoo?

Her father, Chaman Lal Mattoo, fought the case for two decades. In 2006, friends and students formed the Justice for Priyadarshini campaign. Today her brother, Hemant Mattoo, opposes Singh’s early release.

How we wrote this. Researched from the Supreme Court’s 2010 judgment, the Delhi High Court’s judgments of 2006 and 2025, and the reports listed below, and written in our own words by the TrendingPunjabi desk with the help of an AI model. Santosh Kumar Singh was acquitted by the trial court in 1999 and convicted of rape and murder by the Delhi High Court in 2006, a conviction the Supreme Court upheld in 2010; he pleaded not guilty and his defence is set out as he argued it. Priyadarshini Mattoo’s name has been public for decades with her family’s consent and is used by the courts; we give no detail of the assault beyond what the judgments relied on, and no photo of her. Judge Thareja’s words are as reported by Outlook; the judgment itself was not available to us. Chaman Lal Mattoo’s accusations against the police and Hemant Mattoo’s statements are their own; J.P. Singh was never charged in the case. Sources differ on some points: her year of birth (1970 or 1973), J.P. Singh’s post at the time, the date of the High Court conviction (17 October 2006 in the judgment; some reports say 27 October), the date of the Board’s late-2025 refusal (October or 27 November), and how many years Singh has served (the figure depends on whether remission is counted). We found no Delhi High Court ruling of January 2024 on his remission; the ruling ordering a fresh review was given on 1 July 2025. We found no report of the High Court’s decision on his latest petition after April 2026. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources

  1. Indian Kanoon: Santosh Kumar Singh v. State through CBI, Supreme Court, 6 October 2010
  2. Indian Kanoon: State (through CBI) v. Santosh Kumar Singh, Delhi High Court, 17 October 2006
  3. Delhi High Court: Santosh Kumar Singh v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), W.P.(Crl) 1431/2023, Delhi High Court, 1 July 2025
  4. Outlook: Justice, at long last
  5. Outlook: 11 long years
  6. Gulf News: Priya was ‘full of life’
  7. Arab News: Man to hang in Mattoo rape, murder case
  8. DNA: Priyadarshini Mattoo case: victim’s father dismayed, CBI satisfied
  9. Oneindia (UNI): Priyadarshini Mattoo’s friends demand retrial
  10. Organiser: A youthful initiative for justice to Priya Mattoo
  11. The Quint: Did we fail Priyadarshini Mattoo? (Aditya Raj Kaul)
  12. Gulf News: Trial by media wins justice for victims in India
  13. Scroll: Convict granted three-week parole for law exam
  14. The Tribune (PTI): Board rejects release pleas of Jessica Lal, Priyadarshini Mattoo’s killers (2019)
  15. The Tribune: Delhi High Court orders fresh review of Santosh Singh’s plea for premature release
  16. The Tribune: Priyadarshini Mattoo’s family meets Home Minister to stall her killer’s release
  17. The Tribune: Block premature release of Priyadarshini Mattoo’s convict, Kashmiri Pandits to government
  18. The News Mill: Delhi HC orders Santosh Singh to surrender, denies parole extension
  19. The Daily Pioneer: ‘You will get objective treatment’: Delhi HC to Mattoo case convict
  20. ThePrint: Which life convict walks and why? Mattoo killer’s plea puts early release yardstick under lens
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All Crime Files stories · All news