1. Home
  2. History
  3. Komagata Maru and Ghadar
History

Komagata Maru and the Ghadar Rising: The Ship Canada Turned Away and the Punjabis Who Went Home to Fight

In 1914 a ship carrying 376 Punjabis sat for two months in Vancouver harbour. Canada refused to let them land. The ship’s return ended in gunfire at Budge Budge. The Ghadar Party’s rising ended on the gallows in Lahore. Here is the full story: the rule, the rebels, the violence on every side and the apologies that came a century late.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 21 min read 2 views WhatsApp

Komagata Maru and the Ghadar Rising: The Ship Canada Turned Away and the Punjabis Who Went Home to Fight
Photo: Leonard Juda Frank · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • From 1908 Canada kept Indians out with a ‘continuous journey’ rule. It never named India, but it required a direct voyage that no ship offered. In 1914 Gurdit Singh chartered the Komagata Maru to test it, with 376 Punjabi passengers.
  • Vancouver kept the ship in the harbour from 23 May to 23 July 1914. The courts upheld the law. Passengers drove off a police tug with coal, and the navy saw the ship out. Only about two dozen landed.
  • Back in India, troops fired on the returning passengers at Budge Budge on 29 September 1914. Most counts say 18 to 20 passengers died. Official records list 26 dead in all. Who fired first is still disputed.
  • Punjabi workers founded the Ghadar Party in Astoria, Oregon, in 1913. It sent thousands home to raise a rising for February 1915. An informer betrayed it. The Lahore trials sentenced 42 to death. Kartar Singh Sarabha was hanged at 19.
  • Justin Trudeau apologised in the House of Commons on 18 May 2016. British Columbia and Stephen Harper had apologised before him. We found no formal British apology for Budge Budge.

At a glance

1913–1915
When
May 1913 to November 1915: the Ghadar Party founded in 1913; the Komagata Maru in Vancouver from 23 May to 23 July 1914; Budge Budge on 29 September 1914; the failed rising of 19 February 1915; Sarabha hanged on 16 November 1915
Where
Astoria and San Francisco, USA; Vancouver, Canada; Budge Budge near Calcutta; Lahore and central Punjab; Singapore
The ship
376 passengers (by the usual count 340 Sikhs, 24 Muslims, 12 Hindus), chartered by Gurdit Singh; only about two dozen allowed to land
The rule
Canada’s ‘continuous journey’ order of 8 January 1908, plus a $200 cash rule for Asian migrants; revoked only in 1947
Budge Budge
18 to 20 passengers killed by most counts; official records list 26 dead in all, including two Europeans and two Punjab policemen
The trials
Lahore conspiracy cases: 291 tried, 42 sentenced to death, 114 transported for life, 42 acquitted; Kartar Singh Sarabha hanged at 19
Apologies
BC legislature (2008), Stephen Harper in Surrey (2008), Justin Trudeau in the House of Commons (18 May 2016), Vancouver city (2021)
In this story · 16 parts
  1. 23 May 1914A ship in the inlet
  2. 8 Jan 1908Sawmills and a closed door
  3. 1913Astoria: the word was ghadar
  4. Mar–May 1914Gurdit Singh’s gamble
  5. May–Jul 1914Two months in the harbour
  6. 19–23 Jul 1914Coal against rifles
  7. 1914Both sides in 1914
  8. Sep 1914–Jan 1915Shots in the gurdwara
  9. 29 Sep 1914Budge Budge
  10. Aug 1914–1915Going home to fight
  11. 19 Feb 191519 February 1915
  12. 16 Nov 1915The Lahore Conspiracy Case
  13. 1921Afterlives
  14. 18 May 2016Sorry, a century later
  15. 1908–2016From Astoria to Lahore, step by step
  16. Part 16Our take
Part 1

A ship in the inlet

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet) On the History of Punjab timeline →

Vancouver, Saturday 23 May 1914. A rusty Japanese steamer drops anchor in Burrard Inlet, a few hundred metres from the city’s docks. From the shore you can see the turbans. Hundreds of men are packed along the rails. They are looking at the wooded hills of the country they have paid to reach.

The ship is the Komagata Maru. Its passengers have renamed it Guru Nanak Jahaz, the ship of Guru Nanak. On board are 376 people from Punjab. By the usual count they are 340 Sikhs, 24 Muslims and 12 Hindus. Many are ex-soldiers of the British Indian Army. All of them are British subjects, travelling inside the British Empire.

Their leader stands on deck in a light suit and a white beard. He is Gurdit Singh, a contractor from a village near Amritsar who made his money in Malaya. He chartered this ship to test a law he believed was a lie.

Canada will keep the ship in the harbour for two months. The story ends under rifle fire near Calcutta. It ends, too, on a gallows in Lahore, where a 19-year-old Ghadar rebel from a village near Ludhiana is hanged.

A black and white photograph of a crowd of turbaned men on the deck of a ship, with an older bearded man in a light suit in the left foreground
Passengers on the deck of the Komagata Maru in Vancouver harbour, 1914. Gurdit Singh stands at the left, in the light suit and white beard. Photograph by Leonard Frank.Photo: Leonard Juda Frank · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Part 2

Sawmills and a closed door

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet) On the History of the Sikhs timeline →

The first Punjabis reached British Columbia in the early 1900s. Many of them were ex-soldiers. They found work in sawmills and on railway gangs. By 1908 officials estimated there were up to 5,000 Indian men in the province.

They also found open racism. In September 1907 a white mob rioted through Vancouver’s Chinese and Japanese quarters. Indian workers, whatever their faith, were lumped together as ‘Hindoos’.

In January 1908 the Khalsa Diwan Society opened a gurdwara on West 2nd Avenue in Vancouver. It is believed to be the first in North America. It was a place of prayer and a community hall. Soon it was a political headquarters too.

That same month Ottawa shut the door, without ever saying so. An order in council, a government decree, was issued on 8 January 1908. It barred any immigrant who did not arrive by a ‘continuous journey’ from his country of birth, on a ticket bought there. No shipping line ran directly from India to Canada. And Canada leaned on the companies not to start one. From June 1908, migrants of ‘Asiatic origin’ also needed $200 in cash. For a Punjabi labourer, that was a fortune.

The rule never named India. London had warned that an open ban on fellow subjects of the King could inflame nationalists in India. So Canada kept them out indirectly.

One man shaped that thinking: William Lyon Mackenzie King, then a young civil servant, later Canada’s longest-serving prime minister. In his 1908 reports, historians record, he argued that Canada should remain a ‘white man’s country’. Indians, he said, were unsuited to its climate. He also said he was protecting them from shipping agents and employers who lured them with false promises.

Lawyers kept beating the rules on technicalities. They did it in 1911. They did it again in November 1913, when 35 of 39 Indians on the Panama Maru were let in. Each time Ottawa rewrote the rules. The latest rewrite came on 7 January 1914.

Part 3

Astoria: the word was ghadar

Astoria, Oregon On the History of Punjab timeline →

Astoria, Oregon, 1913. It is a timber town at the mouth of the Columbia River, smelling of salmon canneries and fresh-cut wood. Punjabis work at the Hammond lumber mill here. They borrow the Finnish Socialist Hall from their immigrant neighbours. There they meet to found a party.

The date is disputed. Astoria’s own accounts say spring 1913. Many histories say 15 July 1913. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism says Portland, in 1912. The research of the Oregon historian Johanna Ogden put Astoria back on the map.

It started as the Hindustan Association of the Pacific Coast. Its president was Sohan Singh Bhakna, born in 1870. He was a farmer from near Amritsar who had come to America in 1909 to work in the mills. Its general secretary was Lala Har Dayal, an Oxford-educated scholar from Delhi. He had turned his back on a career under the Raj. The treasurer was Pandit Kanshi Ram.

Who’s who

  • Sohan Singh Bhakna43 in 1913mill worker from Bhakna, near Amritsar; first president of the party
  • Lala Har Dayal28 in 1913Delhi-born scholar and the movement’s voice; general secretary and first editor
  • Kartar Singh Sarabha17 in 1913student from Sarabha village, Ludhiana; ran the Punjabi edition of the paper
  • Gurdit Singhabout 53 in 1914contractor from Sarhali, near Amritsar; chartered the Komagata Maru
  • W.C. HopkinsonCanadian immigration inspectorspied on the Punjabi community for Canada and British India

In November 1913 the party opened a press at 436 Hill Street, San Francisco. It called the press the Yugantar Ashram. On 1 November it put out the first issue of its weekly paper, in Urdu. A Gurmukhi edition followed on 9 December. The paper gave the movement its name. Har Dayal’s first issue asked a question and answered it.

What is our name? Ghadr.Ghadar, first issue, 1 November 1913

Ghadar means mutiny. It was the word the British used for 1857. The paper called openly for armed revolt. The British banned it in India as soon as it arrived, in December 1913. Copies were smuggled in anyway.

The party was overwhelmingly Punjabi and Sikh. By one estimate, about nine in ten members were Punjabi Sikhs, and about half of them were old soldiers. But its leaders were Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims. Its inner political circle reportedly did not allow religion to be discussed at all. Its enemy was the Raj, not any faith.

The youngest of its stars was Kartar Singh Sarabha. He was born on 24 May 1896 in Sarabha village near Ludhiana. In July 1912 he had sailed to San Francisco to study at Berkeley (the university has no record that he enrolled). He helped run the paper and oversaw its Gurmukhi edition. He wrote poems and articles for it too.

The British were watching. They watched through W.C. Hopkinson, a Canadian immigration inspector and Canada’s spy on the Punjabi community. In March 1914 US officials arrested Har Dayal. He faced deportation to India. He jumped bail and fled to Switzerland, then Berlin.

Part 4

Gurdit Singh’s gamble

Hong Kong

Gurdit Singh was born in 1861 in Sarhali, Amritsar district, to a family of small farmers. The Indian cavalry turned him down. In 1885 he followed his father to Malaya, and there he became a successful contractor.

In Hong Kong in early 1914 he met Punjabis stranded on their way to Canada. His answer was bold. If no ship sailed from India to Canada, he would hire one. He founded the Guru Nanak Steamship Company. In March 1914 he chartered the Komagata Maru, a Japanese steamer.

The British in Hong Kong arrested him on 25 March. They found no case and let him go. On 4 April the ship sailed with 165 passengers. It picked up more at Shanghai, then 86 at Moji in Japan and 14 at Yokohama. At Yokohama two Ghadar leaders came on board as visitors, Maulvi Barkatullah and Bhagwan Singh. They brought the party’s literature with them.

When the ship left Yokohama on 3 May, it carried 376 passengers.

Counting the passengers. Most accounts say 376 passengers: 340 Sikhs, 24 Muslims and 12 Hindus. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism counts 359 Sikhs and says the ship left Hong Kong with 194 people, not 165. Everyone agrees almost all were Punjabis and British subjects.

Part 5

Two months in the harbour

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet)

Richard McBride, the Conservative premier of British Columbia, said flatly that the passengers would not land. The local Conservative MP, H.H. Stevens, led the campaign to keep them out. He warned Ottawa that landing them was more likely to cause riots than keeping them on board.

On the water, the immigration agent Malcolm Reid and his inspector, Hopkinson, took charge. The ship was not allowed to dock. It was kept at anchor under guard. A handful of passengers who already lived in Canada were let ashore. Everyone else waited.

A black and white photograph of a group of men in suits and hats on a deck, talking with reporters
Immigration inspector William C. Hopkinson (far right), immigration agent Malcolm Reid and MP H.H. Stevens meet reporters during the stand-off, 1914.Photo: See description · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The weeks dragged on. Food and water ran short. The passengers said Canada was starving them into leaving.

On shore, Vancouver’s Punjabis fought back with lawyers and money. A shore committee was led by Husain Rahim, with Bhag Singh, Balwant Singh and others. It raised about $20,000 and took over the ship’s charter. That way the Japanese owners could not sail it away.

The committee wanted one test case, and it got one. On 29 and 30 June the lawyer J. Edward Bird argued the case of a passenger named Munshi Singh. He argued it before the British Columbia Court of Appeal. On 6 July the judges ruled unanimously for the government. They upheld Canada’s power to decide who could land.

Readers’ poll

In 1914, did Canada have the right to turn the Komagata Maru away?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 6

Coal against rifles

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet)

In the early hours of 19 July, the tug Sea Lion came alongside. On board were about 150 police and special immigration officers, armed. They had come to force the ship out to sea.

The passengers were ready. From the high deck they hurled down lumps of coal, firebricks and scrap iron. The tug was driven off. To the passengers and their supporters, men without guns had beaten back the police.

Prime Minister Robert Borden now sent in the navy. The old cruiser HMCS Rainbow was brought in. Its orders were to enforce the law firmly, as he put it, but ‘with no unnecessary violence’. Crowds watched from the waterfront and from small boats.

A cabinet minister, Martin Burrell, worked out a deal. Canada would supply food and fuel for the voyage home. On 23 July 1914 the Komagata Maru sailed out of Burrard Inlet, with the Rainbow behind it. It was two months to the day after it arrived. Only 20 to 24 people, depending on the source, had been allowed to stay.

A black and white photograph of a steamship with a tall funnel moving across a harbour, with hills behind
The Komagata Maru leaves Vancouver on 23 July 1914, escorted out of Burrard Inlet. Photograph by Leonard Frank.Photo: See description · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Part 7

Both sides in 1914

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet)

The men who kept the ship out did not think of themselves as villains. The record should hear them too.

Both sides in 1914

What Canada and the British said

  • Ottawa said it was simply enforcing its immigration law. The BC Court of Appeal upheld that law unanimously on 6 July 1914.
  • Mackenzie King and others argued Canada should stay a ‘white man’s country’. Indians, they said, were unsuited to its climate and better protected from labour agents.
  • H.H. Stevens warned that landing the passengers would cause riots in Vancouver.
  • Officials said the voyage was a political challenge, not an honest migration. They pointed to the Ghadar leaders and literature on board.

What the passengers and Ghadarites said

  • They were British subjects, and many had fought for the Crown. Yet the Empire would not let them move within it.
  • The ‘continuous journey’ rule was a racial ban in disguise. It was written for a route that Canada made sure did not exist.
  • They were kept on a crowded ship for two months, short of food and water, while the courts and the politicians stalled.
  • Ghadar leaders said the voyage proved British rule meant no rights anywhere. They called on Indians to go home and fight.

Both can be true. Canada broke no law of its own in 1914. And the law itself was built to keep people out because of where they were born.

Part 8

Shots in the gurdwara

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet)

The ship was gone, but Vancouver’s Punjabis were now at war among themselves. Hopkinson ran informers inside the community.

In late August 1914 one of the informers, Harnam Singh, was found dead. Another, Arjan Singh, died soon after. Then came 5 September. At a service in the West 2nd Avenue gurdwara, another informer, Bela Singh, pulled out a revolver and opened fire on the congregation. Two men died. One was Bhag Singh Bhikhiwind, a leader of the shore committee. Bela Singh claimed self-defence.

On 21 October 1914, Hopkinson was waiting in the Vancouver courthouse to give evidence at Bela Singh’s trial. Mewa Singh walked up and shot him dead. He was a 33-year-old mill worker from Lopoke, near Amritsar.

Mewa Singh pleaded guilty. He said he had acted because of the killings in the gurdwara. He was hanged in New Westminster on 11 January 1915, the first Sikh executed in Canada. Vancouver’s Sikhs remember him as a shaheed, a martyr. To the officials of the day he was a murderer.

Readers’ poll

How should Mewa Singh be remembered?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 9

Budge Budge

Budge Budge On the History of India timeline →

The ship reached the mouth of the Hooghly, near Calcutta, on 26 September 1914. By then the Government of India had a new law. The Ingress into India Ordinance of 5 September let it hold or restrict anyone coming home from abroad.

On 29 September the ship was brought to Budge Budge, a river port about 23 km below Calcutta. Police searched it for weapons. A special train stood waiting to take the passengers straight to Punjab.

Seventeen Muslim passengers boarded it, the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism says. The Sikhs refused. They wanted to go to Calcutta instead. Carrying the Guru Granth Sahib before them, they set off on foot along the road to the city.

Troops and police turned them back and herded them to the railway yard. By evening the passengers were sitting on the ground near the line, surrounded. A British police officer went in to fetch Gurdit Singh. Then the shooting began.

Who fired first is still disputed. The official inquiry accepted the police account. In that account, a shot was fired at the officer and the passengers attacked. The troops, it says, fired only when they had to. Passengers, and later Sikh accounts, say the troops opened fire on unarmed men who were sitting down.

did not fire until it was absolutely necessary to do soBudge Budge Committee of Inquiry, 1914, on the troops

How many died depends on whom you ask. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism says 18 Sikhs were killed and 25 wounded. Most histories, and the memorial, count 20 passengers killed. Government records, cited in later studies, list 26 deaths in all. That count takes in the passengers, two Europeans, two Punjab policemen and two local people.

Gurdit Singh escaped. Most of the others were rounded up. The committee of inquiry concluded that the passengers had firearms. It could not say where they got them.

A tall white memorial tower with a pointed top, standing among trees in a small garden
The Komagata Maru memorial at Budge Budge, near Kolkata, in 2020. Jawaharlal Nehru opened a memorial at Budge Budge in 1952.Photo: DeepanjanGhosh · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Claim 1

Twenty passengers died at Budge Budge

Why people believed it

It is the figure on most timelines, including the plaques and many school books.

What the record shows

The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism says 18 Sikhs were killed and 25 wounded. Government records list 26 dead in all, counting two Europeans, two Punjab policemen and two locals.

On the recordAbout right for the passengers: somewhere between 18 and 20, with 26 dead in all.

Claim 2

The passengers fired first

Why people believed it

It was the finding of the official inquiry in 1914.

What the record shows

The inquiry relied on police witnesses. It called some passengers’ statements untrustworthy. Passengers and Sikh accounts say the troops fired on seated, unarmed men. No independent witness settles it.

UnprovenUnproven. Only one side’s witnesses were believed.

Claim 3

The Ghadar Party was founded in San Francisco

Why people believed it

Its headquarters, press and paper were there. Older histories began the story there.

What the record shows

The founding meeting was held at Astoria, Oregon, in 1913, though the exact date is disputed. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism traces the association to Portland in 1912.

BustedBusted. San Francisco was its home, not its birthplace.

Claim 4

Ghadar was a Sikh movement

Why people believed it

Most members were Sikh. Gurdwaras in Canada and California were its meeting halls.

What the record shows

About nine in ten members were Punjabi Sikhs. But its leaders included Hindus such as Har Dayal and Muslims such as Maulvi Barkatullah. And it kept religion out of its politics.

Still openMostly Sikh in its members. Non-religious in its aims, on purpose.

Part 10

Going home to fight

Lahore

Britain went to war on 4 August 1914. In San Francisco, that was the signal. Britain’s trouble was India’s chance, the Ghadar leaders said. Go home and raise the army against the Raj.

They went in thousands. The first group of about 60 sailed from San Francisco on 29 August 1914. Sohan Singh Bhakna was arrested on his return on 13 October. He would not walk free for 16 years. By official count, 2,312 Ghadar men entered India between October 1914 and February 1915. By 1916 more than 8,000 had come back.

They were not quiet about it. Men sang revolutionary songs on the ships, and spies took notes. Most were stopped at the ports. Of those the police picked up, about 2,500 were confined to their villages. About 400 were jailed as dangerous. About 5,000 were let go with a warning.

Kartar Singh Sarabha got through. In October 1914 he landed at Calcutta, by way of Colombo. At Benares he met the Bengali revolutionary Rash Behari Bose. Then he went to work in Punjab. He visited army cantonments, the towns where soldiers were based, and tried to win over Indian soldiers.

The returned men also turned to violence, and some of it was aimed at Indians. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism records what they did. They murdered policemen and informers. They planned to derail trains and blow up bridges. They made bombs. They carried out armed robberies, or ‘political dacoities’, to raise money. On 27 November 1914 a band was near Pheru Shahr in Ferozepur district. By one account it was on its way to raid the Moga treasury. It shot dead a police official and a zaildar, a village headman. Ghadarites died in the fight, and others were hanged.

Most villagers did not rise. Many had done well from the Raj’s canals. Some turned the returned men in.

Part 11

19 February 1915

Lahore

The plan was for a single day. The leaders were now gathered round Rash Behari Bose in Lahore. On 12 February 1915 they fixed 21 February for a rising in the army. Regiments at Lahore, Ferozepur, Meerut and beyond would mutiny and seize the arsenals.

They had a spy in the room. Kirpal Singh, a police informer, had joined them. The leaders feared a leak and moved the date to 19 February. He passed that on too. Police raided the Lahore headquarters and arrested 13 of the leaders. Suspect regiments were disarmed or moved. On the day, in Punjab, almost nothing happened.

Far away in Singapore, on 15 February, the 5th Light Infantry mutinied. It was an Indian Muslim regiment of 850 men, and about half of them rose. They held out for nearly a week. Some 47 British soldiers and local civilians were killed. Sources differ on the punishment. One count gives 37 death sentences. Another gives 47 men publicly shot.

Sarabha fled Lahore. On 2 March he was at Chak No. 5 in Sargodha, still trying to rouse soldiers. There a risaldar, an Indian cavalry officer, named Ganda Singh had him arrested. Two comrades were taken with him, Harnam Singh Tundilat and Jagat Singh. On 23 March came another blow. The young Maharashtrian revolutionary Vishnu Ganesh Pingle was caught at Meerut, in the 12th Cavalry lines, with ten bombs. Rash Behari Bose slipped away to Japan.

Part 12

The Lahore Conspiracy Case

Lahore

The trials began in Lahore on 26 April 1915. A special tribunal of three judges heard them. It had been set up under the new Defence of India Act. There was no jury and no appeal.

In the first case, judgment came in September. Twenty-four accused were sentenced to death and 27 to transportation for life. Sohan Singh Bhakna was among those sentenced to hang.

Kartar Singh Sarabha took the whole blame on himself. The judges were struck by how young he was. They are said to have urged him to soften his statement. He refused. He was asked about an appeal, his biographers record. He gave an answer that Punjab still knows by heart.

If I had more lives than one, it would have been a great honourKartar Singh Sarabha, as recorded by his biographers, 1915

Lawyers, among them Motilal Nehru, made a plea, The Tribune reports. Seventeen of the men, they argued, had been seized at the ports before they could act in India. The Viceroy, Lord Hardinge, commuted those 17 sentences. Bhakna was saved. He spent the next 15 years in the Andamans and other jails.

Seven were not saved. On 16 November 1915 the British hanged them in Lahore Central Jail. They were Kartar Singh Sarabha, 19, Vishnu Ganesh Pingle, Jagat Singh, Harnam Singh, Bakshish Singh and two men named Surain Singh. (Some sources give the date as 17 November.)

A printed handbill with ten small oval portraits of men, most in turbans, arranged in rows under a heading
‘India’s Martyrs’, a handbill printed by the Ghadar Party in San Francisco in 1916. It shows portraits of ten men hanged or jailed after the failed rising, Kartar Singh Sarabha among them.Photo: Ghadar Party · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In all, the Lahore conspiracy cases tried 291 people. Of them, 42 were sentenced to death, 114 transported for life and 93 jailed. Another 42 were acquitted. Sir Michael O’Dwyer was the Lieutenant-Governor who ran the crackdown. He called Ghadar this:

by far the most serious attempt to subvert British rule in IndiaSir Michael O’Dwyer, Lieutenant-Governor of Punjab

Four years later, O’Dwyer was still governing Punjab when General Dyer opened fire in Jallianwala Bagh. In 1940 one of the Ghadar Party’s later recruits, Udham Singh, shot O’Dwyer dead in London.

And in a house in Lyallpur district, a boy born in 1907 grew up with Sarabha’s photograph in his pocket. His name was Bhagat Singh. Sixteen years after the first Lahore Conspiracy Case, a second one would end with his hanging, in the same jail.

Readers’ poll

Was the Ghadar movement right to choose armed revolt?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 13

Afterlives

Nankana Sahib

Gurdit Singh stayed in hiding for seven years. On 15 November 1921, the birth anniversary of Guru Nanak, he gave himself up at Nankana Sahib. By some accounts, Gandhi had advised him to. He was soon jailed again, for a speech at the Golden Temple. In 1926 he stood in as president of the Shiromani Akali Dal. He died in Amritsar on 24 July 1954.

Har Dayal broke with the movement in March 1919. He asked the British for an amnesty, a pardon. He died in Philadelphia in 1939.

In America, some Ghadarites had taken German money for arms. They were tried in San Francisco in 1917–18, and 29 Indians and Germans were convicted. On the last day, in April 1918, one defendant, Ram Singh, shot dead another, the party leader Ram Chandra. Ram Singh suspected him of betraying the cause or its funds. Ram Singh was himself shot dead in the courtroom.

The party lived on through the Kirti movement and the Babbar Akalis. After 1947 it gave its San Francisco property to India.

Canada’s ‘continuous journey’ rule outlived almost everyone in this story. It was finally revoked on 26 November 1947.

Part 14

Sorry, a century later

Vancouver (Burrard Inlet)

The apologies came slowly, and some came twice. On 15 May 2008 the House of Commons passed a motion on the incident, moved by the Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla. On 23 May 2008 the British Columbia legislature unanimously apologised.

On 3 August 2008, Prime Minister Stephen Harper apologised in a park in Surrey. It was at a Ghadar festival, before a crowd of about 8,000. Many were angry. They said they had been promised an apology in the House of Commons.

On 18 May 2016, Justin Trudeau stood up in the House of Commons. Passengers’ descendants watched from the gallery. He apologised on behalf of the government of Canada for the laws that had kept them out.

The Komagata Maru incident is a stain on Canada’s past.Justin Trudeau, House of Commons, 18 May 2016

Vancouver’s city council apologised in 2021. In 2019 Ottawa took H.H. Stevens’s name off a federal building. In 2024 part of Vancouver’s waterfront was co-named Komagata Maru Place. India struck centenary coins in 2014.

Britain’s troops and police fired at Budge Budge. Its tribunal hanged Sarabha. Britain has made no formal apology for either that we could find.

For Punjabis in Canada, the story never became ancient history. Canada now counts more Sikhs than any country outside India, and Punjabi Sikhs sit in its Parliament. The harbour that turned the ship away is in the same province where Hardeep Singh Nijjar was shot dead in 2023. That killing set India and Canada at odds.

Readers’ poll

Was Canada’s apology enough?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 15

From Astoria to Lahore, step by step

Key dates

  1. 8 Jan 1908Canada brings in the ‘continuous journey’ rule; the Vancouver gurdwara opens the same month.
  2. 1913The Ghadar Party is founded at Astoria, Oregon (date disputed).
  3. 4 Apr 1914The Komagata Maru sails from Hong Kong.
  4. 23 May 1914It anchors in Vancouver with 376 passengers.
  5. 19 Jul 1914Passengers drive off the police tug Sea Lion.
  6. 23 Jul 1914The ship leaves Vancouver.
  7. 29 Sep 1914Troops fire on passengers at Budge Budge.
  8. 15 Feb 1915Mutiny in Singapore.
  9. 19 Feb 1915The planned rising fails in Punjab.
  10. 16 Nov 1915Kartar Singh Sarabha and six others hanged in Lahore.
  11. 15 Nov 1921Gurdit Singh surrenders at Nankana Sahib.
  12. 26 Nov 1947The continuous journey rule is revoked.
  13. 18 May 2016Justin Trudeau apologises in the House of Commons.
Part 16

Our take

Strip away a century of speeches and the story is still plain. Canada wrote a rule to keep out brown subjects of its own Empire without saying so. It enforced that rule on a hungry ship for two months. British India met the same men with rifles on a riverbank. Neither government has much to be proud of.

The Ghadarites were brave, and some were very young. They also killed policemen, informers and headmen, many of them fellow Punjabis. The violence ran every way. An informer fired into a congregation. An inspector was shot in a courthouse. Troops fired on seated men. A 19-year-old was hanged.

What they won was not a free India in 1915. It was an idea that outlived them: that ordinary Punjabi workers abroad, Sikh, Hindu and Muslim together, could stand up to an empire. Bhagat Singh carried it in his pocket. A century late, Canada admitted they had been wronged. That is worth remembering, all of it.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. What did the passengers call the Komagata Maru?

  2. Where was the Ghadar Party founded in 1913?

  3. What did Canada’s 1908 rule demand of immigrants?

  4. What did passengers throw to drive off the police tug Sea Lion on 19 July 1914?

  5. Who shot the immigration inspector William Hopkinson in October 1914?

  6. How old was Kartar Singh Sarabha when he was hanged?

  7. In which year did Justin Trudeau apologise in the House of Commons?

Play: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

What was the Komagata Maru incident?

In 1914 Gurdit Singh chartered a Japanese steamer. It carried 376 people from Punjab to Vancouver to challenge Canada’s ‘continuous journey’ rule. Canada refused almost all of them entry. It kept the ship at anchor for two months and sent it back on 23 July 1914.

What was the continuous journey regulation?

It was an order in council of 8 January 1908. It barred immigrants who did not arrive by a continuous journey from their country of birth. No shipping line ran directly from India to Canada. So in practice it shut out Indians without naming them. It was revoked in 1947.

What happened at Budge Budge?

On 29 September 1914 the returning passengers refused a special train to Punjab and tried to march to Calcutta. Troops and police fired on them. Most counts say 18 to 20 passengers died. Official records list 26 dead in all. Gurdit Singh escaped.

What was the Ghadar Party?

It was a revolutionary party founded in 1913 by Indian workers and students on North America’s west coast, most of them Punjabi Sikhs. Sohan Singh Bhakna was its president and Lala Har Dayal its general secretary. Its paper, Ghadar, called for armed revolt against British rule.

Who was Kartar Singh Sarabha?

He was a young Ghadar activist from Sarabha village near Ludhiana. He ran the Punjabi edition of the party paper. He went back to India to start a rising in the army. He was hanged in Lahore on 16 November 1915, aged 19. Bhagat Singh called him his hero.

Has Canada apologised for the Komagata Maru?

Yes. British Columbia’s legislature apologised in 2008. Stephen Harper apologised at a community event in Surrey in 2008. Justin Trudeau gave a formal apology in the House of Commons on 18 May 2016.

How we wrote this. We built this story from the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Canadian government records, the books and articles cited in the sources below and reports in The Tribune, Scroll.in, CBC and other outlets. The TrendingPunjabi desk wrote it in our own words with the help of an AI model. Sources disagree on the date and place of the Ghadar Party’s founding (Portland 1912, Astoria in spring or July 1913), on the passenger count by faith, on how many passengers were allowed to land, on who fired first at Budge Budge and how many died there (18, 20 or 26 in all), on the Singapore executions (37 or 47) and on whether Sarabha was hanged on 16 or 17 November 1915. We give each version and say who holds it. Quotes from Sarabha and O’Dwyer are as recorded by later writers. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources (18)

  1. Wikipedia: Komagata Maru incident (citing Hugh Johnston, Ali Kazimi and the Komagata Maru inquiry records)
  2. Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Punjabi University: Gurdit Singh, Baba (1861–1954), by Jaswant Singh Jass
  3. Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Punjabi University: Ghadr Movement, by Emily C. Brown
  4. UCLA Center for India and South Asia: The Tragedy of the Komagata Maru, by Vinay Lal
  5. Prime Minister of Canada: Prime Minister delivers formal Komagata Maru apology in the House of Commons (18 May 2016)
  6. Wikipedia: Continuous journey regulation
  7. Wikipedia: Ghadar Party (citing Johanna Ogden, Maia Ramnath and Harish Puri)
  8. Wikipedia: Ghadar Mutiny (citing Hugh Strachan, Peter Hopkirk and the Sedition Committee report)
  9. The Oregon Encyclopedia: East Indians of Oregon and the Ghadar Party, by Johanna Ogden
  10. OPB: India’s 1947 independence had roots in Astoria with Punjabi immigrants
  11. Wikipedia: Kartar Singh Sarabha
  12. The Tribune: When Baba Bhakna was saved from gallows by Motilal Nehru, by Vishav Bharti (3 January 2020)
  13. Scroll.in: The 1915 Ghadar plan to free India from the British was a failure, but it sparked a revolution, by Haroon Khalid (27 April 2018)
  14. Wikipedia: Mewa Singh Lopoke
  15. Maclean’s: Komagata Maru, with apologies to
  16. CBC News: Harry Stevens’ name stripped from federal building in Vancouver over Komagata Maru
  17. Scroll.in: 100 years on: remembering the Hindu–German conspiracy
  18. Wikipedia: Ram Chandra Bharadwaj
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All history · People in history · History of the Sikhs · History of Punjab · History of India