1. Home
  2. News
  3. Crime Files
  4. Nirbhaya case
Crime Files

Nirbhaya: The Bus Ride That Shook India, and the Seven Years to the Gallows

On a cold Sunday night in December 2012, a 23-year-old student and her friend got on the wrong bus in south Delhi. Thirteen days later she was dead, and India was on the streets. The attack, the protests, the new laws, the trial, the long wait for four hangings, and the question that never went away: did anything change?

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 20 min read WhatsApp

Nirbhaya: The Bus Ride That Shook India, and the Seven Years to the Gallows
Photo: Nilroy (Nilanjana Roy) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In short

  • On the night of 16 December 2012, a 23-year-old student, called Nirbhaya, and her male friend were attacked by six men on a moving private bus in south Delhi. She was gang-raped and so badly injured that she died on 29 December in a Singapore hospital.
  • Huge protests followed. The Justice Verma Committee read about 80,000 suggestions in about a month, and Parliament passed the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, adding stalking, voyeurism and acid attacks as crimes and the death penalty for the worst rapes.
  • The driver, Ram Singh, died in Tihar in March 2013 before any verdict. The 17-year-old was convicted by the Juvenile Justice Board and spent three years in a reform home. The other four were sentenced to death in 2013, upheld by the Delhi High Court in 2014 and the Supreme Court in 2017.
  • After four death warrants and a string of mercy pleas, the four were hanged at Tihar at 5:30 am on 20 March 2020. Rape cases recorded by police are still close to 30,000 a year, and only about 27 to 28 in every 100 rape trials end in conviction.

Case file

Sentence carried out
Victim
A 23-year-old physiotherapy student, known by the name the courts and the public use: Nirbhaya, ‘the fearless one’
Where
A private bus moving through south Delhi, boarded at Munirka; the two victims were thrown out near Mahipalpur
When
About 9:30 pm, Sunday 16 December 2012. She died in Singapore on 29 December
Accused
Six: the driver Ram Singh, Mukesh Singh, Vinay Sharma, Pawan Gupta, Akshay Thakur, and a 17-year-old who by law cannot be named
Verdicts
Juvenile Justice Board: the 17-year-old convicted, three years in a reform home (2013). Trial court: four sentenced to death (2013). Delhi High Court upheld it (2014), the Supreme Court upheld it (2017) and dismissed the reviews (2018–2019)
Ram Singh
Found hanging in his Tihar cell on 11 March 2013, before any verdict. Officially a suicide; his family said he was murdered
End
Mukesh Singh, Vinay Sharma, Pawan Gupta and Akshay Thakur were hanged at Tihar Jail at 5:30 am on 20 March 2020
In this story · 16 parts
  1. 16 Dec 2012A film, a bus, a wrong turn
  2. 16 Dec 2012On the roadside
  3. 29 Dec 2012Thirteen days
  4. 22 Dec 2012India on the street
  5. 18–22 Dec 2012Six men in under a week
  6. 23 Jan 2013Eighty thousand letters
  7. 13 Sep 2013A fast-track court, a death in a cell
  8. Dec 2015Three years for the seventeen-year-old
  9. 5 May 2017Appeal after appeal
  10. Mar 2015The film India banned
  11. Jan–Mar 2020Four dates for one hanging
  12. 20 Mar 20205:30 am, 20 March 2020
  13. Part 13Claims and rumours, checked
  14. Part 14Did the gallows help?
  15. 2012–2024Did anything change?
  16. Part 16Our take
Part 1

A film, a bus, a wrong turn

Munirka, Delhi

Sunday, 16 December 2012, a winter evening in Delhi. In a cinema at the Select Citywalk mall in Saket, two friends watched Life of Pi, the film about a boy who survives the sea with a tiger in his boat.

She was 23, a physiotherapy student from a family that had come to Delhi from Ballia in Uttar Pradesh. India would come to know her as Nirbhaya, ‘the fearless one’, a name given by the press because the law does not allow a rape victim’s real name to be printed.

Her friend was Awindra Pratap Pandey, a software engineer from Gorakhpur. He would later speak about that night on television under his own name.

After the film they took an auto-rickshaw to the bus stop at Munirka. They wanted to get towards Dwarka. At about 9:30 pm a white private bus pulled up. A boy on it called out that it was going their way. They got on and paid ten rupees each.

There were six men on board, including the driver. The doors were shut. The bus did not take its normal route.

When Awindra objected, the men turned on him. They taunted the pair, then beat him with an iron rod until he was knocked senseless. They dragged her to the back of the bus. While the bus kept moving through the city, they raped her in turn and assaulted her with the rod, injuring her so badly inside that doctors later had to remove most of her intestine. She fought back. She bit three of them.

Then they stripped both friends, robbed them, and threw them out of the moving bus onto the roadside near Mahipalpur, close to the airport.

Part 2

On the roadside

Mahipalpur, Delhi

What happened in the next few minutes became its own argument.

Awindra told Zee News in early January 2013 that cars, autos and bikes slowed down to look, and that nobody stopped for about 25 minutes. When police vans came, he said, they wasted time deciding which police station the case belonged to. He said he lifted his friend into the van himself.

Only Nirbhaya and I know what happened on that night.Awindra Pratap Pandey, the friend who was with her, to IBN Live in March 2015

Delhi Police said the opposite. Joint Commissioner Vivek Gogia told reporters that a police van reached the spot within three minutes of the alert and left for hospital within 12. That time, he said, went in lifting her in and fetching a bed sheet from a nearby hotel to cover her. By the police log, the van, called Zebra 54, left at 10:39 pm and reached Safdarjung Hospital at 10:55 pm.

Both accounts are on the record. No court has settled which is right. What nobody disputes is that she reached a hospital bed alive, and that she could still speak.

Part 3

Thirteen days

Singapore

At Safdarjung Hospital that first night, a doctor named Rashmi Ahuja took down her case history. Even then, hours after the attack, she told the doctor that more than two men had raped her on the bus. It was the first of three statements she would make. In law they are called dying declarations: the words of someone who believes she may not live.

She had surgery after surgery. On 19 December, in her fifth operation, doctors removed most of what was left of her intestine. She was on a ventilator, in and out of consciousness.

On 21 December, a magistrate, SDM Usha Chaturvedi, came to her bed. This time she told the whole story: the bus, what each man did, the rod, the robbery, being thrown out. On 25 December, when she could no longer talk, a metropolitan magistrate named Pawan Kumar asked her questions with several answers to choose from. She replied by nodding, by gestures and by writing.

Late on 26 December, the government flew her to Mount Elizabeth Hospital in Singapore. The decision was taken at a cabinet meeting chaired by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Some doctors questioned it. The flight took six hours. On the way her heart stopped, and she was without a pulse for nearly three minutes. She never woke up again.

She died at 4:45 am Singapore time on 29 December 2012, thirteen days after she got on the bus. She was cremated in Delhi the next day, under heavy police guard.

Part 4

India on the street

Raisina Hill, Delhi

Long before she died, the country had stopped waiting. From 18 December, when the first arrests were announced, students began gathering. By Saturday, 22 December, thousands had walked up Raisina Hill, the slope that leads to Rashtrapati Bhavan and the ministries.

A group of people sitting and standing in prayer at India Gate in the evening
A group at India Gate praying for her recovery on 21 December 2012, eight days before she died. The photographer said the protest was peaceful when he visited, and turned violent later.Photo: Ramesh Lalwani · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The police answered with water cannon, tear gas and lathis. Hindustan Times counted 375 tear gas shells used. Metro stations in central Delhi were shut and gatherings were banned. Young women held up handmade signs. Some boys climbed lampposts with the tricolour. Some placards demanded death for the rapists.

Protesters near Rajpath as police use tear gas
Students on Rajpath on 22 December 2012, as police turned water cannon and tear gas on the crowd.Photo: Nilroy (Nilanjana Roy) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Not everyone on the street was a protester. A Delhi Police constable, Subhash Tomar, collapsed during the clashes and died in hospital. Doctors gave conflicting accounts of why. Police charged eight young men with his murder, then dropped the charges in March 2013.

After her death, the marches spread across India, with candlelight marches in Kolkata, Bengaluru and other cities, and into Nepal, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Bangladesh. Delhi had lit candles for a murdered woman before, after the Jessica Lal verdict in 2006. This was bigger. The anger was about more than one case: it was about what women in Indian cities put up with every day.

Some men in public life made it worse. The self-styled godman Asaram said she shared the blame and should have pleaded with her attackers. The President’s son, Abhijit Mukherjee, called the women protesting ‘dented and painted’, then apologised. The anger only grew.

Part 5

Six men in under a week

Delhi

The police moved fast. The bus had been seen. CCTV at a hotel near Delhi Airport caught it passing twice that night. It was registered to a travel operator, and its driver was known: a man named Ram Singh, who used the same bus on school runs.

Earlier the same evening, police said, the gang had used the bus to rob a carpenter and dump him at the IIT flyover. He went to the police. Three constables did not act on his complaint, and they were later suspended. Later that evening, the same bus stopped at Munirka.

Ram Singh and three others were arrested on 18 December. The 17-year-old was picked up at Anand Vihar bus terminal on 21 December. The last, Akshay Thakur, was caught in Bihar on 22 December.

The six accused (ages as reported at arrest)

  • Ram Singh30The driver. Found dead in Tihar in March 2013, before any verdict
  • Mukesh Singh26His younger brother. Convicted and sentenced to death. Hanged in 2020
  • Vinay Sharma20An assistant at a gym. Convicted and sentenced to death. Hanged in 2020
  • Pawan Gupta19A fruit seller. Convicted and sentenced to death. Hanged in 2020
  • Akshay Thakur28The bus helper. Convicted and sentenced to death. Hanged in 2020
  • The juvenile17Not named, by law. Convicted by the Juvenile Justice Board in 2013; three years in a reform home

On 21 December, Awindra identified Mukesh Singh. He would be the prosecution’s first witness, PW-1, and its only eyewitness.

Part 6

Eighty thousand letters

Delhi

On 23 December 2012, the government asked a retired Chief Justice of India, J.S. Verma, to rewrite the law on sexual violence. He was 79. He was given 30 days, with two colleagues: Leila Seth, a former High Court chief justice, and Gopal Subramanium, a former Solicitor General.

The public was invited to write in. About 80,000 suggestions arrived, by email, by post, by hand. Verma said every one was read. Some, the committee said, were exceptionally good. Some were casual. The 630-page report came back on 23 January 2013, a month after the committee was set up.

Failure of good governance is the obvious root cause.Justice J.S. Verma, on the unsafe environment for women, 23 January 2013

It asked for much more than tougher sentences. Make rape punishable with life in prison. Criminalise rape within marriage. Rethink the law that shields soldiers in conflict areas, AFSPA, so sexual crimes by them can be tried. Stop the invasive medical test that survivors were put through. Free the police from political control. Bar candidates charged with sexual offences from elections. And no death penalty: the committee said there was considerable evidence that it does not deter serious crime, and that women’s groups had overwhelmingly asked it not to recommend it.

The government took much of the report and left out some of its hardest parts. An ordinance was signed on 3 February 2013. Parliament passed the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act on 19 and 21 March, and the President signed it on 2 April.

  • Rape was defined more widely, beyond one narrow act.
  • Stalking, voyeurism, acid attacks and stripping a woman by force became specific crimes.
  • Gang rape now carried at least 20 years in prison.
  • Rape that leaves a woman dead or in a vegetative state, and repeat rape, could now be punished with death, against the committee’s advice.
  • Marital rape stayed legal. AFSPA was not touched. Amnesty International called the law not nearly enough.

In the 2013 budget, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram also set aside Rs 1,000 crore for women’s safety. It was named the Nirbhaya Fund.

Part 7

A fast-track court, a death in a cell

Saket, Delhi

On 3 January 2013, police filed charges against the five adults. A new fast-track court for sexual offences opened in Saket, a short walk from the mall where the evening had begun. The trial started on 17 January.

Then, early on 11 March 2013, Ram Singh was found hanging in his cell in Tihar Jail. He was on suicide watch, sharing the cell with other prisoners. The jail said he killed himself. His father said he was murdered. His lawyer said he had no reason to take his own life. An inquiry found suicide. The case against him ended with him: no court ever ruled on his guilt.

The rest of the trial was about evidence, and there was a lot of it. The court had her three dying declarations. It had Awindra’s testimony. It had the hotel CCTV. Fingerprints and bloodstains were lifted from the bus. Hair from the third row and a bloodstained seat cover gave DNA that matched hers.

On 10 September 2013, Additional Sessions Judge Yogesh Khanna convicted Mukesh, Vinay, Pawan and Akshay of gang rape, murder, robbery and other charges. Three days later he sentenced all four to hang.

Shocked the collective conscience.Judge Yogesh Khanna, on the crime, 13 September 2013

He placed it in the ‘rarest of rare’ category, the test Indian courts use before they allow a death sentence.

Part 8

Three years for the seventeen-year-old

Delhi

The sixth accused was tried somewhere else. He was 17 years and about six months old that night, and under the law of the time anyone under 18 went before a Juvenile Justice Board, not a criminal court. The board refused requests to test his bones to check his age, and on 28 January 2013 it ruled him a minor. A plea to try him as an adult was dismissed.

On 31 August 2013 the board convicted him of rape and murder. The punishment was the most the Juvenile Justice Act then allowed: three years in a reform home, counting the eight months he had already spent there.

Through the trial, TV channels called him ‘the most brutal’ of the six. The record does not support that. The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights studied the board’s final order and the evidence, and wrote in 2013 that he was not the most brutal, as the media claimed.

He walked out in December 2015. The Delhi High Court refused to stop his release, and a last appeal to the Supreme Court failed. Nirbhaya’s parents joined protesters on the day of his release and were detained by police. On 22 December 2015, two days after he left, the Rajya Sabha passed a new Juvenile Justice Act. It lets 16- and 17-year-olds accused of heinous crimes be tried as adults. It could not apply to him, because a law cannot punish a crime that happened before it was passed.

That December, at the third anniversary of the attack, Nirbhaya’s mother Asha Devi chose to say her daughter’s name in public. We still call her Nirbhaya, as the courts did to the end.

Readers’ poll

Should 16- and 17-year-olds accused of the worst crimes be tried as adults?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 9

Appeal after appeal

Delhi

A death sentence in India is not final until the High Court confirms it. On 13 March 2014, Justices Reva Khetrapal and Pratibha Rani of the Delhi High Court did, and dismissed the four men’s appeals.

The Supreme Court stayed the hangings and took up the case. It heard it for almost a year. In February 2017 it reopened the question of sentence, and asked for anything in the men’s lives that might argue for mercy. On 5 May 2017, Justices Dipak Misra, R. Banumathi and Ashok Bhushan upheld the death sentences together. The aggravating circumstances, they said, outweighed the mitigating ones.

Offences against women are not a women’s issue alone but, human rights issue.Justice R. Banumathi, Supreme Court, 5 May 2017
The domed central wing of the Supreme Court of India building in New Delhi
The Supreme Court in New Delhi, which upheld the death sentences in May 2017 and dismissed the review petitions in 2018 and 2019.Photo: en:User:MohitSingh · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In a review petition, the defence tried again. The Supreme Court’s ruling of 9 July 2018 sets out both sides plainly.

The last argument in court

What the defence argued (A.P. Singh for Vinay Sharma and Pawan Gupta, 2018)

  • The death penalty should be abolished, as Britain and many other countries have done.
  • Police had tried to book the vulnerable and the innocent to cover their failure to find the real culprits.
  • The three dying declarations were contrived and differed on the number of attackers and the bus; the first named nobody, and she could not have given a long statement while on morphine.
  • The DNA results could not be trusted because she had had blood transfusions.
  • Vinay Sharma was at a church music programme from 8:15 pm that night, and both Vinay and Pawan were really under 18.

What the prosecution said, and the court found (Sidharth Luthra for Delhi, 2018)

  • CCTV caught the bus twice near the airport hotel; fingerprints, bloodstains and hair matched by DNA proved it was the bus.
  • All three dying declarations had already been examined at length in 2017, and the court found them reliable.
  • The transfusion argument and the church alibi had been weighed and rejected on the evidence.
  • School admission records, and the men’s own parents, showed both were adults.
  • Only Parliament can abolish the death penalty; the Supreme Court upheld it as lawful in Bachan Singh (1980).

The court found no error and dismissed the reviews of Mukesh, Vinay and Pawan on 9 July 2018. Akshay Thakur’s review, filed later, was dismissed at the end of 2019. In January 2020, five judges rejected the curative petitions of Vinay and Mukesh, the very last step inside the courts.

Part 10

The film India banned

Tihar Jail, Delhi

In March 2015, while the appeals were still in the Supreme Court, a British filmmaker named Leslee Udwin was about to release India’s Daughter, a documentary for the BBC. In it, Mukesh Singh spoke from Tihar. He blamed the victim for being out at 9 pm and for fighting back.

A girl is far more responsible for rape than a boy.Mukesh Singh, in India’s Daughter, as reported by AFP, March 2015

Two of the defence lawyers also spoke in the film, about how women should behave. The Bar Council of India called their remarks objectionable and sent them notices to explain themselves.

Delhi Police got a court order stopping the film being shown in India, saying the comments created fear and tension. Home Minister Rajnath Singh called them an affront to the dignity of women. The BBC showed it in Britain anyway, and the government asked YouTube to block it. Nirbhaya’s father said the film held up a mirror to society. Awindra called it unbalanced and fake, because her side was missing.

Part 11

Four dates for one hanging

Delhi

Once the courts were done, each man still had one more door: a mercy petition to the President. And prison rules say that if one person in a shared case has a plea pending, none of them can be hanged.

So the pleas came one at a time. A Delhi court first fixed the hanging for 22 January 2020. Then for 1 February. On 31 January, Additional Sessions Judge Dharmender Rana put it off again, noting what he called dilatory tactics. Then 3 March. Then 20 March.

Each new date was a new wound for one family. When the March 3 date fell, Asha Devi said the repeated postponements showed the failure of the system.

Our entire system supports criminals.Asha Devi, Nirbhaya’s mother, 2 March 2020

Three of the men even petitioned the International Court of Justice in The Hague. The date did not move.

Part 12

5:30 am, 20 March 2020

Tihar Jail, Delhi

The last night was spent in courtrooms. The Delhi High Court heard a plea late on Thursday, 19 March, and turned it down. At 2:30 am, three Supreme Court judges, R. Banumathi, Ashok Bhushan and A.S. Bopanna, sat in a special hearing on Pawan Gupta’s final petition. They found no grounds in it. In the last 24 hours, courts had turned away five separate attempts to stop the hanging.

The main entrance gate of Tihar Jail in Delhi
The gate of Tihar Jail in west Delhi, where the four men were hanged together on 20 March 2020.Photo: Zuck28 · CC0 · Wikimedia Commons

At 5:30 am, in Tihar Jail, Mukesh Singh, Vinay Sharma, Pawan Gupta and Akshay Thakur were hanged together. Jail officials said it was the first time four men had been hanged at once in Tihar. A doctor declared them dead.

Outside the jail, people waved the national flag and chanted. An activist handed out sweets. Prime Minister Narendra Modi wrote that justice had prevailed. Badrinath Singh, Nirbhaya’s father, said it was their victory. Her mother spoke to reporters at home after a night without sleep.

Justice delayed, but not denied.Asha Devi, 20 March 2020

Amnesty International India called the hangings a dark stain on India’s human rights record. India had not executed anyone since August 2015, it said, and the death penalty would not end violence against women. It had been seven years, three months and four days since the bus stopped at Munirka.

Part 13

Claims and rumours, checked

A case this big drew rumours from the start, many of them spread by TV and social media. Here are the ones people still repeat, with what the record shows.

Claim 1

The juvenile was the most brutal of the six

Why people believed it

TV channels said it again and again, quoting unnamed police sources, and it drove the fury at his three-year sentence.

What the record shows

The Juvenile Justice Board convicted him of rape and murder. But the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights, after studying the board’s final order and evidence in 2013, wrote that he was not the most brutal, as the media had claimed. No court ever found that he was.

BustedNot supported by the record.

Claim 2

Ram Singh was murdered in his cell

Why people believed it

He died on suicide watch, in a shared cell. His father said he had been threatened and was killed, and his lawyer called it foul play.

What the record shows

Jail officials said he hanged himself, and an inquiry found suicide. In 2019, Tihar’s former law officer Sunil Gupta wrote in his book Black Warrant that he believed the cell mates were allowed to kill him. No court has ruled on it.

Still openOfficially suicide; the doubts were never tested in court.

Claim 3

The bus was planted and the men were framed

Why people believed it

It was the defence’s case through every court, along with an alibi for Vinay Sharma.

What the record shows

Three courts found otherwise: CCTV of the bus near the airport, fingerprints, bloodstains, and DNA from hair and a seat cover matching hers, plus three dying declarations and the eyewitness. The Supreme Court rejected it again on review in 2018.

BustedRejected by every court that heard it.

Claim 4

The police let them lie on the road while arguing over jurisdiction

Why people believed it

Her friend said so on Zee News in January 2013: nobody stopped for about 25 minutes, and the police argued about which station the case belonged to.

What the record shows

Delhi Police denied it. They said the van arrived within three minutes of the alert and reached Safdarjung Hospital at 10:55 pm. Three constables were suspended, but that was for ignoring the carpenter robbed earlier that night.

Still openTwo accounts on the record; never settled.

Claim 5

The juvenile was rewarded with money and a sewing machine

Why people believed it

When he came out in 2015, posts said the government was paying him for his crime.

What the record shows

Officials did plan help for him to set up as a tailor, and a new identity. The aftercare rules allow that kind of support for any young offender leaving a reform home; it was not a special payment for this case.

BustedHalf true: standard aftercare, sold as a reward.

Claim 6

Nirbhaya named her attackers in her very first statement

Why people believed it

Many retellings say she named them from the start.

What the record shows

Her first statement, to the doctor on the night of the attack, named nobody and said more than two men raped her. The full story, with each man’s role, came in her second statement on 21 December. The courts found the three statements consistent where it mattered.

BustedNot quite. The detail came later, and the courts accepted why.

Part 14

Did the gallows help?

The hanging ended the case. It did not end the argument about whether it should have happened.

Students holding a placard reading Hang The Rapists at a protest in Delhi
‘Hang the rapists’: a placard at the Raisina Hill protests on 22 December 2012. Many protesters wanted death for the worst rapes; women’s groups told the Verma Committee the opposite.Photo: Nilroy (Nilanjana Roy) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The death penalty: both sides

For the death sentence

  • The trial court said the crime shocked the collective conscience, and three courts agreed it was among the rarest of rare cases.
  • The Supreme Court found nothing in the men’s lives that outweighed what they did.
  • Parliament chose death for the worst rapes in 2013, against the Verma Committee’s advice, and widened it in 2018 to the rape of girls under 12.
  • Nirbhaya’s parents fought for seven years to see it carried out, and called the hanging justice.

Against it

  • The Verma Committee said there was considerable evidence that the death penalty does not deter serious crime.
  • Justice Verma said women’s groups overwhelmingly asked him not to recommend it.
  • Amnesty International said there was no evidence it deters crime and called the hangings a dark stain.
  • The defence argued that most of the world has abolished it, and that it should go in India too.

Readers’ poll

Was hanging the four men the right punishment?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 15

Did anything change?

Some things did change. The law is wider. Stalking is a crime. Fast-track courts exist. A police officer who refuses to register a rape complaint can now be punished for it. And the silence broke: women talked about what happens on buses and streets in a way they rarely had before.

The numbers are harder to read. In 2012, the National Crime Records Bureau counted about 25,000 rapes reported to police across India. Since then the figure has stayed mostly above 30,000 a year, peaking at nearly 39,000 in 2016. In 2024 it was 29,536. All crimes against women together came to 4,41,534 cases that year, about 1.4 per cent fewer than in 2023.

These figures count only cases the police register. A rise can mean more women are coming forward, not only more crime, and a fall can mean the opposite. Nobody can read safety straight off them.

Justice is slower than the headlines. Between 2018 and 2022, only 27 to 28 per cent of rape trials that finished ended in conviction, by NCRB data reported by Reuters. Most cases take years.

And the money? The Nirbhaya Fund grew from Rs 1,000 crore to about Rs 3,000 crore by 2016. A parliamentary committee complained that year that almost all of it was lying idle. In December 2024, a minister told the Lok Sabha that about 74 per cent had now been used.

Readers’ poll

Is India safer for women than it was in December 2012?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 16

Our take

Nirbhaya did everything a careful young woman in Delhi is told to do. She went out with a friend. She was heading home before ten. She took transport that looked safe. None of it was enough, and that is what sent a whole country into the cold that December.

The case shows India at its best and its worst. Police who caught six men in under a week, and constables who ignored a robbed carpenter an hour earlier. A committee that read 80,000 letters in a month, and a government that kept the gallows and left marital rape alone. Courts that tested every piece of evidence, and a system that took seven years and four death warrants to finish what they decided.

Four men were hanged. A fifth died in his cell. A sixth walked free at 20, and the law keeps his name secret. Her mother is still speaking. The question she keeps asking is the one that matters most: not whether the men who killed her daughter were punished, but whether the next girl at the next bus stop gets home.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. What had the two friends been doing before they got on the bus?

  2. How many dying declarations did Nirbhaya make in hospital?

  3. Where did Nirbhaya die?

  4. What did the Justice Verma Committee recommend as the punishment for rape?

  5. What did CCTV at a hotel near Delhi Airport show?

  6. How many dates were fixed for the hanging before it finally happened?

  7. What happened to the 17-year-old accused?

Quick check: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

What happened in the Nirbhaya case?

On 16 December 2012, a 23-year-old physiotherapy student and her friend boarded a private bus at Munirka in south Delhi. Six men on board beat the friend and gang-raped her, then threw both out near Mahipalpur. She died of her injuries in Singapore on 29 December 2012.

Why is she called Nirbhaya?

Indian law bars publishing the name of a rape victim, so the press gave her names such as Nirbhaya, which means ‘fearless’. The courts used it too, in their judgments, as ‘Nirbhaya (changed name)’.

What happened to the six accused?

The driver Ram Singh was found hanging in his Tihar cell in March 2013, before a verdict. The 17-year-old was convicted by the Juvenile Justice Board and sent to a reform home for three years, the most the law then allowed. Mukesh Singh, Vinay Sharma, Pawan Gupta and Akshay Thakur were sentenced to death and hanged on 20 March 2020.

Why did the hanging take so long?

The death sentence passed through the trial court (2013), the Delhi High Court (2014) and the Supreme Court (2017), then review petitions, curative petitions and mercy petitions to the President. The four men filed them one after another, and the rules say a hanging must wait while any plea is pending, so four death warrants were issued before the last one held.

What laws changed after the Nirbhaya case?

The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013 widened the definition of rape, made stalking, voyeurism and acid attacks specific crimes, set a minimum of 20 years for gang rape and allowed the death penalty when a rape leaves the victim dead or in a vegetative state, and for repeat offenders. The Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 allows 16- and 17-year-olds accused of heinous crimes to be tried as adults.

Who is Asha Devi?

Asha Devi is Nirbhaya’s mother. She followed the case through every court for seven years and campaigned for faster justice and tougher laws. After the hanging she said: ‘Justice delayed, but not denied.’

How we wrote this. Researched from the Supreme Court’s 2018 review judgment, reports of the 2013, 2014 and 2017 judgments, the Verma Committee’s findings and the reports listed below, and written in our own words by the TrendingPunjabi desk with the help of an AI model. Following the law and the courts, we do not use the victim’s real name or any picture of her, and we do not name the juvenile offender. Her friend is named because he has spoken publicly under his own name. Ram Singh died before a verdict and was never convicted. Sources differ on some ages (Ram Singh is given as 30 or 33), on exact times that night, and on how quickly police reached the scene; where they do, we give both accounts. The 2024 Nirbhaya Fund figure (about 74 per cent used) is the government’s own, given in the Lok Sabha and reported by PTI.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of India: Vinay Sharma v. State of NCT of Delhi, review judgment, Supreme Court, 9 July 2018
  2. SCC Online: Mukesh v. State for NCT of Delhi (2017) 6 SCC 1: death penalty of the four upheld
  3. LiveLaw: Death sentence of four convicts upheld by the Delhi High Court, 2014
  4. Al Jazeera: Delhi gang rapists sentenced to death, 13 September 2013
  5. The Tribune: Brutal rape, murder: how the events unfolded
  6. CBS News: India police deny they delayed helping rape victim (AP), 5 January 2013
  7. Newslaundry: Conversations with Ramnath Goenka awardees: interviewing Nirbhaya’s friend
  8. Dawn: Sole witness of Delhi bus gang-rape calls BBC documentary fake
  9. Dawn: India bans broadcast of gang-rapist documentary (AFP)
  10. Bar & Bench: BCI issues show cause notices to ML Sharma, AP Singh over India’s Daughter interview
  11. PRS Legislative Research: Justice Verma Committee report summary
  12. Al Jazeera: India panel pushes new laws after deadly rape, 23 January 2013
  13. Wikipedia: 2012 Delhi gang rape and murder (protests, juvenile case, documentary)
  14. Amnesty International UK: India: new rape law not nearly enough
  15. PRS Legislative Research: The Criminal Law (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018
  16. The News Minute: Busting myths being propagated by media about Nirbhaya’s juvenile rapist
  17. Business Standard: Ram Singh was murdered, says his father
  18. The Quint: Black Warrant: a compilation of unheard stories of Tihar
  19. Business Standard: Entire system supports criminals: Nirbhaya’s mother after court stays execution (ANI)
  20. The Quint: Nirbhaya gang rape and murder convicts hanged to death
  21. Business Today: Nirbhaya accused hanged: ‘Justice delayed, but not denied,’ says Asha Devi
  22. The Quint: Amnesty calls hanging of Nirbhaya convicts a dark stain on Indian human rights record
  23. ThePrint: Factbox: India’s struggles with high rape cases, low conviction rates (Reuters), 2024
  24. ThePrint: NCRB report out: crimes against women saw minor dip in 2024
  25. Governance Now; ThePrint: All you need to know about the Nirbhaya Fund (2016); 74% of Nirbhaya Fund utilised, WCD ministry (PTI, 2024)
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All Crime Files stories · All news