1. Home
  2. News
  3. Crime Files
  4. Tandoor murder case
Crime Files

The Tandoor Murder: A Fire on Ashoka Road, Two Bullets an X-ray Found, and 23 Years in Tihar

Near midnight on 2 July 1995, a constable on patrol saw flames rising from a restaurant in the heart of New Delhi. In the clay oven was the body of Naina Sahni. Her husband, a Youth Congress leader, was already running. The night, the second post-mortem, the death sentence, the Supreme Court’s mercy, and the release.

By Simar, TrendingPunjabi news desk 19 min read WhatsApp

The Tandoor Murder: A Fire on Ashoka Road, Two Bullets an X-ray Found, and 23 Years in Tihar

In short

  • On the night of 2 July 1995, Constable Abdul Nazir Kunju and Home Guard Chander Pal found the body of Naina Sahni burning in the tandoor of the Bagiya restaurant on Ashoka Road, New Delhi.
  • Her husband, Delhi Youth Congress president Sushil Sharma, fled and was taken into custody in Bangalore on 10 July. A second post-mortem found two bullets that matched his revolver, and DNA confirmed the body was hers.
  • A trial court convicted him and sentenced him to death in November 2003; the Delhi High Court confirmed it in 2007. The Supreme Court upheld the conviction in 2013 but commuted the sentence to life.
  • The restaurant manager, Keshav Kumar, was convicted of destroying evidence and freed on time served in 2003. The Delhi High Court ordered Sharma’s release on 21 December 2018.

Case file

Convicted
Victim
Naina Sahni, 29, Congress worker, general secretary of the Delhi Youth Congress girls’ wing
Where
Shot at a flat on Mandir Marg near Gole Market; body found in the tandoor at Bagiya Bar-be-Que, Ashok Yatri Niwas, Ashoka Road
When
Night of 2 July 1995; fire seen at about 11 pm
Found by
Constable Abdul Nazir Kunju and Home Guard Chander Pal, on patrol
Convicted
Sushil Sharma, Delhi Youth Congress president: murder. Death sentence (trial court, 2003), confirmed by the Delhi High Court (2007), commuted to life by the Supreme Court (2013)
Also convicted
Keshav Kumar, restaurant manager: destroying evidence, seven years (2003); acquitted of murder. Three men accused of sheltering Sharma were acquitted
Now
Sharma was released on the Delhi High Court’s order on 21 December 2018, after about 23 and a half years in jail. Nothing is pending in the murder case
In this story · 14 parts
  1. 2 Jul 1995Smoke over Ashoka Road
  2. 1992–1995Two young Congress workers
  3. 2 Jul 1995What happened in the flat
  4. 10 Jul 1995Eight days on the run
  5. 12 Jul 1995The doctor who found no bullet
  6. 7 Nov 2003Eight years in court
  7. Nov 2003The manager who fed the fire
  8. 19 Feb 2007“Not a cremation ground”
  9. 8 Oct 2013The Supreme Court spares his life
  10. 21 Dec 2018Out of Tihar
  11. 2021The constable nobody thanked
  12. Part 12What the case changed
  13. Part 13The myths, checked
  14. Part 14Our take
Part 1

Smoke over Ashoka Road

Ashoka Road, New Delhi

It was Sunday, 2 July 1995, a little before midnight, in the heart of New Delhi. Two men were walking their night beat near Ashok Yatri Niwas, a big government-run hotel on Ashoka Road, a short walk from Connaught Place. One was Abdul Nazir Kunju, a constable from Connaught Place police station. The other was Chander Pal, a home guard.

Then they heard a shout. According to the case the courts later accepted, someone cried hotel main aag lag gayi: the hotel is on fire. Smoke and flames were rising from Bagiya Bar-be-Que, an open-air restaurant on the lawn in front of the hotel.

The two men went in. By the clay oven, a man was pushing wood into a fire that was far too big for cooking. He was Keshav Kumar, the restaurant’s manager. He told them he was a Congress worker, the Supreme Court later recorded, and was “burning old banners, posters and waste papers of the party”.

Kunju did not believe him. More police came, and the hotel’s security staff. The two later told the court that the man who ran the restaurant had been there by the oven, and that he slipped away before more police arrived. When the flames died, the police found what was inside the tandoor: the burnt body of a woman.

A cook working at a cylindrical clay tandoor oven
A tandoor is a deep clay oven, heated with wood or charcoal, found in restaurant kitchens across north India. The case made the word infamous.Photo: Quadell · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The man who had run away was Sushil Sharma, the president of the Delhi Youth Congress. The woman, police would soon say, was his wife.

Part 2

Two young Congress workers

Gole Market, New Delhi

Naina Sahni was 29. She was a Congress worker too: the general secretary of the girls’ wing of the Delhi Youth Congress. Maxwell Pereira, the senior police officer who oversaw the case, later wrote that before turning thirty she had graduated, earned a pilot’s licence, held a party post and run a successful boutique. He wrote that she was planning to move to Australia.

Sushil Sharma had come up through student politics and was a rising name in the capital’s Congress. He also ran the Bagiya restaurant, under a licence from ITDC, the government tourism company that owned the hotel.

The prosecution said the two had married in secret and, from 1992, lived together as husband and wife in a government flat, 8/2A Mandir Marg, near Gole Market. Most people did not know they were married. The prosecution said Naina wanted to make the marriage public, and Sushil did not.

There was a third person in the story the courts heard. Matloob Karim was Naina’s old classmate and a fellow Congress worker. The prosecution said Sushil suspected the two were close, and could not bear it. Karim gave evidence for the prosecution. The defence called him unreliable.

The people in the case

  • Naina Sahni29Congress worker, general secretary of the Delhi Youth Congress girls’ wing. Killed on 2 July 1995
  • Sushil SharmaPresident of the Delhi Youth Congress. Convicted of her murder (2003, upheld 2007 and 2013). Released in 2018
  • Keshav KumarManager of the Bagiya restaurant. Convicted of destroying evidence (2003); acquitted of murder
  • Abdul Nazir KunjuConstable on night patrol who found the fire. Key prosecution witness
  • Chander PalHome guard on patrol with Kunju. Key prosecution witness
  • Matloob KarimNaina’s friend and fellow Congress worker. Identified her body; prosecution witness
  • Maxwell PereiraSenior Delhi Police officer who oversaw the inquiry; later wrote a book on it
  • G.P. TharejaAdditional Sessions Judge who tried the case
Part 3

What happened in the flat

Gole Market, New Delhi

Nobody else was in the flat that night, so what happened there comes from the evidence the courts pieced together. This is the prosecution’s account, which the trial court, the High Court and the Supreme Court all accepted.

On the evening of 2 July, Sushil came home and found Naina on the phone. He believed she was talking to Matloob Karim. The prosecution said that after 9:30 pm he fired three times with his licensed .32 revolver. Two bullets hit Naina. The third went into a piece of plywood near the air conditioner.

He wrapped the body, the prosecution said, carried it to his Maruti car and drove off. Pereira’s book says he first thought of the Yamuna, but the road near the ITO bridge was too crowded. So he turned towards the one place that was his: the restaurant on Ashoka Road.

Witnesses placed his car at the restaurant gate between about 9:45 and 10:15 pm. Pereira’s book says Keshav sent the staff away. The courts found that the body was carried to the tandoor and the fire lit, with Keshav’s help. Soon after, Kunju saw the smoke.

The round colonial-era market building at Gole Market, New Delhi
Gole Market in central New Delhi, photographed in 2014. The couple’s flat was on Mandir Marg, close by.Photo: Ronit Bhattacharjee from Gurgaon, India · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

When police searched the flat on 4 and 5 July, they found five cartridges, a lead bullet, and the plywood with a bullet hole in it. The Maruti turned up abandoned on Malcha Marg, near Gujarat Bhawan, on 4 July. There was dried blood in the boot.

Part 4

Eight days on the run

Bangalore

While the police were pulling a body from the oven, Sushil Sharma was spending the night at Gujarat Bhawan, a state government guest house in Delhi, with an official named D.K. Rao. That is what the prosecution said, and the courts accepted it.

Then he kept moving. On 3 July, the prosecution said, he took a taxi to Jaipur. On 4 July he flew to Bombay, and then on to Madras. There, a sessions court gave him anticipatory bail, a court’s promise not to arrest him. The Delhi Police went to the Madras High Court and got it cancelled.

By then he was in Bangalore. On 10 July 1995, eight days after the fire, Bangalore police took him into custody; many reports describe it as a surrender. In a room at the Pai Vihar Hotel, police found a briefcase. Inside was a .32 Arminius revolver, its licence and four live cartridges.

His own story was different. He told the trial court he had been in Tirupati from 1 to 6 July and in Madras on 7 July. The courts found that alibi false, and treated his flight as evidence against him.

Part 5

The doctor who found no bullet

New Delhi

Here the case almost went wrong. The body was so badly burnt that Naina’s own parents could not identify it. Matloob Karim identified her on 5 July.

The same day, Dr Murari Prasad Sarangi carried out the first post-mortem at Lady Hardinge Medical College. He found no bullet. He gave a provisional cause of death of shock from injuries before death, and thought the burns came after. A doctor at Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital had also seen no gunshot wounds.

Pereira later said the first doctor “jumped the gun” by telling reporters the body had been chopped up. That story ran everywhere, and it would never quite die.

So a second post-mortem was ordered. On 12 July, a board of three doctors, led by Dr Bharat Singh with Dr T.D. Dogra and Dr S.K. Khanna, examined the body after X-rays. The X-rays showed metal in the skull and the neck. The doctors took out two lead bullets. Their finding: death by a gunshot to the head, before the fire.

The ballistics lab, the CFSL, matched the two bullets, and the bullet from the flat, to the revolver found in the Bangalore briefcase. Blood of group B, Naina’s group, was found in the flat, in the car boot and on a sheet at the restaurant.

One question was left: was this really Naina? Scientists at the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology in Hyderabad compared DNA from the body with her parents, Jaswant Kaur and Harbhajan Singh. It matched. The body was their daughter.

Why the second post-mortem mattered: without it, the record would have said a woman died of injuries and was burnt. With it, there were two bullets, a gun, and a name on the gun licence.

Part 6

Eight years in court

New Delhi

The police filed their chargesheet on 27 July 1995, less than a month after the fire. Then the trial began, and it went on for eight years. The prosecution called 85 witnesses. The judge, Additional Sessions Judge G.P. Thareja, called seven more himself.

Keshav Kumar did something unusual. He admitted, in court, to the charge of destroying evidence: he said he had put the body in the tandoor at Sushil’s command.

Sushil Sharma fought every link in the chain. His lawyers argued it hard, and their points deserve to be heard as they made them.

The trial: both sides

What the prosecution said (and the courts accepted)

  • Kunju and Chander Pal saw Sharma at the restaurant while the body burned, and he ran when the police came.
  • He then fled through Jaipur, Bombay and Madras to Bangalore, and gave a false alibi about Tirupati.
  • The two bullets from the skull and neck, and the bullet in the flat, came from his licensed revolver, found in his briefcase.
  • Naina’s blood group was found in the flat, the car boot and at the restaurant, and DNA proved the body was hers.
  • Motive: he suspected her friendship with Matloob Karim, and resisted her wish to make their marriage public.

What Sharma’s defence said

  • The case rested only on circumstances, and the chain had gaps: neighbours heard no shots and there was no trail of blood.
  • The first post-mortem and a hospital doctor found no bullet. The defence said the bullets could have been planted between 5 and 12 July, and nothing proved the skull was untouched.
  • The Bangalore recovery was doubtful. Sharma said police had taken the revolver from his home in Maurya Enclave.
  • He loved her and their marriage was known to family and neighbours, so there was no motive; Matloob Karim was unreliable.
  • Media coverage and the police case amounted to an unfair trial, and in any event this was not a ‘rarest of rare’ case for death.

Outside, feelings ran high. Members of the BJP’s local women’s wing disrupted hearings that week, the Tribune reported, and the court complex was put under heavy security.

On 3 November 2003, Judge Thareja found Sushil Sharma guilty of murder, and of conspiring to destroy the evidence. On 7 November he sentenced him to death. He called it a ‘rarest of the rare’ case, the Supreme Court’s test for the death penalty, and ordered that Sharma be “hanged by the neck till dead”. The sentence needed the High Court’s confirmation.

Three men accused of sheltering Sharma while he was on the run were acquitted. The judge also ordered that D.K. Rao be prosecuted for harbouring him; the High Court later set that order aside.

Part 7

The manager who fed the fire

Tihar Jail, Delhi

Keshav Kumar is the quiet figure in this story. He did not pull the trigger. The trial court found too little evidence that he was part of any plan to kill. But he was the man Kunju found pushing wood into the oven, and the man who told the police a story about party posters.

The trial court acquitted him of murder and of conspiracy to murder. It convicted him of destroying evidence, read with conspiracy, and gave him seven years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹10,000.

By then he had already spent about eight years in jail waiting for the verdict, more than his whole sentence, so he walked free. He told reporters he would ask for compensation for the extra time, the Tribune reported. He did not appeal his conviction, the Supreme Court noted later, and the state did not appeal his acquittal on murder.

His confession helped the story make sense, but the High Court ruled it could not be used against Sharma, because it was never proved in evidence against him. What became of Keshav Kumar after 2003, we could not find in any reliable report.

Part 8

“Not a cremation ground”

New Delhi

Sharma appealed. The Delhi High Court heard the appeal together with the death sentence, which it had to confirm or reject. The bench was Justice R.S. Sodhi and Justice P.K. Bhasin, the same two judges who had convicted Manu Sharma in the Jessica Lal case two months earlier.

On 19 February 2007, they dismissed his appeal. They believed Kunju and Chander Pal, saying the two could not have cooked up such a story. They rejected the claim that police had planted bullets in the body. And on the oven, they were blunt.

Bagia restaurant was not a cremation ground.Delhi High Court, 19 February 2007

The judges were fair to the first doctor, too. Judge Thareja had made harsh remarks about Dr Sarangi. The High Court said those remarks were unjustified and ordered them struck out: bullets, they explained, could be seen only on an X-ray.

They confirmed the death sentence. They called the killing planned, not a sudden act; they said Naina was a helpless woman who trusted him, that burning the body showed extreme depravity, and that Sharma had shown no remorse. They saw “no chances of this kind of a person reforming himself”.

Part 9

The Supreme Court spares his life

New Delhi

Sharma went to the Supreme Court. His appeal waited years for a hearing. Senior advocate Jaspal Singh argued that the case rested on circumstances and was not ‘rarest of rare’. The prosecution said both lower courts had been right to order death.

The Supreme Court of India building in New Delhi seen from outside its wall
The Supreme Court of India, where three judges upheld the conviction but set aside the death sentence on 8 October 2013.Photo: Legaleagle86 at English Wikipedia. · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

On 8 October 2013, three judges gave their answer: Chief Justice P. Sathasivam, Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai, who wrote the judgment, and Justice Ranjan Gogoi. On guilt, they agreed with everyone before them. The chain of evidence, they said, was complete and pointed only to Sharma.

On the sentence, they disagreed. The murder, they wrote, was “the outcome of strained personal relationship” and “not an offence against the Society”. Sharma had no criminal record. Naina was not a helpless woman under his control. He had been extremely possessive, but also “deeply in love with the deceased”. He had wept when shown her body at the mortuary. He was his old parents’ only son, and he had spent more than ten years in the death cell.

The brutality alone would not justify death sentence in this case.Supreme Court of India, 8 October 2013

Could he change? The state had brought no evidence that he would not. “We do not think that that option is closed,” the judges wrote. They turned the death sentence into life in prison, which they said meant the whole of his remaining life, unless the government granted remission under the law.

The judges also quietly killed the most famous detail of the case. The medical evidence, they said, “does not establish that the dead body of the deceased was cut”, and no chopper was ever found.

Readers’ poll

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction but replaced the death sentence with life in prison. What is your view?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 10

Out of Tihar

Tihar Jail, Delhi

Life in prison did not end at the gates of Tihar for ever. In Delhi, a Sentence Review Board, chaired by the Delhi Home Minister with members from the jail, the police and the home department, decides when life prisoners may be let out early. Its guidelines, Sharma’s lawyers said, allow release after 20 years for a life prisoner with a single offence, and after 25 years for the most heinous crimes.

Sharma was already out on parole for a time in 2015, granted by the Delhi High Court. In jail he was moved to a semi-open prison and worked on building tasks, and the jail, probation and welfare officers backed his reform. But the Review Board kept saying no, and the Lieutenant Governor agreed with it.

The main gate of Tihar Jail in Delhi
The main gate of Tihar Jail. Sushil Sharma was held there from 1995 until December 2018.Photo: Zuck28 · CC0 · Wikimedia Commons

So he went back to court. His petition said he had served 23 years and six months, or 29 years counting remission. The Delhi government’s lawyer, Rahul Mehra, said the Lieutenant Governor had seen every record and accepted the Board’s view.

On 21 December 2018, Justices Siddharth Mridul and Sangita Dhingra Sehgal ruled for Sharma. The Board’s refusal, they said, “suffers from vice of arbitrariness and illegality”. They also struck down the Lieutenant Governor’s unexplained approval of it, and ordered his release at once. Sharma, now 56, walked free after more than 23 years.

Twenty-three years, step by step

  1. 2 Jul 1995Naina Sahni is shot in the Mandir Marg flat; her body is found burning in the tandoor at Bagiya that night.
  2. 5 Jul 1995Matloob Karim identifies the body; the first post-mortem finds no bullet.
  3. 10 Jul 1995Sushil Sharma is taken into custody in Bangalore.
  4. 12 Jul 1995The second post-mortem finds two bullets in the skull and neck.
  5. 27 Jul 1995Police file the chargesheet.
  6. 3 Nov 2003Trial court convicts Sharma of murder; Keshav Kumar of destroying evidence.
  7. 7 Nov 2003Death sentence for Sharma; seven years for Keshav, who walks free on time served.
  8. 19 Feb 2007Delhi High Court confirms the death sentence.
  9. 8 Oct 2013Supreme Court upholds the conviction and commutes death to life.
  10. Sep 2015Delhi High Court grants Sharma parole.
  11. 21 Dec 2018Delhi High Court orders his release; he leaves Tihar.
  12. 2021The Wire reports Kunju has won his long fight over promotion benefits.

Readers’ poll

Sushil Sharma left jail after about 23 and a half years, over the objection of the Delhi government. What is your view?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 11

The constable nobody thanked

Every version of this story starts with Abdul Nazir Kunju. He saw the smoke. He did not believe the story about posters. He gave the statement on which the case was first registered, and he stood by it in court for years.

He says the case cost him. He told the Millennium Post in 2013 that his station officer had cancelled his two days’ leave on 2 July, a day after his wife gave birth. He said Sharma threatened him during the investigation. “I was not afraid,” he said.

He was promoted out of turn to head constable, on an ad hoc basis, from 4 July 1995, a Rajya Sabha answer later recorded. He told the Post it came with a raise of ₹5, and that a later pay revision left juniors earning more than him. He said he got “no rewards or benefits” and was harassed by his own department. These are his own claims; we found no reported reply from the Delhi Police.

He took voluntary retirement in 2012 and left Delhi. He kept fighting for the seniority his promotion should have carried. In 2021, The Wire reported that the Supreme Court had ordered the Delhi Police to give him all benefits of seniority from his promotion, with arrears from 1995. It had taken 26 years.

Part 12

What the case changed

Forensics. The tandoor case is still taught as a lesson in what a second look can do. A burnt body, a first post-mortem that found no bullet, and an X-ray that found two. Then DNA, still new in Indian courts, to prove who the dead woman was. Pereira said he had to teach the trial judge about DNA evidence. Reports still single the case out for its DNA evidence and its second post-mortem.

Politics. The case broke under a Congress government at the Centre, with a general election less than a year away. Pereira, quoted by The Quint, went as far as saying it “helped bring down India’s national government” in 1996. That is his view; Congress lost that election for many reasons. When Sharma was convicted in 2003, wire reports said the case was still embarrassing the party ahead of state elections.

Influence. Were strings pulled? The record shows a politician who got a night’s shelter at a state guest house, anticipatory bail far from Delhi, and a restaurant security guard the Supreme Court said had been “won over” by the defence. It also shows the limits of all that. The Madras bail was cancelled. Pereira said police named Sharma as the suspect on day one, and that his political friends kept away from him, afraid of being linked. No court found that anyone powerful protected him.

Words. The case gave Delhi a phrase. For years afterwards, any killing in which a body was destroyed was compared to it. When police arrested a man for the murder of Shraddha Walkar in 2022, newspapers went straight back to 1995.

Readers’ poll

How much do you think politics shaped the way this case went?

Tap an answer to see what other readers think.

Part 13

The myths, checked

Twenty years of retelling turned the tandoor case into legend. Some of what people ‘know’ about it is wrong.

Myth 1

He chopped her body into pieces

Why people believed it

The first doctor told reporters the body had been cut up, and newspapers at home and abroad repeated it for years. Even reports of his release in 2018 said it.

What the record shows

The Supreme Court said in 2013 that the medical evidence did not show the body was cut, and no chopper was found. Pereira said police “took pains to tell everybody that there was no chopping”. Former DCP Aditya Arya said the marks came from the heat and from a rod used to push the body in.

BustedBusted. The courts found no cutting.

Myth 2

It was the first case in India to use DNA evidence

Why people believed it

The DNA test made headlines, and law blogs still call the case a forensic first.

What the record shows

DNA fingerprinting was used in an Indian court years earlier, in a paternity case from Kerala in the late 1980s, with evidence from Lalji Singh of the same Hyderabad lab. The tandoor case was one of the first famous murder cases to rest on it.

BustedNot the first. One of the most famous early ones.

Myth 3

It was India’s first ‘tandoor murder’

Why people believed it

The press called it the Tandoor murder, and the name stuck so hard that later cases are measured against it.

What the record shows

The label is a newspaper name for this one case. We found no reliable record that settles whether a body had ever been put in a tandoor before. What is clear is that it was the first such case to shake the whole country.

Still openA famous label, not a proven first.

Myth 4

The first post-mortem proved there was no shooting

Why people believed it

Sharma’s defence leaned on it: the first doctor and a hospital doctor found no bullet.

What the record shows

The bullets were deep in the skull and neck and showed only on X-rays. The second post-mortem found them, ballistics matched them to his revolver, and every court accepted that she died of a gunshot.

BustedBusted. The first look simply missed them.

Myth 5

A rich politician got off lightly

Why people believed it

A death sentence became life, and life became 23 years.

What the record shows

He was convicted by three courts and spent more than 23 years in jail, over ten of them under a death sentence. Pereira said he served longer than anyone else in Tihar. His release came from a High Court ruling against the Delhi government, which wanted him kept inside.

Still openA matter of opinion. The record shows a long sentence, not an easy one.

Myth 6

Naina’s family fought to have him hanged

Why people believed it

It is what people expect of a murdered woman’s family.

What the record shows

The Supreme Court noted that no member of her family came forward to give evidence against him. Her brother and sister-in-law said they were under an obligation to him. Arya said her family refused to take her body after the post-mortem.

On the recordOn the record: the family stayed silent.

Part 14

Our take

Strip away the legend and the tandoor case is a story about small things. A shout in the dark. A constable who did not believe a story about posters. A doctor’s X-ray that saw what an eye could not. A blood group in a car boot. Each one alone proves little. Together, three courts said, they left no room for doubt.

It is also a story about how India punishes. Two courts said this man deserved to die. A third said a crime born of a jealous marriage, by a man with no past record, did not. Twenty-three years after the fire, another court said the state could not keep him locked up just by saying no.

Naina Sahni was 29, with a pilot’s licence and plans to start again in another country. The case is known by the name of an oven. She was a person first.

Test yourself

7 questions on this story

  1. Who spotted the fire at the Bagiya restaurant?

  2. What did Keshav Kumar tell the policemen he was burning?

  3. What did the second post-mortem find that the first one missed?

  4. In which city was Sushil Sharma taken into custody on 10 July 1995?

  5. Which lab’s DNA test confirmed that the body was Naina Sahni’s?

  6. Why did the Supreme Court replace the death sentence with life in 2013?

  7. Which two Delhi High Court judges confirmed the death sentence in 2007, two months after convicting Manu Sharma in the Jessica Lal case?

Quick check: which came first?

Two moments from this story. Tap the one that happened first.

 

Questions people ask

What was the Tandoor murder case?

The 1995 killing of Naina Sahni, a Delhi Congress worker. The courts found her husband, Youth Congress leader Sushil Sharma, shot her at their flat and then tried to burn her body in the tandoor of a restaurant he ran on Ashoka Road, New Delhi.

Who found the body?

Constable Abdul Nazir Kunju and Home Guard Chander Pal, who were on night patrol, saw flames at the Bagiya restaurant at about 11 pm on 2 July 1995 and found the body in the tandoor.

Why was there a second post-mortem?

The first post-mortem found no bullet. A board of three doctors examined the body again on 12 July 1995 after X-rays and removed two bullets from the skull and neck, which ballistics experts matched to Sharma’s revolver.

Was Naina Sahni’s body chopped into pieces?

No, according to the Supreme Court. It said in 2013 that the medical evidence did not establish that the body was cut, and the investigating officers said the same.

Why did the Supreme Court not hang Sushil Sharma?

In October 2013 it said the murder came from a strained personal relationship, was not an offence against society, and that he had no criminal record and could still reform. It upheld his conviction and gave him life in prison.

Is Sushil Sharma in jail now?

No. The Delhi High Court ordered his release on 21 December 2018, ruling that the Sentence Review Board’s refusal to free him early was arbitrary and illegal. He had served about 23 and a half years.

What happened to Keshav Kumar?

The restaurant manager was acquitted of murder but convicted of destroying evidence in 2003 and given seven years. He had already spent about eight years in jail, so he was freed. We found no reliable report of his life after that.

How we wrote this. Researched from the Supreme Court’s 2013 judgment, the Delhi High Court’s 2007 judgment and the reports listed below, and written in our own words by the TrendingPunjabi desk with the help of an AI model. Sushil Sharma was convicted of murder by three courts; Keshav Kumar was convicted only of destroying evidence; the three men accused of harbouring Sharma were acquitted, and D.K. Rao was never tried. What happened inside the flat is the prosecution’s account as the courts accepted it; Sharma denied it. Details from Maxwell Pereira’s book and from Constable Kunju’s interviews are their own accounts and are labelled as such. Sources differ on some points: Naina’s age (29 or 30), who ordered the second post-mortem and who led it (we follow the Supreme Court), the times on the night, and whether Sharma surrendered or was arrested in Bangalore. Many early reports said the body was cut up; the Supreme Court found no evidence of that. Polls are readers’ opinions, not findings.

Sources

  1. Indian Kanoon: Sushil Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), Supreme Court, 8 October 2013
  2. Indian Kanoon: State v. Sushil Sharma, Delhi High Court, 19 February 2007
  3. The Tribune: Death for Sushil Sharma; seven years for Keshav (8 November 2003)
  4. Dawn: Ex-Congress leader sentenced to death
  5. Al Jazeera: Death for India’s Tandoor killer
  6. The Irish Times: Congress politician shot wife and tried to burn her body (AFP)
  7. LiveLaw: Supreme Court commutes death penalty of Sushil Sharma in Tandoor murder case
  8. Millennium Post: ‘Tandoor killer no threat to society’
  9. Millennium Post: ‘Naina Sahni’s body was not chopped into pieces’
  10. Millennium Post: Witness claims continuous harassment from Delhi police, despite role in solving case
  11. The Wire: Delhi cop, key witness in sensational ‘Tandoor case’, secures justice after 26 years
  12. ThePrint: The wrong theory that survives 23 years after Delhi’s infamous tandoor murder case
  13. DailyO: Excerpt from The Tandoor Murder, by Maxwell Pereira
  14. Open: Most foul: review of Maxwell Pereira’s The Tandoor Murder
  15. Business Standard (PTI): Tandoor murder case: Delhi HC releases Sharma on parole
  16. ThePrint (PTI): In tandoor murder case, High Court orders Sushil Sharma’s release
  17. The Tribune: Tandoor murder case: HC orders release of convict Sushil Sharma
  18. LiveLaw: Delhi HC orders immediate release of Tandoor murder case convict after 23 years
  19. The Quint: In Shraddha’s killing, Delhi reminded of Tandoor murder: what happened in 1995?
  20. Down To Earth: Genetic fingerprinting catches on
  21. Wikipedia: Murder of Naina Sahni
PromotedGTA 5 FULL GAME WALKTHROUGH PART 2 🔥 | Epic Missions & Gameplay | Gsran GameGsran gameWatch

Paid placement · Promote your video

All Crime Files stories · All news